VanJack
Registered User
- Jul 11, 2014
- 21,613
- 15,040
Initially i thought Grenier was a close comparable (and i still do to a degree) but i'm noticing a few differences.
For starters, out of Jr. Grenier was noted as a big skilled forward BUT one thing to note is he isn't overly physical dispute his size. MacEwen on the other hand is actually similar to Mallet in that he plays physical and uses his size. Of course unlike Mallet, he was a lot more productive before his overage season (Mallet had 19pts in 60 games vs MacEwen 40pts in 66 games).
Basically MacEwen seems more like a combo of the 2. He's more polish than Mallet and likely more skilled than Mallet was (also bigger frame) but probably not as physical (Mallet had an edge and probably was closer to being a goon than a power forward before his overage year). On the flip side when you compare him to Grenier, he's much more physical. One stat that can prove this is the fact Grenier only had 42 PIM in his final season, 6 in 31 games the season before)... MacEwen had 56 and 90.
Also one other difference/similarity is Mallet played both C/RW... MacEwen plays C/RW as well. Grenier is basically just a RW. Its easier for a C to move to the wing but much harder for a winger to move to C. That flexibility could be the difference in making Utica (next year) or being sent to the ECHL.
Right now as it stands, i think Labate is the only C in Utica with much size and i believe he played most of the year on LW. Unless Utica adds some size in the off season, they probably could use a big physical center (or even RW to replace Grenier who will be a UFA, again Utica lacks size as a team, something that i'm sure Bennnig will want to address).
I realize there's a tendency to try and compare all of the over-age forwards the Canucks have signed out of the Q, but don't really see much comparison between MacEwan and guys like Grenier, Mallet and P.C. Labrie who played wing.
For one thing, MacEwan is a natural centre and that's the position he's primarily played....doubt the Canucks would have signed him if he'd been a winger....big cenrtres with skill and skating ability are usually far more prized as prospects, which explains why a few more NHL teams other than the Canucks were in on him.