I mean, I have zero reason to lie to a message board about broken controllers?
The only time I ever remember having a broken controller is when I've dropped it in a pitcher of water.
I have had a sticky thumbstick or trigger button before, but I have never had a controller cease to function. I just don't understand what people are doing to have gone through 4-5 controllers per console. That's insane to me.
My baby loves to pick up my controllers and leave them on the floor in my game room and I've stepped on them countless times. No issues. To me, if you're going through several controllers per console (not to even mention in the same like...year period) you're either super, super, super hard on your controller or you've got really bad luck.