There are a few key days—followed by lots of small disasters for the New York Islanders. But here are the biggest three...
#3--The day the New York Islanders sent Bryan McCabe and Todd Bertuzzi to the Canucks for Trevor Linden.
Nothing against Linden, he is a heart and soul guy, and a great player, but we gave up two future all-stars for a player who was only going to be here for a few months.
#2--Trading Olli Jokenin and Roberto Luongo to the Florida Panthers for Mark Parrish and Oleg Kvasha—followed by trading Kevin Weeks to the Lightning (I dont recall what we got in return).
This was the disaster of disasters. With these trades, we were left with no goalie—and with the miracle gift of winning the lottery, and having the first overall pick in the 2000 draft, we passed on Dany Heatley, passed on Marion Gaborik and drafted Rick DiPietro with the pick.
DiPietro is a solid goalie—when he is healthy. Sure—he is top 10 material. But he also makes many errors—he wanders, overhandles the puck, and costs us at least one goal a night. This is when he is actually playing. With his injury issues, I now wonder if he is NHL material on a long term basis at all. His contract is bad as well, however, he could always be baught out (its not my money) or if he is forced out due to injury, insurance should cover the salary contract, and I don't think it would be a cap hit.
What makes this even worse is that Luongo is arguably the best goalie in the game—something we already knew he had the potential to be when he was drafted 4th overall by Milbury a few years earlier, and Jokenin has become one of the game top centers and draws. In Return we had Parrish—who produced reasonable numbers, but never made the players around him better, and Kvasha, who was a complete bust. The players who were passed over—Heatley and Gaborik, are superstars in every sense of the word.
And...the #1 worst day in New York Islanders franchise history...
The hiring of Mike Milbury as coach, and eventually a few months later as GM.
The two trades mentioned above are bad—both engineered by someone who knows very little about hockey and hockey players. Both of these moves would never have happened with a different GM. And these moves are just the tip of the sword.
Honorable mention to...
Chara and the 2nd overall (Spezza) pick to Ott. for Yashin
Tim Connolly and Taylor Pyatt to Buffalo for Mike Peca
(at least Peca was great for us, until he was traded away for Mike York)
All of this has led to the mediorce situation on Long Island. I actually think Snow has been okay. He rebuilt the farm system at the last draft, adding some good potential, and should be able to add a substantial asset or two at this next draft. But it is going to take at leas 3 more seasons for the team to be taken seriously, and that is only if they stick with their plan to build through the draft.
Right now, Okposo looks good though he is hurt, and having a bit of a slow start. Frans Neilsen—also hurt—looks like he can slot in as a vry capable 3rd line—maybe 2nd line center. And despite the boo's on draft day, Josh Bailey looks very good for a 19 year old...certainly not out of place playing in the NHL.
But all of the damage of Mike Milbury put the Islanders in this state. so...my vote—the day he was hired!!!