Superline 1 vs Superline 2

[jvcjdudu jcycyxjene]

Which would you rather have? I'm kind of pissing in the wind here but I'm curious.

Click to read more...

 

[McVespa99]

McDavid. But damn that #1 is scary too

 

[34]

Both.

 

[CanadienShark]

I'm so tempted by the first group, but logic lead me to McDavid's group.

 

[jvcjdudu jcycyxjene]

Surprised to see it so lopsided. I have it:

Pasta > Tkachuk
Mack < McDavid
Rants > Marner

 

[CraigsList]

Man, that second line would be a beauty to watch. Hard to not vote for them, but you have to think that all 3 need to have the puck for long periods of time. I still went with them, because McDavid.

 

[filinski77]

Surprised to see it so lopsided. I have it:

Pasta > Tkachuk
Mack < McDavid
Rants > Marner

Always so hard to do one vs. one matchups, I'd rate it as:

McDavid

Mackinnon
Marner/Rantanen
Pastrnak
Tkachuk

I'd take McDavids line, it is close however and you definitely don't go wrong with either.

 

[Echo Roku]

That first line isn’t as good as the Avs actual first line. Not because of skill, but because Pastrnak doesn’t fill the same role as Landeskog does and helps the line thrive

 

[tony d]

Close but Group 2 for me.

 

[Conspiracy Theorist]

Who's gonna score for group 2?

 

[The Moose is Loose]

the 2nd line easily

 

[CantLoseWithMatthews]

Smart players change up their game to make their line better. Any of Tkachuk, McDavid, or Marner could become goal scoring threats if they had to

 

[Makar Goes Fast]

Surprised to see it so lopsided. I have it:

Pasta > Tkachuk
Mack < McDavid
Rants > Marner

in my eyes, this is the correct answer

 

[Jetcetera]

I'd take Pastrnak, Mackinnon and Rantanen. I don't think McDavid is that much better than Mackinnon to justify taking that line when Pastrnak and Rantanen are much better than Tkachuk and Marner

 

[780il]

Easily Line 2. Tkachuk and Mcdavid combine the best of both worlds. Add in Marner and its no question the 2nd option.

 

[authentic]

Yeah 2 easy for me.

 

[ricky0034]

Smart players change up their game to make their line better. Any of Tkachuk, McDavid, or Marner could become goal scoring threats if they had to

plus McDavid already is one

he finished last season with more goals than anyone else in this thread,and will likely have 40+ again this year

 

[WetcoastOrca]

I’d take the best player. McDavid.

 

[Taluss]

Ill take either on the Sens please

Edit: Went line 1

Pasta> Tkachuk
Mack< Mcdavid
Rantanen> Marner

 

[bukwas]

I don't often vote against McDavid (even when grouped) but this is 1 exception.

 

[missionAvs]

Tough one but I have:

Pasta > Tkachuk
MacK << McJesus
Rants > Marner

I honestly think this is about as dead even as it'll get. Line #2 has the clear best player but they also have the worst player of the group in Tkachuk.

McJesus >> MacK >= Rants >= Pasta = Marner >> Tkachuk.

 

[BostonBruins11]

Always so hard to do one vs. one matchups, I'd rate it as:

McDavid

Mackinnon
Marner/Rantanen
Pastrnak
Tkachuk

I'd take McDavids line, it is close however and you definitely don't go wrong with either.

Fixed

McDavid

Mackinnon
Pastrnak/Rantanen
Marner
Tkachuk

 

[authentic]

Who's gonna score for group 2?

McDavid had more goals last season than Tavares ever had and you don't think there would be tons of goals with Marner on his line?

 

[Plural]

Marner, McDavid and a traffic cone please.

 

[Plural]

Smart players change up their game to make their line better. Any of Tkachuk, McDavid, or Marner could become goal scoring threats if they had to

McDavid already is. Marner is equal to Rants (I was wrong to doubt him) and Tkachuk will score with his ass with those two.