STL fan in MN
Registered User
- Aug 16, 2007
- 7,227
- 4,234
Yeah that’s fair. I am sick and tired of seeing the Blues look lackadaisical to start every single game, and then after the game give the same non-answers to the media as to why. Berube definitely was running out of ideas, so it will be interesting to see how we look with a new coach.I feel like the criticism with Berube's firing is that both the compete from the players was lost and the system Berube put in place just doesn't work. Aside from their 0-10-1 start to the season, the Sharks have gone 8-7-2 with a hilariously mediocre team when compared to the Blues. I don't think the Blues should be a playoff team, but I expect better compete out of these guys and if Armstrong thinks the message has gotten stale/the system has shown not to work, then you fire him
Coached Sault Ste. Marie for 3 years; 2 division titles, named OHL and CHL Coach of the Year in 2018. Lost in the OHL Finals in 2018. 2 years with San Antonio (AHL), never made the playoffs. 2 years + current with Springfield (AHL); lost in the Calder Cup Finals in 2022, out in the preliminary round 2-0 (best-of-3) last season.Alright, what can we expect from Drew Bannister? I don't know much about him outside of prospect watching a handful of Springfield games.
Mixed feelings about this. Obviously the current team has tons of problems and the head coach will always bear responsibility for those. It’s clear things have gotten stale so I don’t hate trying a new voice.
But if anything, this firing might bring up more questions than it answers. If you trade Perron, ROR, Barbashev and Tarasenko last year and replace them with Blais, Kapanen, Hayes and Vrana and then call it an offseason… well if I’m Berube, I would be pissed that I was expected to win with that. There needs to be serious concern about whether we are putting both players and coaches into positions to succeed here.
Stop it. We were never firing the guy who'd coached the team to the Cup 3 years prior, coming off a 109-point season and aShould have made Monty the coach instead of letting him go to Boston!
It would be really good if he really is good at player development. We also need better, or more scouts, and the related better drafting. But player development has been a big problem.Coached Sault Ste. Marie for 3 years; 2 division titles, named OHL and CHL Coach of the Year in 2018. Lost in the OHL Finals in 2018. 2 years with San Antonio (AHL), never made the playoffs. 2 years + current with Springfield (AHL); lost in the Calder Cup Finals in 2022, out in the preliminary round 2-0 (best-of-3) last season.
Seemed to develop a positive reputation for player development, but that might be relative because we've historically sucked at it. 1st time coaching anywhere at the NHL level. Rumored to have been considered for an assistant position this offseason, ultimately remained at Springfield.
Who was it that said Bannister didn't have the faith of Armstrong because we didn't give him one of the assistant roles? Hmmm.
Who said their was a disconnect between coach and GM? Oh yeah, that was me earlier today,
Its unfortunate that Berube was let go. I think he is a good coach when given a good roster and paired with a good Xs and Os guys. Unfortunately, we didn't have either of those. His message was definitely getting stale, and there seems to be a major disconnect with how he is coaching vs the personell Army is getting. I thought it was a potential issue. I wasn't expecting it to be one that was handled like this, and this quickly.
I do like Bannister. I think he is a great developmental coach and a good coach. We may need the developmental side more in the coming years. But we could really use him in Sprindfield now, with Dean, Bolduc there now and Dvorak and potentiall Snuggy on the way, I think Springdale is a more useful place for him.
How many coaches is Armstrong going to fire before the finger starts pointing a bit in his direction? We were awful last year. He did nothing this off season to improve the team. We needed a good xs and Os coach to run the PP and fix the defense. He got guys who got the head coach fired. Hopefully, Ott isn't too far behind.
I'm curious who Springfield replaces Bannister with, considering that's going to be a highly important position for the future of the organization.I do like Bannister. I think he is a great developmental coach and a good coach. We may need the developmental side more in the coming years. But we could really use him in Sprindfield now, with Dean, Bolduc there now and Dvorak and potentiall Snuggy on the way, I think Springdale is a more useful place for him.
How many coaches is Armstrong going to fire before the finger starts pointing a bit in his direction? We were awful last year. He did nothing this off season to improve the team. We needed a good xs and Os coach to run the PP and fix the defense. He got guys who got the head coach fired. Hopefully, Ott isn't too far behind.
You're goddamn right I'll hold Yeo against him, Cup or no Cup, because Yeo should have never started the season with the Blues after his f***ing abysmal coaching "effort" down the stretch in 2018 - and that was evident to much of this forum at season's end, even if everyone later relented with well, maybe with better players he'll be less of a f***ing dumbass.Are you going to hold Payne, Hitchcock and Yeo against him when keeping Doug resulted in a cup?
That's my issue with it. This is such an unlikeable group of players and there's no part of me that believes that a new voice is going to be able to get more out of this roster without heads rolling.I think the thing that bothers me about this is that last season, Armstrong recognized there was a problem 8 games into the season to the point he felt it was necessary to go address the team and make it clear, "this is on you guys, I'm not firing the head coach."
ROR the Captain gets shipped out, Vlad the Indifferent gets shipped out, Barbie the Opportuner gets shipped out, ... but there's still a lot of core guys here, including a few guys who are supposed to be future leaders for this team and a guy who's supposedly a key leader of the team who gets the 'C' affixed to his jersey, and after a semi-decent start they go right back to doing the same shit again - but now the head coach has to pay the price.
