Willi Plett, RW
- 6’3”, 205 lbs
- Stanley Cup Finalist (1988)
- Best percentage scores: 52, 46, 41, 35, 33, 32
- Six 20-goal seasons, two with 30+
- Not a big PP scorer, he was better at ES: Four 20+ ESG seasons, one 30+
- Best ES points percentages: 63, 62, 49, 48, 45, 39
- Solid 46 points in 83 playoff games
- 203 NHL Fights, 32nd all-time
- 25-20-53 record in limited results at
www.dropyourgloves.com
loh.net said:
Plett didn't start playing organized hockey until age 12 although once he caught on, he fell in love with the game. But by the time he made the junior level with the St. Catharines Blackhawks of the OHA, he lacked finesse and aggressiveness. As a result, his coach, Hap Emms, demoted him to a tier-two level club.
From that point forward, Plett began to barge around the ice, playing roughhouse hockey. It didn't do too much to raise his stock in the draft, but the Atlanta Flames eventually picked him up in the 4th round in 1975.
Plett tried his hand with the Flames for a couple of games before heading to Tulsa for tutelage from a coach who could understand his needs, former NHL enforcer Orland Kurtenbach.
The following season, Plett started the year in Tulsa, but then got the call to join the Flames where he made a surprise splash, netting 33 goals in 64 games. By season's end, he had secured the Calder Trophy as the league's best rookie.
Clearly Willi Plett was a big, tough player who thrived on aggressiveness and fighting. But he brought much more to the rink than a set of brass knuckles. He could play the game. In 1980-81, with the Calgary Flames, Plett scored a career-high 38 goals.
But not long after his transition to the Minnesota North Stars, in 1982-83, his role was changed from a bellicose goal scorer to exclusively that of a pugilist. As a result his point production fell way off and as he approached age 30, he simply lost the desire to strut around the rink talking tough and fighting. He noted that as he got older, it was as though he became too mature to act that stupid.
In 1987, the Bruins picked him up in the Waiver Draft. With a lineup replete with tough guys, Plett was finally able to assume a role as a support player. With his former nemesis, Terry O'Reilly as coach, Plett enjoyed team leadership that understood his situation as the aging gunslinger. As such, the Bruins made a solid run in the playoffs, making it to the finals, only to be shut out by the Edmonton Oilers. It was Plett's final game in the NHL.
Joe Pelletier said:
Willi was never much of a skater but was a hard worker and a team player. He used his muscles in and around the goal cage and was hard to move away from the slot. Willi had a very short junior career and only played a handful of games for Niagara Falls and St. Catherines. He was regularly criticized for not using his size to his advantage. Despite that, someone from the Atlanta Flames scouts saw him and liked what they saw. The Flames drafted him with their 4th choice, 80th overall in 1975.
Willi started his professional career in CHL for Atlanta's farm team, Tulsa Oilers. Plett is quick to credit head coach Orland Kurtenbach for making him into an NHL player. Kurtenbach was a similar player to Plett. Both got off to late starts in their hockey careers, and both made it in the NHL due to their size and willingness to use it. It was Kurtenbach who convinced Plett to charge into corners aggressively, be the immovable object in front of the net, and be willing to battle with all comers.
Willi scored 20 goals in his first 35 games, while fellow NHL rookie Don Murdoch of NY Rangers (who scored 16 goals in his first 16 games), to create one of the most interesting races in the history of the Calder Trophy as the rookie of the year. While Murdoch was slumping during the second half of the season, Willi continued playing strong two way hockey for the Flames. Willi finished his rookie season with 33 goals and 56 points in 64 games and won the Calder Trophy.
Willi had some stellar seasons in Atlanta / Calgary. His best season goal and point wise came during the 1980-81 season. He scored 38 goals and had 68 points. He was a fan favorite in both Atlanta and Calgary because of his aggressive player. Yes, Plett was a feared heavyweight NHL fighter, but, save for his plodding skating, he was also an extremely good player.
"His greatest plus is his size. No one can forget he is out there running around. And my biggest defenseman can't handle him in front," suggest Atlanta coach Fred Creighton. "He had one ability," says Cliff Fletcher, long time Atlanta/Calgary GM and one of Plett's earliest believers, "In all sorts of heavy traffic he could get the puck, snap off a shot real quick and most times it was pretty accurate. And he was big. I had to like that."
