Proposal: Stl-Tor

[StlBill]

With Gunnarson coming back on a very team friendly deal, I think we’re going to deal from a strength and possibly deal Edmundson. I love the guy and over the last three years he’s played a lot on the #1 pairing with Petro. He regressed some this year, but I think he bounces back. What to leafs fans think of something along the lines of:
Edmundson & Fabbri
for
Kapanen +

Reason for including Robby is he could use a fresh start (wouldn’t necessarily have a guaranteed spot and him and Eddie are best buds. Fabbri could thrive with Marner & JT IMO.

Thoughts?

Click to read more...

 

[DingDongCharlie]

Why does Toronto want another LD?

 

[WTFMAN99]

Doesn't really help Toronto. We need a RHD.

 

[TorontoTrades]

Pietrangelo and Parayko were the two that made sense.

Definitely not available after that cup run.

So blues and leafs deal doesn't make sense anymore

 

[Colt55]

Pietrangelo and Parayko were the two that made sense.

Definitely not available after that cup run.

So blues and leafs deal doesn't make sense anymore

They were never available. That's the funny part.

 

[BleedBlue14]

Only thing that makes sense for Toronto that would be expendable from us would probably be Schmaltz for very cheap if someone in Toronto beleives in Schmaltz

 

[simon IC]

Why does Toronto want another LD?

Take away Edmundson and substitute Reinke +?

 

[TheBluePenguin]

Pietrangelo and Parayko were the two that made sense.

Definitely not available after that cup run.

So blues and leafs deal doesn't make sense anymore

Those two make sense on every team in the league lol

 

[Falco Lombardi]

If Edmundson was right handed, maybe Toronto would be interested.

But even then, I feel like we couldn’t pry Kapanen away, which is unfortunate. I’d love to have Kappy on the Blues.

 

[ktownhockey]

If Edmundson was right handed, maybe Toronto would be interested.

But even then, I feel like we couldn’t pry Kapanen away, which is unfortunate. I’d love to have Kappy on the Blues.

I like that look. I think if it were Kappy going for Ed it would be Ed plus something pretty good (potential) or someone (Prospect or player) out of favour.

 

[Colt55]

I like that look. I think if it were Kappy going for Ed it would be Ed plus something pretty good (potential) or someone (Prospect or player) out of favour.

Why Edmondson is top 4 and has been top pairing is young and tough which Toronto sorely lacks. But to say you need a significant add then your off. Just not a match besides I hear Montreal is interested and then he will be your problem.

 

[Falco Lombardi]

Why Edmondson is top 4 and has been top pairing is young and tough which Toronto sorely lacks. But to say you need a significant add then your off. Just not a match besides I hear Montreal is interested and then he will be your problem.

That’s relatively disingenuous after the season Edmundson just had. In no way was he top 4 a year ago.

 

[Colt55]

That’s relatively disingenuous after the season Edmundson just had. In no way was he top 4 a year ago.

He was top pairing with petro last year and this year. He was better last year had a set back this year towards the end but played top pairing mins how am I being disingenuous

 

[ktownhockey]

Why Edmondson is top 4 and has been top pairing is young and tough which Toronto sorely lacks. But to say you need a significant add then your off. Just not a match besides I hear Montreal is interested and then he will be your problem.

Agree to disagree I guess. I like Edmonson, the significant add I meant was on the low level like a 2nd round pick and we add a pick for a Schmaltz like player. I feel those are significant. Could be wrong value wise but for the leafs to trade Kap it would take that I think.

Kap, 2020 4th
Edmondson, 2021 2 nd

If not, no worries lol Habs can have him.

 

[Colt55]

Agree to disagree I guess. I like Edmonson, the significant add I meant was on the low level like a 2nd round pick and we add a pick for a Schmaltz like player. I feel those are significant. Could be wrong value wise but for the leafs to trade Kap it would take that I think.

Kap, 2020 4th
Edmondson, 2021 2 nd

If not, no worries lol Habs can have him.

Oh I thought you meant like a 1st or a list prospect.what you propose is very fair.

