From the previous version, I've been on the Polak bandwagon for a while. But JVR doesn't do it for me. Too much of a finesse player without any real bottom 6 utility. Despite how he's being absurdly overvalued by Leafs' fans, I think Komarov is a much better fit.
I get the hesitation...I just see it a little differently.
I've watched JVR since his days at UNH. I wish he used his body more (big guy), and I see him as a lot like Burakovsky, but just further along in his development.
Thing is, I want to dump Laich on the Leafs. To do that, we may need to take some salary, and they are in fire sale mode. JVR comes to DC and plays with Kuz and Williams/Oshie for this year and next, and his value will be higher than now. He's a goal scorer, and a great passer. He would give this years team (and next) amazing depth....and with no adders to salary (250k less than Laich). If the Caps needed salary relief after this or next season, a 4.25m JVR would be an easy sell. Especially if he gets 50-70pts or so on the Caps 2nd line.
Bura-Johansson-Wilson would be a very tough match up. If you want Chimera there, then Bura-Richards-Beagle would be an awesome 4th line.
JVR is a luxury for the regular season, but in 4 rounds of playoffs, we will lose a top 6 skater or 2, and our LW depth is weak (unless you move MaJo to LW...but then C depth is weak)
Ovy-Backs-Oshie
JVR-Kuz-Williams
Bura-MaJo-Wilson
Chimera-Richards-Beagle
That depth would be unparalleled. 2 guys on the 3rd line that can play top 6. 2 guys on the 4th line that can play 3rd line, etc.
I see it as total preparation for playoff injuries. (With Polak added to the deal as 7th Dman, pushing Chorney to 8).