Speculation: Sharks 2015-2016 Roster Talk: Rumors, Roster, Proposals. Part I

Status
Not open for further replies.

Fistfullofbeer

Moderator
May 9, 2011
30,441
9,109
Whidbey Island, WA
It really is hard to believe the special teams are so bad with the personnel available.

Seriously. I don't know what is going on at home.

We are 0/21 on the PP (last place) and 5/19 on the PK (25th in the league).

The road numbers while not great are more middle-of-the-pack. 9/48 on the PK (12th) and 9/45 on the PP (14th). We have played only 8 games at home as opposed to 13th on the road, so a good home-stand may even things out but I do think that the coaching staff needs to focus a little bit more on special teams.

All that being said, it is really commendable that the team is in 1st place with the bad ST play and not having Couture.
 

Juxtaposer

Outro: Divina Comedia
Dec 21, 2009
48,044
17,794
Bay Area
The special teams are not that bad, chill. They're getting ****ed by bad percentages. They're a little below average league-wise in terms of shot rates. Couture being back should put the 1PP back on track, and he's also an elite penalty killer. That'll help. If it's still not good enough, make sure the #6 RHD you acquire at the deadline is PP-capable.

Mediocre special teams is really not bothering me right now.
 

do0glas

Registered User
Jan 26, 2012
13,271
683
The special teams are not that bad, chill. They're getting ****ed by bad percentages. They're a little below average league-wise in terms of shot rates. Couture being back should put the 1PP back on track, and he's also an elite penalty killer. That'll help. If it's still not good enough, make sure the #6 RHD you acquire at the deadline is PP-capable.

Mediocre special teams is really not bothering me right now.

I know deboer said he wants to win 5v5 but when games are so even in the playoffs the 1 or 2 pps you get might be the decider. So I hope they start to work on it a bit. I do agree that the percentages are low. Entries and passing look good though
 

bigwillie

Registered User
Jul 14, 2006
7,031
10
Portland, OR
What kind of PP specialists might be available at the deadline? I'd be OK flipping Wingels for a defenseman if he can QB a 2nd unit powerplay effectively and not be a tire fire 5v5.
 

hohosaregood

Banned
Sep 1, 2011
32,455
12,707
From what I can tell from stat checking is that you can get by in the playoffs with a garbage PP. PK matters a lot more but even then, neither of them really correlate that strongly to playoff victory.
 

bigwillie

Registered User
Jul 14, 2006
7,031
10
Portland, OR
I will also say that there were years when the Sharks had stellar special teams, and one common knock against them on these boards was that they were too reliant on the PP to generate offense to be successful in the postseason, where man-advantage opportunities are at a greater premium. I do hope DW and PDB do some work to improve special teams, but I am very happy that they've been able to put up wins having such miserable PP/PK rates.
 

hockeyball

Registered User
Nov 10, 2007
21,557
913
I will also say that there were years when the Sharks had stellar special teams, and one common knock against them on these boards was that they were too reliant on the PP to generate offense to be successful in the postseason, where man-advantage opportunities are at a greater premium. I do hope DW and PDB do some work to improve special teams, but I am very happy that they've been able to put up wins having such miserable PP/PK rates.

I agree, this is a silver lining.

Conspiracy theory time, they are doing this on purpose to force the team to play 5vs5 better :P
 

spintops

Registered User
Sep 13, 2013
1,649
860
CUgj05UUkAE_oVm.jpg:large
 

Nolan11

Registered User
Mar 5, 2013
3,236
334
I'm bored, so have been looking over hockeyscap and pondering what ifs.....

Braun + 2nd to the Isle for Hamonic
Hamonic + Brown (cap) to the Wild for Spurgeon + Granlund
Then Couture to Preds for Seth Jones + 2nd

end up with:

Karlsson - Thornton - Pavs
Marleau - Hertl - Ward
Donskoi - Granlund - Wingels
Nieto - Tierney - Smith
Torres - Goodrow

Vlasic - Seth Jones
Martin - Burns
Dillon -Spurgeon
Mueller - Tennyson

Jones
Stalock

OK, off to actual work now, but fun pondering.....
 

Gilligans Island

Registered User
Jul 2, 2006
11,186
313
SF/Bay Area
What kind of PP specialists might be available at the deadline? I'd be OK flipping Wingels for a defenseman if he can QB a 2nd unit powerplay effectively and not be a tire fire 5v5.

