Value of: Shea Theodore

[Mallard]

Give it a rest. It's unfortunate he had to be played so much and he really got exposed. Why trade a young, cheap, ELC, expansion exempt guy when we don't have to? Play him more in the AHL next year and maybe on a very sheltered role on the Ducks next year.

How many points did he have against Calgary again? He's only 21.

 

[Brock Radunske]

Pleasure doing business with you.

Pretty sure the Leafs already gave you Leipsic...

 

[fmrdh]

13OA

Theodore+ ?

 

[Huffer]

13OA

Theodore+ ?

I think if the Jets were interested it would be to keep the 13th and use a forward prospect like Petan or Dano instead.

 

[phillipmike]

The willingness to dump a top prospect for nothing because of a rough playoffs as a 21 year old is amazing lol

Well there are people who think a 19 year old defensemen with 6 NHL games (all in the playoffs) is already better than Morgan Rielly.

 

[crazychimp]

Lol, he made one really big mistake but you guys won in the end so it's okay. He made some great plays in the Calgary series, looked great on the PP, played decent in the second round too, so yeah I'd take him for sure.

 

[Zegs2sendhelp]

Jeeze, one bad play and Boom

I'm not opposed to moving him if the trade makes sense, but I'm not going to sell low on him because of a mistake in an important game. Sometimes young players try to do much when they are in high pressure situations, and I think that is one of theodores problem that he occasionally trys to do too much.


The reason id be willing to move him is because I think Montour and Larsson are better than him... and I think Mahura is going to be knocking on his door step soon also.

 

[WhatWhat]

This seems like a crazy overreaction but if he would actually be available I'm sure Dallas would be interested. Does Shore interest you?

 

[Officer Rod Farva]

Kovalchuk.

 

[dracom]

Kovalchuk.

Kovalchuk is easily becoming the most overrated trade piece on here.

 

[leafsfuture]

Leafs all over this if he actually is on the block.

Even though he is a LD, he has a cannon of a shot that we could use

 

[Zegs2sendhelp]

Leafs all over this if he actually is on the block.

Even though he is a LD, he has a cannon of a shot that we could use

I feel like that would make most sense, leafs have a ton of forwards/prospects with talent and in need of dmen of any skill set really.

And Toronto and Anaheim have good trade history with each other

 

[bernmeister]

Theodore, Mountour and 2018 Duck 1st
for
Stepan
reasonable cap dump is acceptable for balance of 6.5 vs 2 ELCs

 

[WhatTheDuck]

Theodore, Mountour and 2018 Duck 1st
for
Stepan
reasonable cap dump is acceptable for balance of 6.5 vs 2 ELCs

I couldn't possibly think of an idea more opposite of what Anaheim should be looking to do. Absolutely terrible.

 

[TopShelfWaterBottle]

Theodore, Mountour and 2018 Duck 1st
for
Stepan
reasonable cap dump is acceptable for balance of 6.5 vs 2 ELCs

Lol love the sarcasm here

 

[MMC]

Ok, now that I've cooled off, everything I've previously said in this thread is null and void. Let's start over.

 

[KaseMeOutside]

Terrible thread and alot of terrible ideas

 

[Oscar Lindberg]

Ok, now that I've cooled off, everything I've previously said in this thread is null and void. Let's start over.

Flaky move

Commit to your overreactions

 

[KaseMeOutside]

Theodore, Mountour and 2018 Duck 1st
for
Stepan
reasonable cap dump is acceptable for balance of 6.5 vs 2 ELCs

Hell no. Why are we trading so much for someone who'd be our no. 3 center?

Montour is going nowhere.

 

[DingDongCharlie]

Just get him off the team.

You can have Griffin Reinhart for him.

 

[dracom]

You can have Griffin Reinhart for him.

Lol, no way. You can keep your bust.

 

[KasperTheGrittyGhost]

Nyquist for Theodore + 2nd + Cap Dump

 

[DingDongCharlie]

Nyquist for Theodore + 2nd + Cap Dump

Would you really sell that low on Nyqvist? I don't think Anaheim could/would be able to take the cap dump anyways

 

[eternalbedhead]

Theodore, Mountour and 2018 Duck 1st
for
Stepan
reasonable cap dump is acceptable for balance of 6.5 vs 2 ELCs

Absolute hell no from Anaheim. We do nothing to help our expansion draft problem (and actually make it worse by trading Vatanen's likely replacement; not to mention someone who has mightily impressed so far), we have absolutely no need for Stepan, and we're massively overpaying to boot.

 

[Kalv]

Ok, now that I've cooled off, everything I've previously said in this thread is null and void. Let's start over.

Haha, props for admitting this


If Theo doesn`t improve defensively I really can see him being available at some point - depending how Larsson will look next year. But Theo is a 21 year old defenseman, youngest on his team, yet still leading the blueline in scoring with respectable 7p in 11g and has played every single playoff game averaging 18+ minutes.
That is not that bad.
Montour, being almost as young and not putting up as many points but has looked much more impressive though, maybe that makes Theo look a bit worse. And yes, that turnover in game 7, there is just no excuse for that, it was hooooorible