Willi spent five relatively anonymous seasons in Minnesota. Despite once scoring 4 goals in a single game while in Minny, his role seemingly was reduced to that of pugilist more than all around player. The old Norris division featured some bitter rivalries and many brawls. His goal totals dwindled while his fighting majors and penalty minute totals increased. As he aged, the intimidating, ornery warrior found he less and less enjoyed the game… The veteran only played one year in Boston before retiring after the 1987-88 season. It almost became a very memorable season. He helped Boston reach the Stanley Cup final, where they lost to the strong Edmonton Oilers team.
Willi played hardnosed hockey all the time and finished his 13 year NHL career with 2572 penalty minutes in only 834 regular season games, still ranking him among the all time leaders in PIMs. Willi could not only fight but also put the puck in the net. He had 437 points (222 goals and 215 assists) in 834 regular season games and 46 points (24 goals and 22 assists) in 83 playoff games. In addition, he retired with 466 NHL playoff penalty minutes, once an NHL record.
No, Willi Plett was never in the running for the Lady Byng Trophy for gentlemanly play, In 1980, he landed a huge bodycheck on Philadelphia's Paul Holmgren, and the ensuing fight touched off a bench--clearing brawl. In 1982, he was suspended for eight games for a sticks-winging incident with Detroit goalie Greg Stefan. In the 1984 playoffs, he went after Blackhawks goalie Murray Bannerman after being speared, touching off a bench-clearing brawl. The next season, Plett and Detroit's Greg Smith began to fight as the teams went to their dressing rooms after the first period, The ensuing brawl included a wrestling match between coaches Glen Sonmor and Nick Polano. In 1988, he received a five-minute head-butting penalty during a fight-fest between Boston and Quebec in which 219 minutes in penalties were doled out.
THN yearbook 1978 said:
The odds against such a happening (Plett storming back to win the Calder following a call-up) are immense, but the blonde, bony visaged RW did just that. He did it by scoring 33 goals – and more importantly, making the Atlanta Flames first line a going concern.
“Plett put life into Eric Vail and Tom Lysiak,” reports Flames coach Fred Creighton. “You could say he was the spark that made Atlanta take flame. Lysiak wasn’t himself and who could blame him? (after being ripped off by his agent) and Vail was coming back from an injury riddled year. Both of guys had been there before, but they needed Willi’s zest and desire to get them going.”
The odds Plett surmounted are unbelievable: His junior coach told him he wasn’t aggressive enough. Creighton didn’t think he had enough skills to score consistently. Being born in Paraguay doesn’t help the average young man become a hockey player… and even though he moved to Canada as a young child, he didn’t take up hockey until he was 12.
…in the OHA, his work didn’t please coach Paul Emms. “If somebody would put a mean streak in you, Willi, you might make a pretty good hockey player.” Plett didn’t like it, but finally got the message and now admits: “Emms was right. For my size you could say my lack of hitting was a weakness. I came to the conclusion that if I didn’t hit anyone, I wouldn’t go very far.
Don Murdoch (Calder Runner-up) isn’t the two-way hockey player that Plett has made himself become. Neither is Roland Eriksson, the Minnesota north stars center, who led all rookies in scoring with 69 points. Nor is Paul Gardner, who had 59 and did well on the point during power plays. The impact Plett made in the NHl is shown by the fact that he was only 4th in the rookie point parade. “Plett is simply a better hockey player than those guys,” said King Clancy. “He does more things well than any of them. Most of them play offense, more than defense.”
“Not hitting enough wasn’t the only complaint that Emms had. I couldn’t really shoot the puck good enough to suit him either.”… his sudden upsurge in shooting ability came from participating in normal practice sessions and one on one shootouts… when he was ripping the NHL apart last year, Creighton was openly doubtful he could keep it up. “He doesn’t have wonderful moves and he doesn’t deke anybody. His shot is just so-so. It’s not as good as Eric Vail’s.” He feels Plett’s emergence as something of a fair-haired hero helped the crowd. “He charges into the corners, bangs people along the boards and goes into the slot looking for a mixup. The crowd likes that. He gets garbage goals, because he stands boulderlike in the slot. “I aim for the corners when I get the puck in the slot, and I think I do it more than most hockey players. I think, because of lacrosse, I go for spots someone else might not even think about trying for.”
Plett worries that he is starting to think too much about goals and not enough about defense. “I hope winning the Calder doesn’t mean I have to score too much in order to keep things going. I feel if I worry about scoring, I won’t do the rest of my job. I know that some of my goals last year were scored when the goalie was messed up. I don’t want to be in the penalty box all the time. I think the balance between scoring and being in the box can become a real problem to me.”
