Proposal: STL-DET

[datsyukfan]

st.louis:

Parayko

Detroit

2019 late 1st (received in Nyquist trade)
NYI 2019 2nd
Andreas Athanasiou

Is this close at all. Who and what needs to be added to bring parayko to Detroit

Click to read more...

 

[StLHokie]

Start with Larkin

 

[WingsMJN2965]

 

[izzy]

value doesnt suck, bit less than parayko is worth but blues wont trade parayko unless its an overpayment

fits the current core and the future core too well

 

[Tatar Shots]

bad for St. Louis. Also, odds of Nyquist returning a 1st are not great.

Start with Larkin

Parayko isn’t remotely near Larkin in Value

 

[Henkka]

Won't work. STL creates the same need for themselves than Detroit has.

 

[StLHokie]

Quite bad for St. Louis. Also, odds of Nyquist returning a 1st are not great.



Parayko isn’t remotely near Larkin in Value

Doesn't matter, Blues don't trade Parayko for anything other than overpayment

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

Start with Larkin

I knew this would be ask, And yet Leaf fans are offering Kapanen+Liljegren for Parayko big difference there.

 

[BlueOil]

trading parayko and leaving a giant hole in our top 4 d isn't exactly a favorable outcome for the blues

the picks are nice and happytoseeyou is a tempting player, but it'd probably be turned down still

 

[datsyukfan]

trading parayko and leaving a giant hole in our top 4 d isn't exactly a favorable outcome for the blues

the picks are nice and happytoseeyou is a tempting player, but it'd probably be turned down still

Ya reason I said it is because I’ve heard that the blues are really unhappy with there lack of prospects and I thought 2 picks picks would help in getting them more kicks at it. Also team speed seems to be a bit of an issue for them so AA becomes attractive. From a wings perspective I would prob add another 2nd or a forward prospect like bergren

 

[BleedBlue14]

Ya reason I said it is because I’ve heard that the blues are really unhappy with there lack of prospects and I thought 2 picks picks would help in getting them more kicks at it. Also team speed seems to be a bit of an issue for them so AA becomes attractive. From a wings perspective I would prob add another 2nd or a forward prospect like bergren

We dont need forward prospects. At all. If anything we need d prospects but considering the trade is asking for a legit #2 right now searching for more prospects in the draft that are defensemen makes absolutely no sense

 

[bellringer77]

I'd do it from a wings side obviously but I would think Hronek would have to go the other way

 

[BlueOil]

Ya reason I said it is because I’ve heard that the blues are really unhappy with there lack of prospects and I thought 2 picks picks would help in getting them more kicks at it.

i'm not sure who your source is, but i think they're a little out of tune. blues are having issues, but mostly with their established players.

Also team speed seems to be a bit of an issue for them so AA becomes attractive. From a wings perspective I would prob add another 2nd or a forward prospect like bergren

team speed is certainly not an asset, but you still miss the mark here. if the blues gave up parayko, some defense would need to be a part of the trade. more forwards or picks does not address that.

 

[780il]

Not close

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

Yeah Detroit would never surrender the pieces to get Colton Parayko, No deal is to be had here.

 

[TK 421]

And right on time is another Parayko to somewhere else thread.

Not interested in moving him, keep your picks. We have multiple young forward prospects each with development time post draft that fit the current cores time line better than the picks would. You know, kind of like Parayko himself.

 

[Vincenzo Arelliti]

Parayko is as close to a top-pairing dman without being one that a player can be. He plays the biggest minutes for us this year and has always done so while Petro has been out. He’s been our best defenseman this year as well. It would take Larkin - whether or not that’s “fair value” is irrelevant.

Personally, my feeling is Parayko and Pietrangelo should be Blues for a long time considering both are top-30 at their position; not only are they valuable in a vacuum, but teams looking to acquire then would have to give us enough to replace them and more since we don’t have internal replacements. Trading either would likely put us on a rebuilding path, which we just can afford to do with most of our core being around 26-27.

 

[Colt55]

I knew this would be ask, And yet Leaf fans are offering Kapanen+Liljegren for Parayko big difference there.

Ksppy liljgren 1st

 

[Man Bear Pig]

I knew this would be ask, And yet Leaf fans are offering Kapanen+Liljegren for Parayko big difference there.

And people said what, that it was fair? Man, the Leafs are living rent-free in your head.

 

[Man Bear Pig]

Ksppy liljgren 1st

Oh look, the other guy obsessed with the Leafs.

 

[stl76]

bad for St. Louis. Also, odds of Nyquist returning a 1st are not great.



Parayko isn’t remotely near Larkin in Value

Not saying Detroit should ever consider dealing Larkin, but he is by far the closest player to Parayko the wings have in terms of 1-for-1 value.

The deal in the OP is laughably bad from a St. Louis perspective.

 

[Celtic Note]

This is terrible for the Blues and what they need to accomplish.

 

[blues hillbilly]

Parayko's best hockey is ahead of him. Doubt if Army would part with Pietrangelo on shorter term for that offer at this point. Bortuzzo is fine as 3 RDman.

We could free up a LD. Gunnar is available for 3rd or Bouwmeister for 2nd, if he waives NMC, but that is about it. Blues anticipate the potential of loosing both of those LDmen next year.

 

[datsyukfan]

Parayko's best hockey is ahead of him. Doubt if Army would part with Pietrangelo on shorter term for that offer at this point. Bortuzzo is fine as 3 RDman.

We could free up a LD. Gunnar is available for 3rd or Bouwmeister for 2nd, if he waives NMC, but that is about it. Blues anticipate the potential of loosing both of those LDmen next year.

Okay what about Dunn for a 2nd and a 4th?

 

[Halak Ness Monster]

Start with Larkin

Parayko for Larkin would be a 1-1 for deal if we're looking to move him.

I doubt DET would move Larkin so there's nothing to see here.

We'll keep our #2 d-man and they'll keep their #1 center