true, but, it is what it is. It's kinda like a good senior men's league. I wonder how the Bears would fair against the Bentley Generals? I suspect that Senior AAA is a bit higher then CIS.
The Bentley Generals have (several times) requested an exhibition game with Alberta Bears. In fact, Ian Herbers had agreed to a game last winter but he decided to cancel it a couple weeks ahead of puck drop.
The Generals have played U of C Dinos a couple of times...once in 2003 and once this past January. Bentley won the 03' game but was outskated/shot/scored (5-2) badly when they went to Father David Bauer Arena this season.
Thing is...the roster we took to Calgary for this most recent game...wasn't quite a "true" Gens' roster. We left 6 regulars at home & dressed a bunch of guys we were considering signing at the time. A few of those 6...we kept...and a few others we decided were too old/slow.
Bottom line...CIS hockey is faster/better conditioned than what the Bentley Generals typically play. Those kids are on the ice and/or in the gym every day. In order for the Bentley Generals to even up the odds...they would need to play an extremely intense/rugged/nasty style...kinda like how they play all the time.
Thing is...you can't request exhibition games against highly respected varsity programs which spend big bucks on their players...and then go out and beat the ever loving piss out of them just to prove a point. The Generals did just that back in 2003 and they beat U of C (3-2 if memory serves me exact)...but...U of C refused to play us again for 10 years after that. I think 2 of their better players got hurt in that game...although...it was worth all the controversy because Bentley built a strong tie with the U of C program and we now gain access to lots of their better graduating players who've become key pieces of our teams over the years.
Hypothetically...if we put something on the line...to make it worth everyones' while...and Alberta Bears/Generals played a game after both teams were completed their respective seasons...we would get an excellent hockey game. I think the Gens' would handle U of A...as good as they are.
Thing is...the Generals are a cut above almost all other SR AAA teams. So, while they might be able to pull it off...I can't say the same for other SR AAA teams. Other SR AAA teams don't have the depth or overall game we've been rolling here. Not trying to be arrogant. That's just the truth.
Anyways...someone was talking about CIS players viability as pro players...I'd like to say...first of all...the NHL isn't the only pro hockey out there. If you look at ECHL rosters...you will find lots of CIS alumni. The Colorado Eagles have harvested out of U of C for a number of years now and done very well with that relationship.
As for CIS players making it to the NHL...it happens. Bracken Kearns wasn't in the Sharks line-up tonight. Too bad. He's an interesting story and a solid depth player for them. He's a U of C alumni.
Typically...its AHL teams who will scout the CIS and offer PTO's at the conclusion of the CIS season. Because these CIS players are older than major JR players...they're viewed less as prospects and more as hole fillers...which is unfortunate. They tend to do "ok" on their initial try-out opportunities...but...they're the first guys to get moved to the ECHL or other AHL rosters anytime room needs to be made for an NHL affiliated player. And I can assure you...once you start moving around in the vast network of farm teams...it becomes almost impossible to generate a reputable line of stats that an NHL team is going to pick up on.
Also needs to be said...because something like 90% of the entire semi-pro circuit is composed of American based teams...a lot of Canadian players have not been given the contract(s) they're most deserving of. Not all...but some...of these farm teams feel they need to feature American born players. Its especially evident on teams located close to NCAA college(s). I've seen some laughably weak American born players with loooong semi-pro resumes/lots of semi-pro $$$$$...and I've seen some amazing Canadian guys come home from the states after a few months because they can't get any kind of a fair shot.