BK
"Goalie Apologist"
Well of course people are in two camps. Why wouldn't they be? Some may say 'no big deal, they'll flip the switch'. Others, like me, will say possibly pizzing away a 20 point lead to drop to a WC spot in 6 weeks is a big deal.
As for last year, not a comparison. The Wild were on an epic horseshoe run due to the insane play of a goalie that their coach didn't rest. That caught up with them in the playoffs. The Wild, however, did the Hawks a huge favor by knocking out STL. Imagine NASH/STL/ANA as the run to the SCF.
But the 'this year v. last year' comparisons fall down. Last year the Hawks were coasting and more importantly, one of the best players in the NHL (and this year's MVP) was out injured. That's simply not the same thing this year.
I know I'm verbose. I do so to try to explain my positions rather than just spouting them. I'd like someone in the 'hey, its the Hawks. They always do this and always flip the switch' camp to explain to me specifically why that will happen with THIS roster and reference specific issues - roster gaps, special teams, one line carrying the team all year, etc. Or are the Hawks just going through a horrible stretch because a 4th line center was out and because another guy is making $4.5M playing in Rockford?
I see it from both sides. Yes Kane was out and the team was coasting but you are ignoring the other side of how things were last year.
Similarities:
- Star player is out (Crow and Kane)
- New additions to the team still gelling and struggling when they join the team (I would argue Ladd is the one struggling, Flash and Weise have played well)
- Team getting hot and closing on our playoff spot (Wild last year and Nashville this year, Dubynk got hot last year and Rinne is hot this year)
- Hossa missing games
- Toews/Keith coasting
Differences:
- Seabrook struggling
- Missing JO
- Darling has been inconsistent