I think people are being a little over dramatic about vatanen.... But Perry deserves all the insults he is getting.
I have to say, that's a bit amusing to hear from you. You were practically screaming to dump Fowler after the playoffs, and were saying that Fowler hadn't evolved at all as a defenseman. You went on a rant about how he never steps up, how he's terrible despite being a world class skater, he's soft, his shot was terrible, etc... You want to talk about being over dramatic? Stones. Glass houses.
Vatanen is being paid $5m, and outside of a couple of good games, he's been hugely underwhelming. The dude just hasn't proven he can be in a top 4 role and be an impact player for us. Sure, Perry is getting paid much more, and his performance stands out that much more as a result, but Vatanen still looks like he didn't bother training in the off-season. I think the frustration surrounding his play is justified.
He can still turn things around, and I don't see anyone suggesting otherwise, but this is a pretty unacceptable start for him, especially when you consider the rather large pay day he just received. He needs to wake the **** up, and start earning that contract. The days of him getting 3rd pairing match ups, and being spoon fed offensive opportunities is past. It would be over dramatic to call Vatanen trash, or to say that he should be traded based on 26 games. Saying he's been underwhelming, and at times bad, or that he hasn't been playing to the level of his new contract isn't over dramatic. Even saying that if this continues, that he might find himself in trade talks isn't over dramatic. Especially if it's true, and it probably is. On a list of players Anaheim needs to be (much) better, he's a comfortable #2 on the list. The gap between him and #3 is rather large.