And one of the very first questions in about 10 hours or so better be, "when are you really going to hold the players accountable for all of this?" because at some point, some of them need to be paying the price for their indifferent, lackadaisical play.
I mean this is the first head coach firing since we won the cup. Are you going to hold Payne, Hitchcock and Yeo against him when keeping Doug resulted in a cup?
100% of Blues Cup wins have come under an Interim Head Coach. So he’s got that going for him.Alright, what can we expect from Drew Bannister? I don't know much about him outside of prospect watching a handful of Springfield games.
Yea for sure, it gets annoying when the players don't have answers and it doesn't look like the effort is there. I don't know where that comes from, but obviously Armstrong felt like this was the final straw.Yeah that’s fair. I am sick and tired of seeing the Blues look lackadaisical to start every single game, and then after the game give the same non-answers to the media as to why. Berube definitely was running out of ideas, so it will be interesting to see how we look with a new coach.
By the way I laughed out loud at how quickly you got that new avatar up there. Well done.
To be fair to Armstrong, he was first hired in 2010 and his first coach was Payne. Was the team very good? Idk, you could argue they were better than they played, but there looks like some under performing players there and no Petro. Blues narrowly missed by 5 points that year, but clearly the expectations were higher. Then Hitch came in the following year and did what he did. He's a hall of fame coach and just knows how to form a great defensive team and it showed. I don't know if we'll ever know if Payne learned how to be a head coach in the future, but he obviously couldn't cut it. Would you give him a pass for his first hire? Genuine question.Who was it that said Bannister didn't have the faith of Armstrong because we didn't give him one of the assistant roles? Hmmm.
Who said their was a disconnect between coach and GM? Oh yeah, that was me earlier today,
Its unfortunate that Berube was let go. I think he is a good coach when given a good roster and paired with a good Xs and Os guys. Unfortunately, we didn't have either of those. His message was definitely getting stale, and there seems to be a major disconnect with how he is coaching vs the personell Army is getting. I thought it was a potential issue. I wasn't expecting it to be one that was handled like this, and this quickly.
I do like Bannister. I think he is a great developmental coach and a good coach. We may need the developmental side more in the coming years. But we could really use him in Sprindfield now, with Dean, Bolduc there now and Dvorak and potentiall Snuggy on the way, I think Springdale is a more useful place for him.
How many coaches is Armstrong going to fire before the finger starts pointing a bit in his direction? We were awful last year. He did nothing this off season to improve the team. We needed a good xs and Os coach to run the PP and fix the defense. He got guys who got the head coach fired. Hopefully, Ott isn't too far behind.
Daniel Tkaczuk is Springfield’s interim now. Per Strickland.I'm curious who Springfield replaces Bannister with, considering that's going to be a highly important position for the future of the organization.
I'd wager whoever is named the next non-interim coach is probably his last coach. Army has 2 additional years after this season, and if the ship isn't headed in the right direction by then, I certainly think he's on the chopping block. And that's well within the normal lifespan of a new coach.
Payne wasn’t even really his hire as Pleau was still GM at the time Murray was fired and replaced by PayneYea for sure, it gets annoying when the players don't have answers and it doesn't look like the effort is there. I don't know where that comes from, but obviously Armstrong felt like this was the final straw.
Also thank you, I take pride in my avatar changes so it's nice to be recognized for that lmao
To be fair to Armstrong, he was first hired in 2010 and his first coach was Payne. Was the team very good? Idk, you could argue they were better than they played, but there looks like some under performing players there and no Petro. Blues narrowly missed by 5 points that year, but clearly the expectations were higher. Then Hitch came in the following year and did what he did. He's a hall of fame coach and just knows how to form a great defensive team and it showed. I don't know if we'll ever know if Payne learned how to be a head coach in the future, but he obviously couldn't cut it. Would you give him a pass for his first hire? Genuine question.
Then obviously Hitch's message got stale and Yeo came in. I think that was a mistake and it was clear just by Yeo's demeanor in the second full season. I don't give Army a pass on that one even despite the team playing well after Hitch was fired. After Yeo is fired, you have Berube who wins you the cup, an obvious win for Army even though Berube's message got stale more quickly than Hitch's. If you give Armstrong a pass for Payne then he's had 1 bad hire, otherwise he's even. My assumption is that if there is one more bad official head coach on this team, then Armstrong is gone. I could be wrong because it seems like Stillman trusts him, but that just seems like the logical next step even if I may disagree with it in the future.
He has the same track record since the cup as Berube. Berube has to coach the team he assembled. If I gave you a piece of swiss cheese for a parachute and push you out the plane, is it your fault you can't fly?
Our problems are not on coaching, they are on the roster. Before the last few games, we were better than most of us thought we should be. Most people in the pre-season polls had us missing the playoffs. So it seems like Berube didn't fail this season, he just had f*** all to work with,
Stop it. We were never firing the guy who'd coached the team to the Cup 3 years prior, coming off a 109-point season and anear-certain, practically definite Cup run if not for that motherf***ing cheap goddamn bastard Kadri2nd-round appearance, for a guy who'd been fired from his previous head coaching job for being an alcoholic to the point it impaired his ability to do his job, because of one season where he was an assistant here.