Why are people having the Pens? Recency bias? I take the Hawks all day long.
From 2008 - 2014 they
3 x cups
2x conference finals
2x 2nd round
This level of domination and peak in the cap era is unheard of. The Pens for example took even longer to make that level of success (2 more years to match the 3 cups). Pens in 2 extra years
3 x cups
3 x first round exits
2 x 2nd round exit
1 x ECF appearance
I take the Hawks all day long. Then the Pens.
A healthy Pitt team likely would have had 4, maybe 5 cups. The year Boston won, Pittsburgh was far and above the best team in the league. Iirc, both Crosby and Malkin missed the playoffs.