I'm going to say this and it probably won't be the most popular. But it seems to be looking true for the most part.
Most, not all, but it seems most of the majority who are unsure of Marner are the older generation of posters. I hate to label, but...
Back in the day, smaller players didn't make it. Usually the bigger boys would make it, even if they were void of skill, they could still rough and tumble their way around. Or if they were smaller, they were all crash and bangers like Clark.
The small and skilled guy rarely made it, so naturally, the older generation would be weary. Times have changed and its time to get on board.
Again I hate to label, but it seems most who preferred Hanifin or another selection are older posters here.