What do you consider old???

BigGoalBrad

Registered User
Jun 3, 2012
10,009
2,789
Gregory Campbell got old very quickly because of the injury.

Sometimes the line between good and experienced and old and slow is thin. Chara and Seids are still NHLers and good players but they were the best at their position recently and are being paid like it now and when they are even older. Wouldn't call either old just quite yet since Im hoping both can kick it up a notch in the playoffs and I think we are still within their window. Both will be very "old" in pro athlete terms before either of their contracts end, however.
 

LSCII

Cup driven
Mar 1, 2002
50,519
22,033
Central MA
Sport-wise? Mid 30's. Like a lot of people are saying here though, it's not the miles so much as it's the ride.
 

Trap Jesus

Registered User
Feb 13, 2012
28,686
13,456
It's all relative to the player and position, but 35 across the board is an age where I start getting hesitant.
 

ODAAT

Registered User
Oct 17, 2006
52,295
20,532
Victoria BC
all depends, I look at a player like Crosby, still a terrific player but concussions and having played a ton of hockey over his pro career, takes a ton of physical shots (I`ve got no issues with that) he`s already looking less like the Crosby I saw in his first few years

Players who play a hard nosed, physical game are often older beyond their years too
 

zaYG

Nerevarine
Jun 29, 2012
3,495
779
Santa Cruz, CA
It really depends. Certain play styles can make a player become old and beat down in their late 20s. Look at Mike Richards for example.
 

since76

Registered User
Jul 14, 2005
3,419
1,298
Quebec
Be old is not a number but a lost of capacity, speed , intensity etc. You can fight it by healthy life, hard traning and you can lose it by the reverse. Some nhl players are old at 30 , other at 38 !
 

Cid

Registered User
Jan 9, 2007
4,223
0
Canada
In today's NHL..... I'd say anything over 30 would be considered old.

The kids are starting at 18-19 and the early to mid 20 year olds are dominating.

Average age on most teams is 25 to 29 years old. Therefor I would consider 30+ to be considered "old".

But then again it really depends on how you define old. Old doesn't mean can't play.
 

Ladyfan

Miss Bergy, Savvy and Quaider. Welcome back Looch!
Sponsor
Jun 8, 2007
63,034
76,266
next to the bench
Nice to see you post OLDJOHN !

I am old.

In hockey It depends on the player. Over 40 is old for hockey IMO.
 

Strange Universe

Registered User
Apr 8, 2009
2,458
2
In my opinion it is when a player takes a shower after the game and the player still smells like Munster cheese...now that's old..:laugh:
 

Dicky113

Registered User
Oct 30, 2007
4,417
3,317
I think players peak at about 27 and by 32 are, with some notable exceptions, starring to wear down. I would say 35 is "old"
 

don

Registered User
Aug 31, 2002
3,196
69
Nashua, NH
Depends on the individual player and a lot on the injuries sustained. When a player "slows" down you can say he's old (Chara) but he can still play an effective game. The problem with getting old is recognizing it. Most don't.
 

TCL40

Registered User
Jun 29, 2011
25,792
945
On average 35 is old in hockey but agree depending on injury history and where the talent started at it can vary a good deal.

I think a lot of defensemen and forwards who play hard, physical hockey and block a lot of shots age more quickly than the finesse players. That's why Campbell seems to be cooked when players of a similar age are still playing well. I think the bottom 6, energy guys, PK, and role player types often go down hill fast and why some former top 6 guys fall into the bottom 6. Sometimes it's where you start that determines when you're old as well.

Chara is getting old but he isn't cooked yet-I do think he's headed for the realm of #2/3 Dman PK/PP specialist.
 

Dellstrom

Pastrnasty
May 1, 2011
25,243
3,805
Boston
For good players I'd say anything over 35 is getting old in terms of sports. Chara is definitely old. It hasn't shown much until this year because no other NHLer can be compared to him in terms of his workouts and fitness. It's hard to judge where he is right now because I'm sure he's still not even close to 100% with his knee, but I can see him playing at a high level for however long he wants, kind of like Lidstrom. He's not going to be that elite #1 guy anymore but if all goes to plan with Hamilton, he and Chara can be an excellent top pairing for a few more years.

I think we have a very good balance on our team. Young guys like Pasta, Spooner, Hamilton, etc. Guys in their prime like Bergy, Krejci, Lucic, Marshy... Veterans like Talbot, Paille, Chara, Seids... It's bad to be too old or too young, we have a good mix.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad