Sakic/Forsberg vs Yzerman/Fedorov

[Cursed Lemon]

Fedorov is, unfortunately, the weak link here. If we're talking peak years, all four of them are pretty much equal, because all four of them had all-time peaks. Prime however is another story, because Fedorov (despite possibly having the highest natural talent of all four) had a string of lackadaisical years in the middle of his prime, and all of these players are playoff warriors and defensively impressive players, which are huge parts of Fedorov's resume.

 

[Luigi Lemieux]

This would be closer if Fedorov's prime wasn't so short. From 93-96 or so he was one of the best players in the world, but Sakic, Forsberg, and Yzerman's primes all lasted much longer.