Toggle sidebar

Teams that Won every Trophy?

KirkAlbuquerque

KirkAlbuquerque

#WeNeverGetAGoodCoach
Mar 12, 2014
32,849
38,008
New York
Rangers

Art Ross Trophy - None. Jagr lost by 2 points in 2006
Bill Masterton Memorial Trophy - several times, most recently Dom Moore in 2014
Calder Memorial Trophy - Brian Leetch 1989
Conn Smythe Trophy - Brian Leetch 1994
Frank J. Selke Trophy - None
Hart Memorial Trophy - Messier 1992 (Jagr robbed in 2006)
Jack Adams Award - none. #WeNeverGetAGoodCoach
James Norris Memorial Trophy -most recently in Leetch 1997
King Clancy Memorial Trophy - Adam Graves 1994
Lady Byng Memorial Trophy - many, most recently 99 in '99
Mark Messier Leadership Award - ironically , none
Maurice Richard Trophy - none, Jagr missed by 2 goals in 2006 to the immortal Jonathan Cheechoo
Presidents' Trophy - several , most recently 2015
Stanley Cup - 1994
Ted Lindsay/Pearson - Jagr in 2006
Vezina Trophy - Hank in 2012
William M. Jennings Trophy - never

So missing the Selke, Rocket, Art Ross, Jennings, Jack Adams, Messier
 
DownIsTheNewUp

DownIsTheNewUp

Registered User
Mar 27, 2017
2,285
5,700
Tampa
As noted Tampa is missing a few but has done pretty well filling this out.

Art Ross - St. Louis (x2), Kucherov
Masterton - Cullen
Calder - None
Conn Smythe - Richards
Selke - None
Hart - St. Louis, Kucherov
Jack Adams - Tortorella
Norris - Hedman
Clancy - Lecavalier
Lady Byng - Richards, St. Louis (x3)
Messier - None
Richard - Lecavalier, Stamkos (x2)
Presidents' Trophy - 2019
Stanley Cup -2004
Lindsay/Pearson - St. Louis, Kucherov
Vezina - Vasilevskiy
Jennings - None
GM - Yzerman
 

Skate2Stick

Registered User
Oct 12, 2013
458
384
The oilers must be close but I know they are at least missing the Calder. Which is funny because they had Gretzky and mcdavid. But maybe they are missing quite a few.
 
Hattrick Kane

Hattrick Kane

Registered User
Oct 8, 2018
8,950
13,015
Blackhawks are close, going with who won it last

Art Ross - Kane (2016)
Masterton - Bryan Berard (2004)
Calder - Panarin (2016)
Conn Smythe - Keith (2015)
Selke - Toews (2013)
Hart - Kane (2016)
Jack Adams - Orval Tessier (1983)
Norris - Keith (2014)
Clancy - No one
Lady Byng - Stan Mikita (1968)
Messier - Toews (2015)
Richard - No one, Hull would have a bunch were it around
Presidents Trophy - 2013
Stanley Cup - 2015
Lindsay/Pearson - Kane (2016)
Vezina - Ed Belfour (1993)
Jennings - Crawford (2015)
GM - No one.

Only missing the Clancy, GM and Richard isn’t bad.
 

kaiser matias

Registered User
Mar 22, 2004
4,727
1,871
Larry Hanson said:
Iginla had the most goals and points and was an absolute beast, even if he wasn't #1 he should have been at least 5th place on every ballot.


https://thehockeywriters.com/flames-jarome-iginla-2002-hart-trophy-snub/
Click to expand...

Not to discredit Iginla, but he was also fed the puck the last few weeks of the season once the Flames were eliminated, in an attempt to help him secure the Richard and Art Ross Trophies. Theodore was helping drag the Canadiens to the playoffs when there was no one else on the team worthwhile (recall this was the year Koivu had cancer and only played 3 games). Both certainly deserved votes.

And you'll notice that the quote you have says "unconfirmed rumours", which have never been proven, and no one has ever been able to make any progress with that.

Lastly, there were 62 ballots for the Hart Trophy that year. Iginla was on 61 of them (voting: 23+18+12+5+3). Theodore was on 58 (26+16+9+5+2). So I was actually wrong here, Theodore was left of 4 ballots, while Iginla was left off 1. Yet no one accuses Alberta writers of leaving Theodore off their ballots, even though that suggestion is equally valid.

And I will state that I have no real care for either side of this debate, I just find the complaining that Iginla was "robbed" dishonest, and outright misleading.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Macho Man
theicebox

theicebox

#MonixWatch
Jan 8, 2010
2,829
1,121
Pittsburgh
Art Ross Trophy: Mario Lemieux (x6), Jaromir Jagr (x5), Sidney Crosby (x2), Evgeni Malkin (x2)
Bill Masterton Memorial Trophy: Lowell MacDonald, Mario Lemieux
Calder Memorial Trophy: Mario Lemieux, Evgeni Malkin
Conn Smythe Trophy: Mario Lemieux (x2), Evgeni Malkin, Sidney Crosby (x2)
Frank J. Selke Trophy: Ron Francis
Hart Memorial Trophy: Mario Lemieux (x3), Jaromir Jagr, Sidney Crosby (x2), Evgeni Malkin
Jack Adams Award: Dan Bylsma
James Norris Memorial Trophy: Randy Carlyle
King Clancy Memorial Trophy: not yet
Lady Byng Memorial Trophy: Rick Kehoe, Ron Francis (x2)
Mark Messier Leadership Award: Sidney Crosby
Maurice Richard Trophy: Sidney Crosby (x2)
Presidents' Trophy: 1993
Stanley Cup: 1991, 1992, 2009, 2016, 2017
Ted Lindsay/Pearson: Mario Lemieux (x4), Jaromir Jagr (x2), Sidney Crosby (x3), Evgeni Malkin
Vezina Trophy: not yet
William M. Jennings Trophy: not yet

The Penguins are missing the King Clancy Trophy, Vezina Trophy, and Jennings Trophy.

Tom Barrasso notably won both the Vezina and Jennings trophies, but he was not with the Penguins during then.

Bryan Trottier notably won the King Clancy Trophy right before his time with the Penguins.

Ron Francis notably won the King Clancy Trophy right after his time with the Penguins.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mitch nylander

Passchendaele

Registered User
Dec 11, 2006
7,731
1,149
KirkAlbuquerque said:
Rangers

Art Ross Trophy - None. Jagr lost by 2 points in 2006

So missing the Selke, Rocket, Art Ross, Jennings, Jack Adams, Messier
Click to expand...

Andy Bathgate tied Bobby Hull with 84 points in 1962. But yeah, you guessed it, Hull 'won' it because he had more goals.

It's as good as winning it IMO.
 
Treb

Treb

Global Flanderator
May 31, 2011
28,384
28,308
Montreal
:habs
Art Ross Trophy: Elmer Lach, Bernie Geoffrion x2, Jean Béliveau, Dickie Moore x2, Lafleur x3
Bill Masterton Memorial Trophy: Claude Provost, Henri Richard, Serge Savard, Saku Koivu, Max Pacioretty
Calder Memorial Trophy: Bernie Geoffrion, Ralph Backstrom, Bobby Rousseau, Jacques Lapperrière, Ken Dryden
Conn Smythe Trophy: Jean Béliveau, Serge Savard, Ken Dryden, Yvan Cournoyer, Guy Lafleur, Larry Robinson, Bob Gainey, Patrick Roy x2
Frank J. Selke Trophy: Bob Gainey x4, Guy Carbonneau x3
Hart Memorial Trophy: Herb Gardiner, Howie Morenz x3 , Aurèle Joliat, Babe Siebert, Toe Blake, Elmer Lach, Maurice Richard, Jean Béliveau x2, Bernie Geoffrion, Jacques Plante, Guy Lafleur x2, José Théodore, Carey Price
Jack Adams Award: Scotty Bowman, Pat Burns
James Norris Memorial Trophy: Doug Harvey x6, Tom Johnson, Jacques Lapperrière, Larry Robinson x2, Chris Chelios, PK Subban
King Clancy Memorial Trophy: Saku Koivu
Lady Byng Memorial Trophy: Toe Blake, Mats Naslund
Mark Messier Leadership Award: None
Maurice Richard Trophy: None
Presidents' Trophy: None
Stanley Cup: Montreal Canadiens x24
Ted Lindsay/Pearson: Lafleur x3, Carey Price
Vezina Trophy: George Hainsworth x3, Bill Durnan x6, Jacques Plante x6, Charlie Hodge x2, Gump Worsley x2, Rogatien Vachon, Ken Dryden x5, Michel Larocque x4, Denis Herron, Richard Sévigny, Patrick Roy x2, José Théodore, Carey Price
William M. Jennings Trophy: Rick Wamsley, Denis Herron, Patrick Roy x 4, Brian Hayward x3, Carey Price

Montreal Canadiens have had top goalscorers (16 times), top seasons (21 times including best of all-time) and great leaders (Jean Béliveau would have definitely won a few), but before those trophies existed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jee
Mitch nylander

Mitch nylander

One of the biggest fans from a bipolar fanbase
Jun 2, 2016
4,508
5,892
I almost don't want to make a list for the leafs cause it'll be sad since we've been a franchise for 103 years.

Art Ross Trophy: None
Bill Masterton Memorial Trophy: Jason Blake
Calder Memorial Trophy: Syl Apps, Gaye Stewart, Gus Bodnar, Frank Mccool, Howie Meeker, Frank Mahovlich , Dave Keon, Kent Douglas, Brit Selby, Auston Matthews
Conn Smythe Trophy: Dave Keon
Frank J. Selke Trophy: Doug Gilmour
Hart Memorial Trophy: Babe Pratt, Ted Kennedy,
Jack Adams Award: Pat Burns
James Norris Memorial Trophy: None
King Clancy Memorial Trophy: Curtis Joseph
Lady Byng Memorial Trophy: Joe Primeau, Gordie Drillon, Syl Apps, Sid Smith (2x), Red Kelly, Dave Keon (2x), Alexander Mogilny
Mark Messier Leadership Award: Mats Sundin
Maurice Richard Trophy: None
Presidents' Trophy: None, but we have led the league 5x prior to the trophy
Stanley Cup: 13x
Ted Lindsay/Pearson: None
Vezina Trophy: Turk Broda (2x), Al Rollins, Harry Lumley, Johnny Bower (2x) and Terry Sawchuk,
William M. Jennings Trophy: None

-------------------------------------------

No Rocket Winner, but we did have goal scoring leaders prior to the invention of the trophy. Those winners being; Babe Dye (3x), Ace Bailey, Charlie Conacher (5x), Bill Thoms, Gordie Drillon and Gaye Stewart.

No Art Ross Winner, but like the rocket we have some winners prior to the trophy. These winners are; Babe Dye (2x), Ace Bailey, Harvey Jackson, Charlie Conacher (2x) and Gordie Drillon

Trophies technically missing - Art Ross, Norris, Rocket, President's Trophy, Ted Lindsay, William M Jennings.
--
Auston Matthews likely wins a few Rocket Richards. The others won't be won for a while. Maybe an outside shot to Marner for the ross.
 
Hockey Outsider

Hockey Outsider

Registered User
Jan 16, 2005
9,155
14,477
KirkAlbuquerque said:
Rangers

Art Ross Trophy - None. Jagr lost by 2 points in 2006
Maurice Richard Trophy - none, Jagr missed by 2 goals in 2006 to the immortal Jonathan Cheechoo
Click to expand...

A Ranger (Bill Cook) led the NHL in goals twice and points twice - long before the Art Ross and Maurice Richard trophy were created. I'm not too picky about this one - those are statistical trophies, the accomplishment (leading the league in a statistical category) took place regardless of whether a trophy was handed out or not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bobholly39
Jonesey

Jonesey

R.I.P. Steve AKA Pred303
Feb 17, 2009
12,877
1,319
Tennessee
I have a spreadsheet for this!

