Nope, disagree wholeheartedly. Vokoun sucked. Horrific puck handler too. Not to mention Anderson was outplaying him at the end there when we let Anderson go. Proven after that too, when they went their separate ways whom we should’ve stayed with.
You can disagree with me all you want, the objective measures disagree with you. Yeah Vokoun let in a bad goal here and there, but he was still clearly and objectively better than Anderson.
Anderson is a 1A/B goalie at best. Vokoun was legitimately a top-10 goalie for a lot of years and one of the top workhorses in the league during his prime.
And after Anderson left, Vokoun still had better stats the following year, and substantially better stats following that year. Anderson's best year came the following year in Colorado (2009-10) where he posted a .917 SV% and a 2.64 GAA in 71 games (the most he's played in a season); Vokoun put up a .925 SV% and a 2.55 GAA in 63 games. The year after that Anderson had an .897 SV% and 3.28 GAA in 33 games with Colorado before being traded to Ottawa where had a very good .939 and 2.05...in 18 games, for a yearly total of .913 and 2.83 in 51 games; Vokoun had a 9.22 and 2.55 in 57 games. In the next two years before he retired, Vokoun put up a .917 and .919 and 2.51 and 2.45 with Washington and Pittsburgh (48 and 20 games, respectively). Anderson put up a .914 and 2.84 in 63 games in 2011-12 and .941 and 1.69 in 24 games. The following year Anderson put up a .911 and 3.00 in 53 games. His best season after Vokoun retired is probably 2015-16 where he played 60 games and had a .916 and 2.78, the only other season he played more than 50 games he had an .898 and 3.32, and another season of exactly 50 games with a .903 and 3.51. And this is ignoring their time with the Panthers, where each of Vokoun's seasons is better than any full season Anderson has ever had.
Anderson is a guy who can catch fire for short times and look like Patrick Roy, but he's not a consistent starter. You can prefer Anderson, that's cool, but Vokoun was a better goalie.