Your Team's Post Full-Season Lockout All Star Team

[Regal]

Curious to see how everyone would construct an All Star lineup of their team from the 2005-06 season to the current one. The idea being to build a lineup assuming everyone is at their peak season during that timeframe. So longevity isn't important, but they can only play at the level they played at for your team, and the intention is to win in a season/playoff style format, so chemistry and role is important, and it's not necessarily just the top scorers.

So, for Anaheim, they might do something like:

Bobby Ryan ('11) - Ryan Getzlaf ('14) - Corey Perry ('11)
Andy McDonald ('06) - Ryan Kesler ('15) - Teemu Selanne ('07)
Chris Kunitz ('07) - Saku Koivu ('10) - Andrew Cogliano ('14)
Travis Moen ('07) - Samuel Pahlsson ('07) - Rob Niedermayer ('07)
Ex: Nick Bonino ('14), Dustin Penner ('07)

Francois Beauchemin ('13) - Scott Niedermayer ('07)
Cam Fowler ('14) - Chris Pronger ('07)
Lubomir Visnovsky ('11) - Toni Lydman ('11)
Ex: Hampus Lindholm ('15)

JS Giguere ('07)
Jonas Hiller ('11)

I thought it would be interesting to see how fans think players on their team stack up over the years. Also interesting to see who everyone thinks would be the best team overall.

Click to read more...

 

[Machinehead]

Marty Straka (06) - Michael Nylander (06) - Jaromir Jagr (06)
Rick Nash (15) - Derek Stepan (15) - Marian Gaborik (10/12)
Marty St. Louis (14) - Derick Brassard (15) - Mats Zuccarello (14)
Brian Boyle (14) - Brandon Dubinsky (11) - Ryan Callahan (12)

Ryan McDonagh (14) - Michal Rozsival (06)
Marc Staal (11) - Anton Stralman (14)
Fedor Tyutin (07) - Dan Girardi (12)

Henrik Lundqvist (whenever )
Cam Talbot (14/15)

Forward group is scary deep, and they would never get scored on ever.

I'd keep Brendan Shanahan '07 around and spell him with Zuccarello.

 

[swflyers93]

I'm going to try the Flyers:

Gagne --- Giroux-- Voracek
Briere --- Carter -- Simmonds
Couturier -- Richards -- Knuble
Lecavalier -- Schenn -- Read

Pronger -- Carle
Timonen -- Coburn
Seidenberg -- Mezaros

Mason
Bobrovsky

 

[hockeykicker]

not exactly sure, i could be off and i feel im missing someone but for the caps possibly:

Ovechkin-backstrom-knuble
Semin-Fedorov-kozlov
Laich-zubrus-clark
steckel-beagle-hendricks

Green-alzner
Carlson-wideman
Witt-schultz

Kolzig
Holtby/varlamov


disregard lines, im bad at putting them together

 

[Connor McSaviour]

Hall (2012) - Horcoff (2006) - Hemsky (2006)
Perron (2014) - RNH (2012) - Eberle (2011)
Torres (2006) - Stoll (2006) - Pisani (2006)
Moreau (2007) - Peca (2006) - Glencross (2008)

Pronger (2006) - Spacek (2006)
Whitney (2011 pre injury) - Gilbert (2009)
Souray (2009) - Visnovsky (2009)

Roloson (2006)
Garon (2008)

 

[Cassano]

Marty Straka (06) - Michael Nylander (06) - Jaromir Jagr (06)
Rick Nash (15) - Derek Stepan (15) - Marian Gaborik (10/12)
Marty St. Louis (14) - Derick Brassard (15) - Mats Zuccarello (14)
Brian Boyle (14) - Brandon Dubinsky (11) - Ryan Callahan (12)

Ryan McDonagh (14) - Michal Rozsival (06)
Marc Staal (11) - Anton Stralman (14)
Fedor Tyutin (07) - Dan Girardi (12)

Henrik Lundqvist (whenever )
Cam Talbot (14/15)

Forward group is scary deep, and they would never get scored on ever.

I'd keep Brendan Shanahan '07 around and spell him with Zuccarello.

Great list. I'd replace 2014 Boyle with 2015 D.Moore though. And would prefer the 2010-11 Callahan who was playing elite level hockey before the Chara slapshot. I would also take 2007 Shanahan over 2014 MSL, but that is up to debate.

Excellent list, nonetheless.

