HF Article
Registered User
- Nov 16, 2005
- 12,507
- 3
For purposes of this list, we used the criteria whereby we ranked only NHL drafted or signed blueliners currently playing in the WHL.
More...
More...
Surprised that the guy who's most NHL ready isn't first. We'll see how Barrie does in the NHL. Cowen is a lock with his size, but his offensive numbers this year are very impressive for someone being called the best shutdown D in the WHL and arguably the entire CHL.
Cowen acts like he doesn't want to be in Spokane. Fans there don't want him to be Captain. He's just biding his time till he gets out. Barrie is a lights out player in the dub. Ponich, even before the injury wasn't that immpressive.
We rock. 1, 3 and a HM.
Has Petrovic really been better than Marincin thus far? I know Petrovic has had a solid year, but Marincin's been dominating on a horrible PGC team - it just seems like he's contributed so much more. I guess that's just my Oilers bias talking...
i honestly think McNabb will turn out as the best NHL defenseman out of this group
Hello all, new to HF Boards, excellent dialogue....
Saw the rankings and had to jump in on this one. While I agree with the bottom five the top 1/2 listed need a shuffling. Cowen is over rated here. Judging by his numbers to date +27 & 31 points they sound impressive but Elliott's current numbers of +40 & 56 points are far more impressive. McNab's numbers continue to get better every year and he's sitting at +17 and 48 points right now. Personally I find Cowen to be the least mobile of the top five and he struggled two years in a row at critical points in WJHC. Elliott's a clutch player for sure and a consistent producer. McNab, in my opinion, should have made Team Canada this year. At 6'4" he's just as impressive physically as Cowen and was a far better fit to the make up of this years squad.
1. Barrie
2. Elliott
3. McNab
4. Ponich
5. Cowen
Hello all, new to HF Boards, excellent dialogue....
Saw the rankings and had to jump in on this one. While I agree with the bottom five the top 1/2 listed need a shuffling. Cowen is over rated here. Judging by his numbers to date +27 & 31 points they sound impressive but Elliott's current numbers of +40 & 56 points are far more impressive. McNab's numbers continue to get better every year and he's sitting at +17 and 48 points right now. Personally I find Cowen to be the least mobile of the top five and he struggled two years in a row at critical points in WJHC. Elliott's a clutch player for sure and a consistent producer. McNab, in my opinion, should have made Team Canada this year. At 6'4" he's just as impressive physically as Cowen and was a far better fit to the make up of this years squad.
1. Barrie
2. Elliott
3. McNab
4. Ponich
5. Cowen
For purposes of this list, we used the criteria whereby we ranked only NHL drafted or signed blueliners currently playing in the WHL.
More...
Elliott gives up 4" and 30 lbs according to stats.... I agree he gives up something but he's consistent, more mobility.
I think McNab's finally finding his game and his numbers have consistently come up.
Make no mistake they'll all end up playing I just think Cowen comes in over rated for what he's shown in clutch games. I've heard Spokane fans aren't impressed (?)