If we're assuming everyone is in their primes...
Doug Gilmour also played a game for the Leafs in the 2000's, so he should be there as well. Kaberle, McCabe, Leetch, Housley, Wesley, Phaneuf/Stralman should be the defense.
Gary Roberts - Mats Sundin - Alex Mogilny
Owen Nolan - Doug Gilmour - Phil Kessel
Darcy Tucker - Eric Lindros - Joe Nieuwendyk
Shayne Corson - Ron Francis - Alex Steen
Extra: Jason Blake, Jason Allison
Brian Leetch - Phil Housley
Tomas Kaberle - Bryan McCabe
Glen Wesley - Dion Phaneuf
Extra: Anton Stralman
Eddie Belfour
Curtis Joseph