 

[canuckster19]

11- D Sedin 10- H Sedin 11-Burrows
07- Naslund 11- Kesler 15- Vrbata
11- Hansen 09- Sundin 11- Torres
11- Higgins 11- Lapierre 07- Linden

11- Ehrhoff 10- Mitchell
11- Hamhuis 11- Bieksa
07- Ohlund 11- Edler

07- Luongo
11- Schneider

Damn that 10-11 team was good.

 

[12345678910]

JVR - Sundin - Kessel
Tucker - Lindros - Lupul
Steen - Kadri - Grabo
Domi - McClement - Antropov

McCabe - Kaberle
Phaneuf - Kubina
Franson - White

Eddie the eagle in net.

 

[Captain Bowie]

I like the idea. Good one.

Canucks:

D. Sedin ('11) - H. Sedin ('10) - Burrows ('10)
Naslund ('06) - Demitra ('09) - Bertuzzi ('06)
Samuelsson ('10) - Kesler ('11) - Vrbata ('15)
Higgins ('12) - Malhota ('11) - Hansen ('12)

HM:
Morrison ('06)
Raymond ('10)
Torres ('11)
Sundin ('09)
Linden ('07)


Ehrhoff ('11) - Edler ('12)
Mitchell ('09) - Bieksa ('09)
Hamhuis ('12) - Salo ('07)

HM:
Ohlund ('07)
Tanev ('15)


Luongo ('07)
Schneider ('12)

HM:
Miller ('15)

 

[izzy]

I'd assume an injury that season wouldn't be a big change? I'll make sure they played at least 35 games for the Blues.

Kariya (08)-Andy MacDonald (09)-Tarasenko (15)
Tkachuk (06)-Weight (06)-Boyes (08, I mean, he scored 43 goals..)
Steen (14)-Backes (11)-Oshie (12)
Schwartz (15)-Berglund (11)-Guerin (07)
Perron (09)/Stastny (15)

Jaybo (14)-Petro (14)
Brewer (07)-Shattenkirk (15)
Jackman (07 or 08)-Erik Johnson (10)
Polak (whenever, I guess 2010 because he put up his best numbers)

Halak (12)
Elliott (12)

Maybe I should have had Stas switch with Berglund but I couldn't do it.

 

[um]

Ovechkin(08)-Backstrom(10)-Semin(09)
Zubrus(07)-Ribeiro(13)-Knuble(10)
Laich(10)-Nylander(08)-Clark(07)
Flieschmann(10)-Fedorov(09)-Brouwer(13)

Poti(08)-Green(09)
Alzner(12)-Carlson(15)
Niskanen(15)-Wideman(12)

Holtby(15)
Kolzig(07)

 

[Lehnsanity]

Heatley-Spezza-Alfredsson
MacArthur -Turris-Ryan
Michalek - Vermette - Fisher
Foligno - Kelly - Neil

Chara - Karlsson
Redden - Volchenkov
Meszaros - Phillips

Hasek
Anderson

 

[Addison Rae]

Sedin 10 / Sedin 10 / Burrows 10
Naslund 06 / Kesler 11 / Bertuzzi 06
Demitra 10 / Sundin 09 / Vrbata 15
Raymond 10 / Bonino 15 / Samuelsson 10

Hamhuis 12 / Tanev 15
Edler 15 / Ehrhoff 11
Mitchell 07 / Bieksa 07

Luongo 07
Schneider 13

 

[bambamcam4ever]

Perron (15)- Crosby (11)- Hossa (08)
Neal (12)- Malkin (12)- Palffy (06)
Kunitz (13)- Staal (12) - Dupuis (12)
Lemieux (06)- Sutter (14) - Talbot (09)

Gonchar (08)- Letang (15)
Martin (13)- Maatta (15)
Niskanen (14)- Orpik (08)

Fleury (08)
Vokoun (13)

 

[Captain Bowie]

Sedin 10 / Sedin 10 / Burrows 10
Naslund 06 / Kesler 11 / Bertuzzi 06
Demitra 10 / Sundin 09 / Vrbata 15
Raymond 10 / Bonino 15 / Samuelsson 10

Hamhuis 12 / Tanev 15
Edler 15 / Ehrhoff 11
Mitchell 07 / Bieksa 07

Luongo 07
Schneider 13

Need more grit in that bottom 6. Otherwise pretty close to mine.

 

[DearDiary]

Perron (15)- Crosby (11)- Hossa (08)
Neal (12)- Malkin (12)- Palffy (06)
Kunitz (13)- Staal (12) - Dupuis (12)
Lemieux (06)- Sutter (14) - Talbot (09)

Gonchar (08)- Letang (15)
Martin (13)- Maatta (15)
Niskanen (14)- Orpik (08)

Fleury (08)
Vokoun (13)

Hornqvist?

 

[gopherman23]

Parise-Granlund-Gaborik
Rolston-Koivu-Demitra
Brunette-Cullen-Nolan
Cooke-Walz-Clutterbuck

Suter-Burns
Kuba-Johnsson
Brodin-Mitchell

Fernandez
Harding

 

[huntison]

Need more grit in that bottom 6. Otherwise pretty close to mine.

Maybe replace Raymond with Torres

And

Bonino with Malholtra

 

[Xavier Laflamme*]

Perron Crosby Hossa
Neal Malkin Iginla
Kunitz Staal Palffy
Recchi Lemieux Morrow

Letang Orpik
Maata Gonchar
Erhoff Martin

Fleury
Vokoun

You could make cases for guys like Hornqvist, Malone, Dupuis, Sutter, Talbot, Murray, Scuderi and a few other guys as well.

That's a nasty team though...

 

[Joey Moss]

Hall (2012) - Horcoff (2006) - Hemsky (2006)
Perron (2014) - RNH (2012) - Eberle (2011)
Torres (2006) - Stoll (2006) - Pisani (2006)
Moreau (2007) - Peca (2006) - Glencross (2008)

Pronger (2006) - Spacek (2006)
Whitney (2011 pre injury) - Gilbert (2009)
Souray (2009) - Visnovsky (2009)

Roloson (2006)
Garon (2008)

Smyth says hi.

 

[PensPlz]

Perron ('15) - Crosby ('14) - Hossa ('08)
Neal ('12) - Malkin ('12) - Hornqvist ('15)
Kunitz ('12) - Staal ('09) - Fedotenko ('09)
Iginla ('13) - Talbot ('09) - Cooke ('12)

Gonchar ('08) - Letang ('15)
Martin ('13) - Orpik ('09)
Niskanen ('14) - Despres ('15)

Fleury ('08)
Vokoun ('13)

Tired to build a team with the playoffs in mind. Balance skill and toughness.

 

[PALE PWNR]

('12) Scott Hartnell-('12) Claude Giroux-('15) Jake Voracek
('06) Simon Gagne-('06) Peter Forsberg-('06) Mike Knuble
('08) Danny Briere-('09) Mike Richards-('09) Jeff Carter
('10) Ian Laperriere-('15) Sean Couturier-('14) Wayne Simmonds
('12) Matt Read
('10) Blair Betts

('10) Chris Pronger-('11) Matt Carle
('08) Kimmo Timonen-('06) Eric Desjardins
('15) Mark Streit-('08) Braydon Coburn
('06) Joni Pitkanen
('08) Jason Smith

('15) Steve Mason
('08) Martin Biron​

 

[mike14]

hmm, all-star hey?

Zherdev - Gomez - Adam Hall
Marcel Hossa - drury - Isbister
Neiminen - Jason Ward - Brashear
Orr - Hollweg - Glass

Strudwick - Redden
Rachunek - Ozolinsh
Pock - Backman

Weekes
Valiquette

 

[Xavier Laflamme*]

('12) Scott Hartnell-('12) Claude Giroux-('15) Jake Voracek
('06) Simon Gagne-('06) Peter Forsberg-('06) Mike Knuble
('08) Danny Briere-('09) Mike Richards-('09) Jeff Carter
('10) Ian Laperriere-('15) Sean Couturier-('14) Wayne Simmonds
('12) Matt Read
('10) Blair Betts

('10) Chris Pronger-('11) Matt Carle
('08) Kimmo Timonen-('06) Eric Desjardins
('15) Mark Streit-('08) Braydon Coburn
('06) Joni Pitkanen
('08) Jason Smith

('15) Steve Mason
('08) Martin Biron​

Damn, that forward group is filthy. You could also add Lindros and Leclaire I believe if we're pretending you're getting prime players.

That defense and goaltending however....

 

[drunksage]

Giving the San Jose Sharks a shot.

Ekman ('06)- Thornton ('06)- Cheechoo ('06)
Marleau ('06) - Pavelski ('14) - Heatley ('10)
Michalek ('07) - Couture ('15)- Setoguchi ('09)
Clowe ('11) - Malhotra ('10) - Wingels ('15)

Vlasic ('15) - Boyle ('10)
Ehrhoff ('09) - Blake ('09)
Campbell ('08) - Burns ('15)

Niemi ('13)
Nabokov ('07)