Stanley CupPresident'sWales CampbellConn SmytheHartCalderVezinaNorrisArt RossSelke
Anaheim Ducks1 ; 2007--2 ; 20072 ; 20071 ; 2011-----
Arizona Coyotes-----------
Boston Bruins6 ; 20112 ; 201418 ; 2019-3 ; 201112 ; 19748 ; 200410 ; 201414 ; 20097 ; 19755 ; 2017
Buffalo Sabres-1 ; 20073 ; 1999--2 ; 19983 ; 20109 ; 2010--2 ; 1997
Calgary Flames1 ; 19892 ; 1989-3 ; 20041 ; 1989-3 ; 19901 ; 20061 ; 20191 ; 2002-
Carolina Hurricanes1 ; 2006-2 ; 2006-1 ; 2006-1 ; 2011---2 ; 2007
Chicago Blackhawks6 ; 20152 ; 20132 ; 19707 ; 20153 ; 20157 ; 20169 ; 201610 ; 19938 ; 20149 ; 20163 ; 2013
Colorado Avalanche2 ; 20012 ; 2001-2 ; 20012 ; 20012 ; 20033 ; 2014--1 ; 2003-
Columbus Blue Jackets------1 ; 20092 ; 2017---
Dallas Stars1 ; 19992 ; 1999-3 ; 20001 ; 1999----1 ; 20153 ; 2003
Detroit Red Wings11 ; 20085 ; 200813 ; 19656 ; 20095 ; 20089 ; 19945 ; 19655 ; 19559 ; 20117 ; 19637 ; 2010
Edmonton Oilers5 ; 19902 ; 1987-7 ; 20064 ; 199010 ; 2017-1 ; 19882 ; 19869 ; 2018-
Florida Panthers--1 ; 1996---2 ; 2015----
Los Angeles Kings2 ; 2014--3 ; 20142 ; 20141 ; 19891 ; 1987-2 ; 20164 ; 19912 ; 2018
Minnesota Wild-----------
Montreal Canadiens24 ; 1993-25 ; 1993-9 ; 199317 ; 20156 ; 197229 ; 201512 ; 20139 ; 19787 ; 1992
Nashville Predators-1 ; 2018-1 ; 2017---1 ; 2018---
New Jersey Devils3 ; 2003-5 ; 2012-2 ; 20001 ; 20182 ; 20004 ; 20081 ; 2004-1 ; 2001
New York Islanders4 ; 1983-3 ; 19843 ; 19814 ; 19831 ; 19795 ; 20181 ; 19823 ; 19791 ; 19791 ; 2002
New York Rangers4 ; 19943 ; 20154 ; 2014-1 ; 19944 ; 19927 ; 19894 ; 20124 ; 1992--
Ottawa Senators-1 ; 20031 ; 2007---1 ; 1996-2 ; 2015--
Philadelphia Flyers2 ; 1975-4 ; 20106 ; 19804 ; 19874 ; 1995-4 ; 1987--2 ; 1987
Pittsburgh Penguins5 ; 20171 ; 19936 ; 2017-5 ; 20177 ; 20142 ; 2007-1 ; 198115 ; 20141 ; 1995
San Jose Sharks-1 ; 2009-1 ; 2016-1 ; 20061 ; 2001-1 ; 20171 ; 2006-
St Louis Blues1 ; 20191 ; 2000-3 ; 20192 ; 20192 ; 20001 ; 20031 ; 19692 ; 2000-2 ; 2019
Tampa Bay Lightning1 ; 20041 ; 20192 ; 2015-1 ; 20042 ; 2019-1 ; 20191 ; 20183 ; 2019-
Toronto Maple Leafs13 ; 1967-2 ; 1963-1 ; 19672 ; 195510 ; 20176 ; 1965--1 ; 1993
Vancouver Canucks-2 ; 2012-3 ; 2011-1 ; 20102 ; 2019--2 ; 20111 ; 2011
Vegas Golden Knights---1 ; 2018-------
Washington Capitals1 ; 20183 ; 20172 ; 2018-1 ; 20183 ; 20131 ; 20063 ; 20162 ; 19841 ; 20081 ; 1984
Winnipeg Jets-----------
[TBODY] [/TBODY]
Lady ByngJack AdamsRocket RichardKing ClancyTed LindsayJenningsMessierGM OTYMastertonNHL Foundation
Anaheim Ducks2 ; 1997-2 ; 2011--1 ; 2016-1 ; 20141 ; 2006-
Arizona Coyotes-2 ; 2010-1 ; 2010--1 ; 20121 ; 2010--
Boston Bruins8 ; 19823 ; 2009-3 ; 20133 ; 19752 ; 20091 ; 20111 ; 20194 ; 20071 ; 2014
Buffalo Sabres1 ; 19732 ; 2006-1 ; 19992 ; 19983 ; 2001--2 ; 19951 ; 2010
Calgary Flames4 ; 20171 ; 20152 ; 20043 ; 20041 ; 20021 ; 20061 ; 2009-2 ; 19962 ; 2016
Carolina Hurricanes1 ; 2002--1 ; 2002-----1 ; 2002
Chicago Blackhawks8 ; 19681 ; 1983--1 ; 20165 ; 20151 ; 2015-2 ; 2004-
Colorado Avalanche2 ; 20141 ; 20141 ; 2003-1 ; 20011 ; 2002---1 ; 2007
Columbus Blue Jackets-1 ; 20171 ; 20041 ; 2017--1 ; 2017--1 ; 2009
Dallas Stars-----1 ; 1999---1 ; 2006
Detroit Red Wings14 ; 20094 ; 1996-2 ; 20152 ; 19942 ; 20081 ; 2007-2 ; 20032 ; 2013
Edmonton Oilers2 ; 19851 ; 1986-3 ; 20148 ; 2018-----
Florida Panthers2 ; 2019-2 ; 2001-----1 ; 2016-
Los Angeles Kings6 ; 20161 ; 1975-1 ; 19912 ; 19802 ; 20181 ; 2014-3 ; 19911 ; 2011
Minnesota Wild-1 ; 2003-1 ; 2019-1 ; 2007--2 ; 2015-
Montreal Canadiens2 ; 19882 ; 1989-1 ; 20074 ; 20156 ; 2015--5 ; 2012-
Nashville Predators------2 ; 20191 ; 20171 ; 20091 ; 2012
New Jersey Devils-1 ; 1994---5 ; 2010--2 ; 2018-
New York Islanders4 ; 19932 ; 2019-2 ; 2011-2 ; 2019--3 ; 20191 ; 2017
New York Rangers14 ; 1999--1 ; 19943 ; 2006---5 ; 20141 ; 2000
Ottawa Senators-2 ; 2013-1 ; 2012--1 ; 2013-1 ; 2017-
Philadelphia Flyers-4 ; 2001--2 ; 19952 ; 2003--3 ; 2011-
Pittsburgh Penguins3 ; 19981 ; 20112 ; 2017-10 ; 2014-1 ; 20102 ; 20162 ; 1993-
San Jose Sharks--1 ; 2006-----1 ; 19971 ; 2015
St Louis Blues3 ; 20003 ; 2012-1 ; 19982 ; 19912 ; 2012-1 ; 20122 ; 19981 ; 1998
Tampa Bay Lightning4 ; 20131 ; 20043 ; 20121 ; 20082 ; 2019--1 ; 20151 ; 19991 2008
Toronto Maple Leafs9 ; 20031 ; 1993-1 ; 2000--1 ; 2008-1 ; 2008-
Vancouver Canucks-2 ; 2007-3 ; 20182 ; 20111 ; 2011-1 ; 2011-1 ; 2008
Vegas Golden Knights1 ; 20181 ; 2018----1 ; 20181 ; 2018--
Washington Capitals-3 ; 20168 ; 20191 ; 20063 ; 20102 ; 2017--1 ; 20101 ; 2001
Winnipeg Jets----------
[TBODY] [/TBODY]
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Ryan Michaels, Hockey Outsider, qwerty and 2 others
The Macho King

