pappyline
Registered User
You are right, The old-timers get no respect. Actually, anybody pre-1980 doesn't get much respect. Best goal scorer discussions seem to start & end with a Gretzy vs Lemiieux argument with a few accolades to Bure & Bossy. It seems to be generally accepted that dominance relative to your peers is the best way to compare eras. After paying homage to Newsy & Joe, lets look at the most dominant goal scoring seasons over the last 50 or so seasons. Comparisons are per cent over the runner-up.When you say greatest, if you look at the stats (both per-and post NHL) lifetime is E.C. newsy Lalonde with an average of 1,4 goals per game (454 goals in 345 games) Single season is Joe Malone with 2,08 for the 1921 season. Too bad these records don't make it into the HHoF logs, since they sem to think nothing existed before 1925 or thereabouts
1. Bobby Hull 65-66 69%
2. Brett hull 90-91 69%
3. Bobby Hull 61-62 67%
4. M.Richard 44-45 56%
5. gretzy 83-84 55%
6. Howe 52-53 53%
7. Howe 51-52 52%
8. M.Richard 46-47 50%
9. Bobby hull 66-67 49%
10. esposito 70-71 49%
11. gretzy 81-82 44%
12. Bobby hull (WHA)43%
13. Howe 56-57 33%
14. Esposito 71-72 32%
15 Esposito 73-74 31%
16 brett Hull 91-92 30%
17 Lemieux 87-88 25%
18. M Richard 49-50 23%
19. Lemieux 88-89 21%
20. Bobby Hull 68-69 18%
Based on this analysis, Bobby Hull is easily #1.