Marner and Nylander vs Horvat and Boeser

[nowhereman]

I'm actually surprised at how little love Horvat is getting here. He's probably the best player of the bunch.

I'll go with the Canucks duo but by the slimmest of margins.

 

[The Winter Soldier]

Horvat is the best player out of the 4 today. Voted Canucks.

I am glad someone is watching the games. He is, he turned the corner last year, and he is turning out to be a very valuable piece as a 2 way top 2 Center.

 

[Tkachuky]

I am glad someone is watching the games. He is, he turned the corner last year, and he is turning out to be a very valuable piece as a 2 way top 2 Center.

He is a beast. Always a threat when playing the Flames. Impressed with the Canucks this year. I think everyone (fans/league) went in with low expectations and the players are playing with confidence and are doing really well.

 

[Halla]

55/45 so far. looks like its pretty close.

Both teams should be happy with their guys

 

[Halla]

Yeah I mean I'm not saying Marner isn't good, I just think Pettersson's absolute ceiling is slightly higher, while it's probably more likely that Marner will reach his. Yeah, the Virtanen pick sucks and Juolevi was confusing then and I'd have preferred any of Keller, Tkachuk or Sergachev, but he's been lighting it up this season so it stings a little less.

I couldn't believe they passed on Tkachuk at the time. Seemed like he woulda been a perfect fit.

Tkachuk-Horvat-Boeser seems like a perfect like. Gritty agitator that can score, two way C , Sniper.

 

[34]

Leafs duo AINEC

Horvat is not in the same level as the other 3.

 

[member 105785]

I couldn't believe they passed on Tkachuk at the time. Seemed like he woulda been a perfect fit.

Tkachuk-Horvat-Boeser seems like a perfect like. Gritty agitator that can score, two way C , Sniper.

Yea, when they said London Knights I thought it was a slam dunk, then there were confused tears shed.

 

[Snippit]

Leafs duo AINEC

It is close. You clearly don't watch the Nucks guys.

But I still gotta go with the Leafs duo by a hair

 

[Ace of Hades]

Leafs duo AINEC

Horvat is not in the same level as the other 3.

What?

Horvat is the best player of the four players involved.

 

[34]

It is close. You clearly don't watch the Nucks guys.

But I still gotta go with the Leafs duo by a hair

I watch. Boeser has looked fantastic in a sample size so far. If he keeps it up the Nucks have a solid player on their hands. Horvat is average.

 

[34]

What?

Horvat is the best player of the four players involved.

Right.

 

[Ace of Hades]

Right.

Is on a team's number one center spot facing top line competition and putting up 8 goals and 16 points in 21 games, and isn't one dimensional must be "average".

 

[dellzor]

Leafs duo AINEC

Horvat is not in the same level as the other 3.

Why am I not surprised it's a Leafs fan saying this ROFL

 

[34]

Number one center facing top line competition and putting up 8 goals and 16 points in 21 games, and isn't one dimensional must be "average".

Ok. If you say so.

 

[Ace of Hades]

Ok. If you say so.

Don't let facts get in your way.

 

[Snippit]

I watch. Boeser has looked fantastic in a sample size so far. If he keeps it up the Nucks have a solid player on their hands. Horvat is average.

Horvat's average..

I now know how seriously I should take your future posts. Thanks, dude.

 

[Snippit]

Why am I not surprised it's a Leafs fan saying this ROFL

He also thinks Marner/Matthews/Nylander will get a combined 21M.

Some guys just do not have an opinion that's even worth addressing.

 

[Halla]

Is on a team's number one center spot facing top line competition and putting up 8 goals and 16 points in 21 games, and isn't one dimensional must be "average".

you clearly don't watch the leafs at all if you think Marner or Nylander are one dimensional.
not gonna argue that Horvat isn't better defensively, but he also isn't close offensively.

Marner: 0.77ppg
Nylander 0.70ppg
Horvat: 0.53ppg

waiting for a laughable response about how anyone can put up points on the leafs

 

[Ace of Hades]

you clearly don't watch the leafs at all if you think Marner or Nylander are one dimensional.
not gonna argue that Horvat isn't better defensively, but he also isn't close offensively.

Marner: 0.77ppg
Nylander 0.70ppg
Horvat: 0.53ppg

waiting for a laughable response about how anyone can put up points on the leafs

Never said either of those players are one dimensional, so your post is pretty much moot. I was referring to Horvat there.

 

[Halla]

He also thinks Marner/Matthews/Nylander will get a combined 21M.

Some guys just do not have an opinion that's even worth addressing.

curious how much you thin the trio are gonna get?

I'd be pretty surprised if Marner/Nylander don't get 6m each.
Ehlers got 6m with 64pts, Patrnak 6.66 with 70pts

Matthews is a different story. He is gonna get close to Mcdavid. 11M is my guess

 

[Halla]

Never said either of those players are one dimensional, so your post is pretty much moot. I was referring to Horvat there.

this is a thread comparing players, so when you say a guy "and isn't ....." it pretty much implies that the other guys are, otherwise you woulda just said he is strong defensively.

 

[Snippit]

curious how much you thin the trio are gonna get?

I'd be pretty surprised if Marner/Nylander don't get 6m each.
Ehlers got 6m with 64pts, Patrnak 6.66 with 70pts

Matthews is a different story. He is gonna get close to Mcdavid. 11M is my guess

Matthews - 11.5M
Nylander - 6.5M
Marner - 6.5M

Just my guess - but 23M at the absolute minimum with your estimates.

I think all 3 will put up upwards of 70 points or close to it

 

[Knight53]

Nucks duo. Horvat being a centre that produces makes him the most coveted out of the 4.

The other 3 will probably be 60-70 point wingers throughout their careers

 

[Ace of Hades]

this is a thread comparing players, so when you say a guy "and isn't ....." it pretty much implies that the other guys are, otherwise you woulda just said he is strong defensively.

Or you can just ask and clarify in what I meant instead of assuming.

 

[135ace]

Horvat>Nylander (but it's close) then there's a massive drop down to Marner and another pretty big drop to Boeser. Overall it's the Leafs duo.