Ference wasn't that small though, I think people just thought he was. He's 5'11"...when you look at the average height of defensemen all-time, I feel like he's probably at par or an inch shorter than the average. Ference seemed pretty bitter with the Penguins though.
Yes, he really was. At the time he broke into the league, he was absolutely tiny for defensemen.
From about the mid-90s, and right up until the 05 lockout, defensemen that weren't around 6'2 were considered undersized. And they were undervalued. There's a reason freaking Derian Hatcher got a Norris nomination while Brian Rafalski never got close. It's also why despite being a strong junior performer, Ference only went in the 8th round, was unranked by Central Scouting and received no invites for workouts or interviews. He actually drafted a letter to send to every team in the league pre-draft asking for a chance.
In the late 90s especially, with Chris Pronger winning the Hart, all anyone wanted was big men on defense.
A lack of size on the blueline was a common complaint about CP's Penguins. Which is why he was always trying to add hulking giants back there, most infamously with the Zubov for Hatcher trade and his "we need a warrior" remarks that accompanied it. Then there was Peter Popovic, Mike Wilson, Jamie Pushor, Rick Berry and Dan Focht. The day we got rid of Ference we acquired Shawn Heins. Nuff said.
It's only been fairly recently the lumbering defenseman has started becoming obsolete.
Didn't the Pens FO make a big deal about Ferance's diabetes too? I forget the specifics, but I thought that was part of the reason they got rid of him.
I don't remember that. But there was definitely some kind of falling out with the coaching staff and management that predicated his trade. I do remember the rumblings.
He was never nearly as good for us as he was the year we went to the Conference Finals, the Mario comeback season. He was on the top powerplay during he playoffs, on the point opposite Kovalev. He was pretty terrible the following season, despite some excellent games where he was matched up against Jagr and owned him. I remember thinking at the time, "What the hell is this guy's problem? Why can't he do this every game?" But looking back at it now at the career he had since we dumped him, it's pretty clear he wasn't being coached well. Over that span of four or five years, none of our guys were, frankly.