 

[ktownhockey]

Oh I thought you meant like a 1st or a list prospect.what you propose is very fair.

I'm a Leafs fan but a realistic one. I don't know if either team does it. We have alot of winger depth so Kap is trade worthy. I think the proposal is fair but won't happen due to the rumoured signing of Kapanen. Hard to trade a dude who took less money. Would love Ed though haha.

 

[Colt55]

I'm a Leafs fan but a realistic one. I don't know if either team does it. We have alot of winger depth so Kap is trade worthy. I think the proposal is fair but won't happen due to the rumoured signing of Kapanen. Hard to trade a dude who took less money. Would love Ed though haha.

The East hates big tough dmen like him

 

[Reality Czech]

Why Edmondson is top 4 and has been top pairing is young and tough which Toronto sorely lacks. But to say you need a significant add then your off. Just not a match besides I hear Montreal is interested and then he will be your problem.

You're still as biased and unreasonable as ever, I see. Come on dude, why you gotta cause problems in every thread? You'd make a great used car salesman though, I'll give ya that.

I like Eddy as much as the next guy but legit top 4 guys aren't usually healthy scratches during the playoffs. His value ain't that high right now.

 

[Dr Quincy]

With Gunnarson coming back on a very team friendly deal, I think we’re going to deal from a strength and possibly deal Edmundson. I love the guy and over the last three years he’s played a lot on the #1 pairing with Petro. He regressed some this year, but I think he bounces back. What to leafs fans think of something along the lines of:
Edmundson & Fabbri
for
Kapanen +

Reason for including Robby is he could use a fresh start (wouldn’t necessarily have a guaranteed spot and him and Eddie are best buds. Fabbri could thrive with Marner & JT IMO.

Thoughts?

TOR doesn't need a LD.
TOR doesn't need Fabbri at all.

They'd rather move Kapanen for what they do need than just do this deal.

 

[Dr Quincy]

He was top pairing with petro last year and this year. He was better last year had a set back this year towards the end but played top pairing mins how am I being disingenuous

Because that's demonstrably false.

 

[Colt55]

You're still as biased and unreasonable as ever, I see. Come on dude, why you gotta cause problems in every thread? You'd make a great used car salesman though, I'll give ya that.

I like Eddy as much as the next guy but legit top 4 guys aren't usually healthy scratches during the playoffs. His value ain't that high right now.

How is displaying my opinion causing trouble. I guess I should just ask you for what and how I think before I type. Good to know. Also I am not here attacking other people like you seem to be doing. So practice what you preach.

If eddy is not top pairing or hasn't been for the last two years please provide evidence to the contrary and I will eat crow.

 

[BlueBaron]

Not ideal but not bad. Dermott will probably be shifted to the right so getting a LHD could work if necessary.

Odd to see a sane proposal with our team.

 

[garyturner3]

They were never available. That's the funny part.

If they didn't turn the ship around like they did, then of course your GM would have considered making some bold moves. There were countless rumors involving both players earlier in the year, some of them from pretty legit insiders too. The majority of them, like any other rumor were probably baseless, but there definitely was some smoke to the Parayko and more-so Petro rumors back in December. In hindsight it was obviously a great decision to stick with the core because on paper they shouldn't have been where they were in the standings and the rest is history!

 

[Blueboy]

How is displaying my opinion causing trouble. I guess I should just ask you for what and how I think before I type. Good to know. Also I am not here attacking other people like you seem to be doing. So practice what you preach.

If eddy is not top pairing or hasn't been for the last two years please provide evidence to the contrary and I will eat crow.

He was healthy scratched in the playoffs, if that isn’t evidence, I don’t know what is.

 

[Falco Lombardi]

He was top pairing with petro last year and this year. He was better last year had a set back this year towards the end but played top pairing mins how am I being disingenuous

He was playing with Petro to start but played very poorly, so poorly that he was moved out off the pairing and at times, was a healthy scratch. Clearly the top 4 was Petro, Parayko, Dunn, and Bouwmeester.

That’s not to say he can’t be that player again, but it is disingenuous to pretend he was something he clearly was not this season.