The Macho King

Back* to Back** World Champion
Jun 22, 2011
48,776
29,312
KirkAlbuquerque said:
Rangers

Art Ross Trophy - None. Jagr lost by 2 points in 2006
Bill Masterton Memorial Trophy - several times, most recently Dom Moore in 2014
Calder Memorial Trophy - Brian Leetch 1989
Conn Smythe Trophy - Brian Leetch 1994
Frank J. Selke Trophy - None
Hart Memorial Trophy - Messier 1992 (Jagr robbed in 2006)
Jack Adams Award - none. #WeNeverGetAGoodCoach
James Norris Memorial Trophy -most recently in Leetch 1997
King Clancy Memorial Trophy - Adam Graves 1994
Lady Byng Memorial Trophy - many, most recently 99 in '99
Mark Messier Leadership Award - ironically , none
Maurice Richard Trophy - none, Jagr missed by 2 goals in 2006 to the immortal Jonathan Cheechoo
Presidents' Trophy - several , most recently 2015
Stanley Cup - 1994
Ted Lindsay/Pearson - Jagr in 2006
Vezina Trophy - Hank in 2012
William M. Jennings Trophy - never

So missing the Selke, Rocket, Art Ross, Jennings, Jack Adams, Messier
Click to expand...
Bathgate actually tied for it with Bobby Hull (Art Ross) but lost due to goals.