Marek Zidlicky & Okposo for Wingels and ?

One can dream.

I agree the 3rd pairing RD who can be a PP QB is the spot to focus on. Wait for Couture to return to assess the special teams.
 

hockeyball

Registered User
Nov 10, 2007
21,557
913
Tyson Barrie anyone?

Yah, he'd be ideal, seems unlikely though unless Colorado is stupid (which is possible).

Braun for Barrie might work for both teams though. Colorado shores up their defense, we improve our offense, etc. Rather keep Braun if possible though, otherwise the net gain isn't all that great, more of a sideways move.
 

matt trick

Registered User
Jun 12, 2007
9,808
1,437
Marek Zidlicky & Okposo for Wingels and ?

One can dream.

I agree the 3rd pairing RD who can be a PP QB is the spot to focus on. Wait for Couture to return to assess the special teams.

& Hertl....maybe Braun more realistically, but that I think they'd pass on Braun, unless there was a Hamonic trade which would bring them a forward to replace Okposo. Okposo would cost a ton.

Zidlicky would be okay, Demers would actually be ideal, but no chance dallas trades him.

Spurgeon, Barrie, or Byfuglien would be incredible, but all will cost a lot of assets, starting with a 1st (and someone will move their 2016 1st for them) or top 6 forward (yes, better than Wingels).
 

Gilligans Island

Registered User
Jul 2, 2006
11,186
313
SF/Bay Area
Yah, he'd be ideal, seems unlikely though unless Colorado is stupid (which is possible).

Braun for Barrie might work for both teams though. Colorado shores up their defense, we improve our offense, etc. Rather keep Braun if possible though, otherwise the net gain isn't all that great, more of a sideways move.

I'd prefer Barrie, too, but price would be much higher than a rental like Zidlicky.

If the Avs want Braun, then maybe but we'd still have a hole in our 3rd RD since Barrie would play top 4 minutes.

& Hertl....maybe Braun more realistically, but that I think they'd pass on Braun, unless there was a Hamonic trade which would bring them a forward to replace Okposo. Okposo would cost a ton.

Zidlicky would be okay, Demers would actually be ideal, but no chance dallas trades him.

Spurgeon, Barrie, or Byfuglien would be incredible, but all will cost a lot of assets, starting with a 1st (and someone will move their 2016 1st for them) or top 6 forward (yes, better than Wingels).

Yeah, those 3 are much more enticing now and in the long run but cost would be higher. I was looking for a rental only (cheaper price).
 

EmergencyExit

Registered User
Aug 9, 2011
1,373
34
Toronto
I'd take Russel. If you're talking rentals then he's not a bad guy to improve that third pairing. I'm interested about the comments those Flames fans are making. If true it would mean he can't handle tougher competition.

I don't know if Lovejoy would be enough of an upgrade over Tennyson to justify his cost (however minor).
 

DonskoiDonscored

Registered User
Oct 12, 2013
18,642
9
There is no need to talk about defensive improvements and rentals at the moment. Lovejoy is only an upgrade on the rotating cast of #7's we have, but once Joakim Ryan gets called up that won't even be the case.

Russell would be ok, but there's no reason to depart with assets right now. Let's wait until the deadline.
 

EmergencyExit

Registered User
Aug 9, 2011
1,373
34
Toronto
Is Ryan ready for the show? Don't know anything about him besides his statline in the AHL.

I like the discussion of upgrades just for the sake of spitballing names. I agree however that they should let the team keep playing before spending assets to upgrade.
 

do0glas

Registered User
Jan 26, 2012
13,271
683
Is Ryan ready for the show? Don't know anything about him besides his statline in the AHL.

I like the discussion of upgrades just for the sake of spitballing names. I agree however that they should let the team keep playing before spending assets to upgrade.

Agreed. If deboer loosens the reigns on vlasic and Braun...
 

Gilligans Island

Registered User
Jul 2, 2006
11,186
313
SF/Bay Area
There is no need to talk about defensive improvements and rentals at the moment. Lovejoy is only an upgrade on the rotating cast of #7's we have, but once Joakim Ryan gets called up that won't even be the case.

Russell would be ok, but there's no reason to depart with assets right now. Let's wait until the deadline.

Rental deals are done at the TDL, not after the first quarter of the season. No one above mentioned deals done now. You're assuming we meant now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad