Is 'mushy middle' not a thing anymore? Because that was everyone's greatest criticism of Jets management three or four years ago.
'You'll never get impact players at 9th overall. You can't expect to outdraft the rest of the NHL.'
Fast forward to today where they've appeared to get the best or second best player at 7th and 9th, top five talent at 9th, top 10 or better talent at 17th and suddenly--'oh, well they've been drafting so high of course they've drafted better than some teams who have outright tanked.'
Averages hardly tell the whole story, anyhow. In those six drafts the Oilers picked in the top five 5 times, Sabres twice, Panthers 3 times, Leefs 3 times, and the Islanders 3 times.
The Jets have picked in the top 5 once. Same as the Lightning and the Flames and fewer than the Avalanche, Blue Jackets, and Hurricanes.
Uh, I mean I agree...
More difficult to pick terrific players.
The Jets have done fine in the 'mushy middle' I think - Morrissey and Connor being right in the heart of that mush. Top 10 isn't the mushy middle though. Top 5 is the high end and we've only had one pick there - and Laine's about as good as you could hope for at 2nd overall.
Top 5 - [Jets' pick]
2011: RNH, Landeskog, Huberdeau, Larsson, R. Strome [7. Scheifele]
2012: Yakupov, Murray, Galchenyuk, G. Reinhart, Rielly [9. Trouba]
2013: MacKinnon, Barkov, Drouin, Jones, E. Lindholm [13. Morrissey]
2014: Ekblad, S. Reinhart, Draisaitl, Bennett, Dal Colle [9. Ehlers]
2015: McDavid, Eichel, D. Strome, Marner, Hanifin [17. Connor]
2016: Matthews, [2. Laine], Dubois, Puljujarvi, Juolevi
Scheifele beats his top 5 class. Trouba beats his top 5 class. Morrissey...we'll see - 2013 is stiffer competition than the previous two years. Ehlers should be somewhere in that top 5 for his year...though so should Nylander. A bit early to say for Connor, but I wouldn't be surprised if he turns out better than Strome and Hanifin. Laine's right where he should be.
The Jets first pick has been arguably been better than any other single team over this period.
No home runs outside of the 1st though. And that's where you'd hope the huge scouting staff would be able to unearth some gems. But, it's only 6 drafts in at this point - and too early to say about late round surprises in at least half of those.