I think there are probably a retro Ross and Selke with Boucher and Bill Cook but those don't count for this I guess.
 
Jee

Jee

uwu
Aug 25, 2006
30,056
12,816
Montréal
Treb said:
:habs
Art Ross Trophy: Elmer Lach, Bernie Geoffrion x2, Jean Béliveau, Dickie Moore x2, Lafleur x3
Bill Masterton Memorial Trophy: Claude Provost, Henri Richard, Serge Savard, Saku Koivu, Max Pacioretty
Calder Memorial Trophy: Bernie Geoffrion, Ralph Backstrom, Bobby Rousseau, Jacques Lapperrière, Ken Dryden
Conn Smythe Trophy: Jean Béliveau, Serge Savard, Ken Dryden, Yvan Cournoyer, Guy Lafleur, Larry Robinson, Bob Gainey, Patrick Roy x2
Frank J. Selke Trophy: Bob Gainey x4, Guy Carbonneau x3
Hart Memorial Trophy: Herb Gardiner, Howie Morenz x3 , Aurèle Joliat, Babe Siebert, Toe Blake, Elmer Lach, Maurice Richard, Jean Béliveau x2, Bernie Geoffrion, Jacques Plante, Guy Lafleur x2, José Théodore, Carey Price
Jack Adams Award: Scotty Bowman, Pat Burns
James Norris Memorial Trophy: Doug Harvey x6, Tom Johnson, Jacques Lapperrière, Larry Robinson x2, Chris Chelios, PK Subban
King Clancy Memorial Trophy: Saku Koivu
Lady Byng Memorial Trophy: Toe Blake, Mats Naslund
Mark Messier Leadership Award: None
Maurice Richard Trophy: None
Presidents' Trophy: None
Stanley Cup: Montreal Canadiens x24
Ted Lindsay/Pearson: Lafleur x3, Carey Price
Vezina Trophy: George Hainsworth x3, Bill Durnan x6, Jacques Plante x6, Charlie Hodge x2, Gump Worsley x2, Rogatien Vachon, Ken Dryden x5, Michel Larocque x4, Denis Herron, Richard Sévigny, Patrick Roy x2, José Théodore, Carey Price
William M. Jennings Trophy: Rick Wamsley, Denis Herron, Patrick Roy x 4, Brian Hayward x3, Carey Price

Montreal Canadiens have had top goalscorers (16 times), top seasons (21 times including best of all-time) and great leaders (Jean Béliveau would have definitely won a few), but before those trophies existed.
Click to expand...

My god are we good at producing goalies
 
ChuckLefley

ChuckLefley

Registered User
Jan 5, 2016
1,665
1,038
Matchbox 18 said:
The blues only missing the art ross,messier,Richard trophies. Not bad for 52 years of futility until last year lol.


Art Ross Trophy-none
Bill Masterton Memorial Trophy-Blake Dunlop,Jamie mcClennan
Calder Memorial Trophy-Barrett jackman
Conn Smythe Trophy-Ryan o’reilly
Frank J. Selke Trophy-Rick meagher,Ryan o’rielly
Hart Memorial Trophy-Brett hull
Jack Adams Award-red berenson,Brian sutter,Joel quennville,ken Hitchcock
James Norris Memorial Trophy-Al macinnis,Chris pronger
King Clancy Memorial Trophy-Kelly chase
Lady Byng Memorial Trophy-Phil goyette,Brett hull,pavol demitra
Mark Messier Leadership Award-none
Maurice Richard Trophy-none
Presidents' Trophy-99/00
Stanley Cup-19
Ted Lindsay/Pearson-Mike liut,brett hull
Vezina Trophy-Jacque plante
William M. Jennings Trophy-Roman turek,Brian Elliot,jaro halak
Click to expand...
Technically you can say we won the Richard since we had the goal scoring leader on a few occasions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Matchbox 18
You must log in or register to reply here.

Ad

Latest posts

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

Top Bottom