How is the answer Georgiyev based on play? Shestyorkin has a 19 point better SV% than Georgiyev. Unless you expect that to revert to less than .910 over a larger sample, which would make him the most overrated prospect in the league, the answer is Shestyorkin based on play.
Some of you overrate Georgiyev's play a lot. When he plays well, all we hear is how well he's playing. When he can't stop the puck, it's the fault of the defense. But some of you are sure to blame Hank when he doesn't play well. Georgiyev gets a free pass. Georgiyev is a young inconsistent goaltender. That's all there is to it. Some don't want to admit it, but he rotates great performances and bad performances, which is why his numbers have went down as he's played more this season than previous seasons.