Hmm. Spitballing here. I don't want there to be more than 10 categories though, that gets annoying. Going with celebs/known names as the trophy names just because I'm unimaginative.
Most positive poster- The Oprah Winfrey award
Most negative poster- The Justin Bieber trophy
Funniest poster - The Ryan Reynolds award
The most unbearable poster who gets a pass because they're cheering for the same team
- The Jar Jar Binks trophy
Most 'advanced stats' poster (corsi, fenwick, the works) - Gregory House award
Most alcoholic beverage mentions (not factually, vote on who could be the one) - 'The southern stereotype' trophy