Proposal: Three Way | COL - ANA - CHI

[IWantSakicAsMyGM]

Timmins wont replace EJ

Well after longer thought, he might on the IR

I agree that it's unlikely that he'll be as good as EJ, but there's a laundry list of defensemen who weren't finished products at 22 years old, but still turned into legit NHLers. So, unless you want to share your crystal ball and can prove Timmins won't ever get there, I'm still putting him in the list of potential replacements. And with Makar on the 1st pairing, all we really need him to be is a 2nd/3rd pairing RHD who can PK, which isn't an extremely high bar.

 

[TLEH]

No interest in Compher at the price he's at, and certainly not to retain 50% for Getz.

 

[63 others]

I agree that it's unlikely that he'll be as good as EJ, but there's a laundry list of defensemen who weren't finished products at 22 years old, but still turned into legit NHLers. So, unless you want to share your crystal ball and can prove Timmins won't ever get there, I'm still putting him in the list of potential replacements. And with Makar on the 1st pairing, all we really need him to be is a 2nd/3rd pairing RHD who can PK, which isn't an extremely high bar.

Well i know his potential

It was more of a sarcastic note about his injury history which concerns me