Feaster is a mystery of awfulness. I just don't see why or how he keeps his job. This draft was the worst yet. He sat at his table and refused to answer his own phone. For a long time he made other teams walk up to the table to deal with him. I just don't see how he remains employed. I have never seen anything like that before let alone how terrible a job he has done in every other aspect.
Feaster lives off of two things; a Stanley Cup run (built largely off the backs of guys like Rick Dudley and, imagine this, strong drafting) and his willingness to do what ownership wants. A good GM would have told ownership from the start that this team needs a tear it down and build approach, but ownership didn't want that. They wanted to retool and go for a cup run year after year. Feaster knew it and told him they could do it. Likely was the only decent applicant who told them that while flashing his big ring in their eyes and presto, he has a job.
Jay Feaster is actually the worst GM currently employed in the league when it comes to his drafting record. He was GM for seven drafts in Tampa Bay (2002-2008) and again three now with the Flames.
I won't discuss his time with Calgary yet, as it is a bit early to truly assess those drafts (typically you give it five years after a draft to do a review) but in his time in Tampa Bay the club made 62 selections. Of those, 23 made the NHL, which is a rate of 37 per cent. On the surface that sounds good, but if you take 164 games (the equivalent of two full seasons) as a status for success for a skater and 82 games (the equivalent of one full season) for a goalie, then only Fredrik Norrena, Paul Ranger, Nick Tarnasky, Ryan Craig, Mike Lundin, and Steven Stamkos have reached those levels, and only Stamkos made it as a core player (maybe Ranger briefly as well). And at 1st overall, almost all picks pan out (minus the Alexandre Daigle's and Patrik Stefan's).
His drafting success level is downright brutal. Other than Stamkos, his 1st round picks are Vladmir Michalek, Riku Helenius, and Andy Rogers.
Well to be fair I guess it's going to be another 2-3 yrs before we can really see how Feasters drafts stack up. He took lots of heat for the ROR signing but I read that 6 other GMs offer sheeted him aswell.
All 30 GM's could have offer sheeted him, only he offer sheeted him at that high of a price tag.