“I would take his problems in a minute,” emphasized Ted Harris, the North Stars’ coach. “His greatest plus is his size. No one can forget he is out there running around. And my biggest defensemen can’t handle him in front.” Plett may not be a fast or skillful skater, and he doesn’t have half the polished moves of a tactician like Eriksson, but he has size, guts and accuracy with the puck in front of the net – and the ability to make thigns happen in the corners. He served 124 minutes in penalties but most were “good” penalties.
Last season Fletcher, sensing that something extra was needed on the Vail-Lysiak line, kept pushing for Plett to polish his skills and make the big team.
Complete Handbook Of Pro Hockey 1978 said:
One of the new breed of big, strong rookies who can score goals, check and play aggressively when needed… strong skater and outstanding in corners… plays the game hard.
OPC 1977-78 said:
possesses a strong wrist shot and fine scoring ability, he’s acknowledged as one of the Flames’ aggressive players.
Complete Handbook Of Pro Hockey 1979 said:
Wild Willi… strong and tough and by far the club leader in PIM… throws some of the hardest checks around… despite rough and tumble style, he’s a quiet, friendly guy.
Toronto Star said:
BEST FIGHTER:
1. Stan Jonathan, Barry Beck (tie)
3. Willi Plett
4. Terry O’Reilly
5. Clark Gillies
OPC 1979 said:
A favourite with the Omi fans for his rough and tumble style of play. Has a winning attitude.
Complete Handbook Of Pro Hockey 1980 said:
returned to form what won him Calder trophy… throws hard check… also throws hard punch… can let temper get in the way of game… recovered booming shot after returning from leg injuries… uses size as well as anyone.
OPC 1981 said:
A strong skater who’s not shy of the corners, Willi throws some of the hardest checks in the NHL… has scored key goals.
Complete Handbook Of Pro Hockey 1981 said:
once a feared checker, needs to be motivated… gives opponents the willies… tough checker, tougher fighter…
Complete Handbook Of Pro Hockey 1982 said:
size and strength make him important policeman type on a fairly placid team… devastating forechecker who bowls people over… seldom challenged to fisticuffs because of his size and strength.
THN Yearbook 1983 said:
Plett waged a battle with ex-Flames coach Al MacNeil last season and had an off-year as a result… Nanne is obviously banking that Plett can be inspired to play his physical brand of hocky that will enable some of the Stars’ smoothies more room to operate.
Complete Handbook Of Pro Hockey 1983 said:
Acquired to add some muscle… inconsistency has been the consistent factor of his career… big, tough, good skills and a strong shot… one of the league’s most feared cornermen and fighters.. size and strength mean he’s challenged only by the foolhardy.
THN Yearbook 1984 said:
Plett, who gives the Stars some much-needed muscle…
Complete Handbook Of Pro Hockey 1984 said:
One of the NHL’s toughest along the boards and in the corners… a feared fighter…
THN Yearbook 1985 said:
Players such as… Willi Plett will not allow the stars to be outmuscled.
THN Yearbook 1986 said:
Then there’s Plett. He has the toughness that every team covets, but many won’t touch. While he may be overrated by some standards, he still has a lot of belief in himself, and he proved that last season in the playoffs. Plett awoke from the doldrums and was a quality performer for his team. It’s the annual Trivial Pursuit question whether he will be the giant for the Stars in the sleeping or scoring department.
Hockey Scouting Report 1986-87 said:
Plett is a good skater, surprisingly so for a man of his size. He has good balance that makes him somewhat agile and he’s also equipped with a little bit of speed, too. However, like most big forwards, he has some difficulty with his turns. He handles the puck fairly well and that’s because the opposition gives him a lot of room when he’s on the ice. But Plett can move well with the puck in front of him. He likes to use his teammates but his hands are a little tough and he has neither the touch nor the anticipation to be an exceptional playmaker. Plett doesn’t have much of a shot and will do almost all of his scoring from the front of the net, deflecting pucks or tucking in rebounds. Defensively, he was horrendous last year. He wanders from his position in the defensive zone, leaving openings, and doesn’t follow his check back through center ice.
Plett is a very physical player – and he uses his body very effectively. He doesn’t hit as often as he used to, but Plett still has the strength and force to be a punishing hitter. He also has superior upper body strength and can outmuscle anyone along the boards, though he often doesn’t know what to do with the puck after he gets it. When he plants himself in front of the opposition net Plett is almost impossible to move and he does a good job of pestering the goaltender to distraction. Because of his size, Plett also makes an effective screen for his teammates and he is more than willing to take any punishment heading his way for the privilege of standing in the crease. Willi is a good fighter, but mostly unchallenged nowadays. Plett’s value comes when he opens space for his teammates, something he does every time he’s out on the ice. Of course, his ability to intimidate the opposition has long been his value.
Hockey Scouting Report 1987-88 said:
somewhat agile, but not very quick… hands are too tough to be even a fair playmaker… defensively no better than adequate… obviously the physical game is his strength… intimidation is a role he is growing tired of… don’t misunderstand, Plett has no conception that he is Wayne Gretzky. Rather, 11 years of police work has taken its toll… but he will continue to fill his role and, though he doesn’t get off the bench in the fast games, Plett comes to play every night. He is also a team leader in the dressing room.
Hockey Scouting Report 1988-89 said:
he’ll need plenty of time and space to put home a rebound… struggles defensively against a speedy forward… good fighter, but doesn’t have the heart for it anymore… he’s effective as a deterrent, but his time is almost up. After all, what do you do with a fighter who doesn’t want to fight?
FIGHTS PLUS SCORING!
Here is a list of the 15 forwards who are currently in the top-50 all-time for NHL fights and are in any way arguably AAA draft material or better:
Name | class | GP | Fights | rank | win% | Points | Playoff Points
Tiger Williams | light-heavyweight | 962 | 332 | 2 | 0.435 | 513 | 35
Bob Probert | heavyweight | 935 | 302 | 4 | 0.686 | 384 | 48
Marty Mcsorley | heavyweight | 961 | 274 | 9 | 0.646 | 359 | 29
Kelly Buchberger | light-heavyweight | 1182 | 257 | 13 | 0.37 | 309 | 24
*** ********** | middleweight | 1083 | 249 | 15 | 0.516 | 336 | 13
***** ****** | middleweight | 720 | 237 | 18 | 0.627 | 268 | 26
Rick Tocchet | light-heavyweight | 1144 | 230 | 21 | 0.731 | 952 | 112
Dale Hunter | middleweight | 1407 | 227 | 23 | 0.506 | 1020 | 118
Terry O'Reilly | heavyweight | 891 | 223 | 24 | 0.642 | 606 | 67
Randy McKay | light-heavyweight | 932 | 216 | 25 | 0.508 | 363 | 43
Al Secord | heavyweight | 766 | 210 | 28 | 0.473 | 495 | 55
Willi Plett | heavyweight | 834 | 203 | 32 | 0.526 | 437 | 46
Brian Sutter | light-heavyweight | 779 | 200 | 35 | 0.64 | 636 | 42
**** ******* | heavyweight | 535 | 192 | 40 | 0.703 | 200 | 20
Darren McCarty | light-heavyweight | 758 | 174 | 48 | 0.63 | 288 | 49
Tocchet, Hunter,O’Reilly and Sutter are ATD players who are obviously much better than Plett. But after that, it gets pretty muddy. Al Secord is always an ATD player, and though he’s better than Plett, it’s a pretty marginal edge. Tiger Williams is typically in the ATD but his prime scoring numbers are identical to Plett’s and he was a more frequent, but not as effective fighter. That comparison could go either way. McSorley’s numbers include over half a career as a defenseman, he’s definitely better. Beyond that, there is no one who combines Plett’s goals and pugilistic ability. Not McCarty, not McKay, not Buchberger. I always wanted Plett as a 4th line MLD player (described him as a “goon who could play”), but could never get him. In the AAA, he’s much more than just a “goon who can play”.
Forwards with 300 points and 2500 PIM
1. Pat Verbeek: 1063/2905
2. Dale Hunter: 1020/3565
3. Rick Tocchet: 952/2972
4. Gary Roberts: 910/2560
5. Tiger Williams: 513/3966
6. Willi Plett: 437/2572
7. Bob Probert: 384/3300
8. Matthew Barnaby: 300/2562
Seasons with 40+ points and 200+ PIM
Dale Hunter | 11
Tiger Williams | 6
Terry O’Reilly | 5
Gerard Gallant | 4
Bob Probert | 4
Scott Stevens | 4
Pat Verbeek | 4
Laurie Boschman | 3
Chris Chelios | 3
Dave Manson | 3
Willi Plett
|
3
Gary Roberts | 3
Al Secord | 3
Brian Sutter | 3
Keith Tkachuk | 3
Rick Tocchet | 3
8 players | 2
34 players | 1