Proposal: Taylor Hall vs. Evander Kane?

[CantHaveTkachev]

Kane is a finisher and brings an edge and swagger to his game the Oilers sorely missed...and a tough SOB

Hall is a low% volume shooter despite some bite to his game

Kane all day

 

[fuswald]

Haven't seen Hall play for ages so have to go with Kane.

 

[ManofSteel55]

Obviously Hall at his peak was a step above what Kane has ever been, but for today, I take Kane. Hall is slowing down and his blazing speed was always part of what made him great. He is no longer the impact player he was, while Kane brings some elements to his game that do make him that type of impact player. Kane's goal scoring and physicality are the difference between these two now.