Brian Lee (#9-2005) vs Luc Bourdon (#10-2005)

[TruGr1t]

I don't think anyone considers Lee better than Bourdon, just a better prospect. Obviously Bourdon is at least a tad better right now because he's at a different stage in his development. I mean, I think Kaygorodov is better than Crosby today but there's no doubt in my mind as to who I'd rather have.

I'm gonna have to agree with Matt here. I just don't see them being in different stages developmentally. Now they ARE completely different players so comparing them is fundamentally difficult, but these are guys around the same age range who have played relatively similar levels of hockey. Bourdon is maybe a bit more physically mature at this point, but that has in itself led to the type of game he plays. I am in no way knocking Lee as I have seen him play maybe a grand total of three times.

anyone see Boudorns hit last night. Holy *****, hit him so hard, his helmet came off. seriously, anyone have a link for the highlites.?

These are actually really good highlights (the best I've found online) courtesy of BCTV. Forgive the sports desk guy, he totally sucks. Also watch for Conklin's TERRIBLE goaltending and the Winchester hit. People are making a big deal about that hit, but Bourdon's almost looks bigger. He threw maybe one or two other giant hits in this game.

Highlights Here

 

[NyQuil]

Is there a Sens fan who thinks Bourdon is better or a Nucks fan who thinks Lee is better?

If so, come out of the woodwork.

 

[Mizral]

I"ve never seen Lee.

However, forgive my mistrust of QMJHL defensemen. Despite liking what I see in Bourdon, I don't see the #1/2 defenseman upside.

 

[Dominator13]

Yes, because every scouting staff contains 3 people....

no but they were head of staff just like in montreal now, there the ones who make disicions along with the GM.Montreal had the lowest depth chart of prosepects to first a year ago.