Second Official MLB Discussion Thread

[td_ice]

Voted just now.

 

[Winger for Hire]

I had an interesting and kind of difficult time doing the overall rankings.

But I do feel that the head to head matchups will be super interesting and less difficult to do.

 

[td_ice]

I had an interesting and kind of difficult time doing the overall rankings.

But I do feel that the head to head matchups will be super interesting and less difficult to do.

Same.

 

[Tecumseh]

I voted a few days ago.

 

[Elvis P]

I voted a few days ago.

Those are the new White Sox season tickets. Thanks. I have asked Fenway to post the standings when he has time.

 

[Winger for Hire]

Those are some pretty sweet tickets... but where's the Disco Demolition one?

 

[Elvis P]

Those are some pretty sweet tickets... but where's the Disco Demolition one?

Good question. I just wanna thank all for doing such a great job drafting. It makes the constant editing of the OP much less tedious and much more fun.

 

[Elvis P]

I'm having some bad luck with the voting. Please send your votes to Pwnasaurus. If he doesn't post the standings by 8:00 PM CT Thursday, my team is dropping out of the playoffs and send them to me. Thank you very much for your cooperation and patience.

 

[bluesfan94]

I'm taking votes; so far I have three ballots.

Edit: nevermind, looks like pwn said yes First

 

[NJDevs26]

I only sent mine to Pwn...I hope there weren't PM problems with the other league too, maybe that's why so few ballots came in?

 

[td_ice]

I will send votes to bluesfan as well. To cover all bases.

Sent.


Now bluesfan has 4 votes. Just needs two more.

No sense you dropping out Wrigley. No one is in that much of a hurry that another day to get things squared away will matter.

 

[Elvis P]

I'm taking votes; so far I have three ballots. ...

Sounds good. I sent mine to you twice. Post the standings and I'll make the threads.

I will send votes to bluesfan as well. To cover all bases. Sent. Now bluesfan has 4 votes. Just needs two more. No sense you dropping out Wrigley. No one is in that much of a hurry that another day to get things squared away will matter.

Sounds good. The teams are so close I will be voting on matchups.

 

[bluesfan94]

I don't have NJDevs votes and I know he sent them to pwn. I'll pm him and post results in the morning, around 9 Central. The standings are close so I think this is only fair.

 

[Elvis P]

I don't have NJDevs votes and I know he sent them to pwn. I'll pm him and post results in the morning, around 9 Central. The standings are close so I think this is only fair.

Sounds good.

 

[NJDevs26]

I responded to him this morning. If he didn't get it I give up

 

[Winger for Hire]

 

[Elvis P]

Iron Fist is out!

 

[Elvis P]

Dummy Hoy

Position Players​

|

Lineup​

C: Deacon White | 1. Rabbit Maranville
1B: Jake Beckley | 2. Johnny Evers
2B: Johnny Evers | 3. Pete Browning
3B: Arlie Latham | 4. Charlie Keller
SS: Rabbit Maranville | 5. Deacon White
LF: Pete Browning | 6. Arlie Latham
CF: Charlie Keller | 7. Elmer Flick
RF: Elmer Flick | 8. Jake Beckley
Bench: RF/1B Babe Herman
Bench: SS/3B Bobby Wallace
Bench: 2B/LF Red Schoendienst
Bench: 3B/SS/2B Joe Dugan
Bench: OF Dummy Hoy
Bench: LF/1B Monte Irvin​

​

Possible fun MLB team. My leadoff hitter is a rabbit and one of my player's first names is Dummy! (I'm not implying bench players such as Babe Herman wouldn't start, so please don't be offended)

 

[bluesfan94]

Alright standings:
1. Pittsburgh Pirates
2. St. Louis Browns
3/4. Great Lake Loons
3/4. Toledo Mud Hens
5. London Tigers
6. Washington Wild Things

 

[td_ice]

Dummy Hoy

Position Players​

|

Lineup​

C: Deacon White | 1. Rabbit Maranville
1B: Jake Beckley | 2. Johnny Evers
2B: Johnny Evers | 3. Pete Browning
3B: Arlie Latham | 4. Charlie Keller
SS: Rabbit Maranville | 5. Deacon White
LF: Pete Browning | 6. Arlie Latham
CF: Charlie Keller | 7. Elmer Flick
RF: Elmer Flick | 8. Jake Beckley
Bench: RF/1B Babe Herman
Bench: SS/3B Bobby Wallace
Bench: 2B/LF Red Schoendienst
Bench: 3B/SS/2B Joe Dugan
Bench: OF Dummy Hoy
Bench: LF/1B Monte Irvin​

​

Possible fun MLB team. My leadoff hitter is a rabbit and one of my player's first names is Dummy! (I'm not implying bench players such as Babe Herman wouldn't start, so please don't be offended)

Doing research for this draft, I noticed there were a lot players named Heinie.

Elmer Flick sounds like a character from Green Acres.

 

[Winger for Hire]

I expected nothing less

 

[Tecumseh]

For what it's worth, Winger, I had your team ranked third (second if you exclude ranking my own team). Honestly ranking these teams, 1-6 are arguably interchangeable

 

[Winger for Hire]

For what it's worth, Winger, I had your team ranked third (second if you exclude ranking my own team). Honestly ranking these teams, 1-6 are arguably interchangeable

Appreciate that and I was tongue in cheek-ing that a bit. It was hard to separate the teams because each had their own flavor that I had a hard time ranking. I was honestly expecting to be low because I stuck myself with a more modern approach

H2H a lot of things can happen with these teams.

 

[Elvis P]

Alright standings:
1. Pittsburgh Pirates
2. St. Louis Browns
3/4. Great Lake Loons
3/4. Toledo Mud Hens
5. London Tigers
6. Washington Wild Things

The Loons will be 3rd and the Mud Hens 4th for seeding purposes. The Pirates and the Browns get a bye, because their GMs are Kryptonians. The threads are up. Everyone has until 01:42 PM CT Tuesday to vote. You can vote on your own series to encourage and reward voting.

 

[NJDevs26]

Glad I hit the two slot, but yeah a lot of these series are going to come down to matchups and taking a better look at the teams.

For clarification, these are five-game series or seven game series in the first round?