The whole conversation has gotten toxic. Yes, lives are more important than the economy. No, the economy isn't completely unrelated to quality of life.
No one would argue to shut down the economy for 1 life. Everyone would shut down the economy for 1 billion lives. The answer lies somewhere in the middle, and the right conversation has nothing to do with equating lives to dollars (although there are idiots on both sides that pretend that's the dichotomy).
This remains the best article I've seen on the subject:
If we actually do this, if we shut down everything for a few weeks, give hospitals enough breathing room, lower the R0 to a reasonable number, it's not out of the question that we can start opening stuff back up in a few weeks. It's irresponsible of Trump to start bringing up dates like Easter (Trump irresponsible?!?!), but the alternative extreme of "no one leave your houses for 4 months except grocery store workers and farmers" probably isn't feasible either. There's a reason even the good governors are shutting things down a week, two weeks at a time. Trump loves to feed false hope based on nothing, and that was the Easter comment. But outside of a few doofuses, no one is saying "we need to just sacrifice old people for the economy because we like money." There's a real discussion to be had here about what we do about the real economic hardships that come from shutting everything down for a month at a time, and that discussion is always changing based on how much or how little we have this thing under control.
It's very fashionable to shit on the US and it's not like the response has been anywhere close to ideal (or with ideal timing), but the fact is that practically the whole country is inside. The whole country has implemented some level of safeguard in one way or another. Hank's right, the lack of coordination amongst 50 states with their own little mini governments is a weakness when compared to China, but all things considered the response hasn't been completely mangled. I'm inside, you're inside, every restaurant, gym, and movie theater in the country is shut down. The correct stuff is being done. Not only that, but our "curve", as bad as it looks, looks very very similar to China's in the first weeks of its first cases as well. Our "death" curve (when they're plotted on "deaths since day of 10th death" or whatever) has never risen above theirs. They were successful in flattening it, likely more successful than we will be given the centralized government, but we're still "ahead" of them and very strict orders are coming in every day (Atlanta for example just implemented stay at home for the whole city for two weeks, except for grocery trips). Testing is picking up, I've heard several stories of people 2-3 degrees away from me that were able to simply inquire and get tested. The parameters for who's eligible will continue to widen as more tests become available, which is happening more and more. We keep ramping this up, and sure, not as fast as we should've or to many people's liking, but we're getting there.