Given he is being handily out performed by virtually every other player in the top end of that draft, it's not too soon to ask questions.
I don't know about that. That draft really didn't have a lot of quality depth, and you can't compare him to players selected before him as they weren't available. How many guys drafted after him have truly turned out better considering Edmonton was really looking for some offensive pop from their forwards.
11-Ellis (yeah, he's great, but no one wanted a small defenseman at the time and would he have developed as well without being with or behind the great defensemen Nashville has had over his career?)
12-DeHaan (an average 4th-5th d-man on the left side, slightly better value but not ridiculously so).
13-Kassian (similar quality of player, Zach is tougher/meaner, MPS may be a better all around player. He would not have stuck with this team through his battles with addiction)
14-Kulikov (similar to DeHaan for overall results and handedness, but more games played after being rushed into the show)
15- Peter Holland (similar quality to MPS)
16-Leddy (after Ellis here is where the biggest miss comes, but at this point we are 6 positions back so it's not just the Oilers here).
Anything after this is far enough away that you'd say the players have outperformed their draft position if they are better than MPS.
Ultimately, I'd rather have had one of those defensemen, particularly Ellis, but I'm not sure at this point whether any of the guys selected after him would be contributing to today's team anyways.
MPS ended up being traded for Perron who was good for us, who in turn brought us the pick that should have been Barzal or Connor, but became Reinhart. Kind of ironic that ultimately he turned into the pick we used to get a 20 year old defensemen who's top end potential was a 4-5 left handed d-man, when if they had just gone for defense at the draft, they likely would have had a 24 year-old 4-5 left handed d-man (or Ellis).