Lil Sebastian Cossa
Opinions are share are my own personal opinions.
- Jul 6, 2012
- 11,436
- 7,446
An interesting take, but I don't think a healthy Fischer really would've had any effect on the Lidstrom/Suter debacle. Considering they still would've lost Rafalski and then Lidstrom, they probably still would've gone after a top pairing Dman when Suter hit the UFA market.
IMO, A healthy Fischer probably means no Markov in 06-07 and then no Stuart trade in 07-08, which obviously would've given them back a 2nd in 08 and a 4th in 09.
The Quincey deal would be a toss up.
IIRC, at the time of the Quincey deal, the Red Wings already seemed pretty confident that they had Suter in the bag to replace Lidstrom. The factors in acquiring Quincey were them already anticipating the loss of Stuart to free agency due to his family situation (which obviously would've been negated if a healthy Fischer meant no Stuart trade), and there was also them wanting immediate depth because Babcock didn't want to use Kindl or Commodore on the 3rd pairing. Given the 3rd pairing depth issue, maybe they instead go with a rental since Fischer would be in tow and they may not have the cap flexibility to re-sign Quincey as an RFA. Then again, Holland wasted little time giving the cap space from the departing Stuart and then some to the combination of Samuelsson, Colaiacovo, Tootoo and Gustavsson, and re-signing Quincey, so maybe they do still make the Quincey trade...
I'm not saying they'd have not gone after Suter. But they would not have needed a minute crunching D in Quincey because they'd have had Fisch. But they would have had Kronwall, an uninjured at that point Ericsson, Fischer, and a few other lesser guys (Commodore, Cola, Kindl, etc.)
They certainly would have gone after Suter. And with the fact that they had 3 top 4 guys without him and he's not necessarily being asked to be the one shining light saving the Red Wings... maybe it changes that negotiation a bit. If nothing else, a healthy Fischer stops the terrifyingly desperate signing of Cola in 2012 and potentially the dog and pony show of 14 where they tried for any defenseman capable of top 4 minutes and got told no by them all and then had to bring Quincey on a raise after they basically kicked him to the curb.