RW Andrei Svechnikov (2018, 2nd, CAR) II

[DudeWhereIsMakar]

I think Svechnikov compares more to Huberdeau.

 

[mammothCacti]

Him along with Zadina are the two best wingers that we've seen in a-while being ranked in the Top 5. I would say they should get the same hype as Patrick Laine, Nail Yakupov, Jonathan Drouin, Jonathan Huberdeau, and even Taylor Hall.

Did you forget about guys like Marner, Nylander, Ehlers? Ya know Marner had higher ppg than all of them in the O right?

 

[LEAFANFORLIFE23]

IMO, he's the best winger prospect since Yakupov/Hall. Last year, he would have been a toss-up for first overall.

Yak was a total bust, being the most since Yak is not a high bar

 

[Lays]

He would’ve easily gone 1st last year, I like him much more than I did Pulju in his draft year.

 

[StatisticsAddict99]

Did you forget about guys like Marner, Nylander, Ehlers? Ya know Marner had higher ppg than all of them in the O right?

Shiny new toys, though I do think Marner was still up in air with the C/W thing...

 

[Castle8130]

Probably somewhere between Pujl and Laine in that comparison. Would say svechnikov will be a goal scoring winger and dynamic offensive player, but doesn't completely dominate play. Someone that dominates on the pp, but at 5v5 he won't be a possession kind of guy.

his high:
40 goals 41 assists

his low:
25 goals 25 assists

Those are his career high seasons.

 

[mammothCacti]

Shiny new toys, though I do think Marner was still up in air with the C/W thing...

Oh that is true, both Mitch and Will at least were labeled as C/W.

 

[mouser]

Yak was a total bust, being the most since Yak is not a high bar

I’m guessing you didn’t take the time to read and think about the thread topic.

 

[ponder]

IMO Laine and Hall were better prospects, but he’s still top notch. Similar level to Marner, Pulju, Drouin, Yak, Landeskog, Huberdeau. Most drafts Svechnikov wouldn’t go 1st overall - I expect him to go in the 2-5 range in 2018, and if he was in a draft with a top notch centre prospect, he wouldn’t go ahead of them. In contrast, Hall and Laine go 1st overall in the majority of drafts (Laine only went 2nd because Matthews was an exceptionally good prospect, and Hall went 1st over Seguin, who seemed like a likely franchise centre).

I think Svechnikov is the top winger prospect in the 2018 draft, but it’s close. Zadina and Tkachuk are both very good too, both have a shot to go ahead of him.

 

[BB88]

Didn't take long to forget the draft season Laine had.

 

[93LEAFS]

Behind Hall and likely Laine. Svechnikov I’d consider on par or in the same tier with Marner, Puljujarvi and Drouin. I’d put Zadina and Tkachuk slightly behind them.

 

[ViktorBaeArvidsson]

As prospects(keep in mind this is how they where deemed pre-draft and not at some of they’re current development paces)...


League Altering Elite Winger Prospects:
______________

Ovechkin

Franchise Elite Winger Prospects:
_____________

Yakupov, Hall, Laine(maybe I was a little high on him as a Jets fan about to pick him but his international status and Playoff/Tournament success as a prospect was better than both Hall and Yakupov, with scouts knowing well that Laine had the best shot since Ovi)


High End Elite Winger Prospects:
_____________

Drouin, Svechnikov, Puljujarvi

Elite Winger Prospects:
______________

Tkachuk, Zadina, Huberdeau, Ehlers, Nylander etc...

High End Top Line Winger Prospect:
______________

Connor, Boeser, Rantanen, Tippett, etc..

Did you forget about guys like Marner, Nylander, Ehlers? Ya know Marner had higher ppg than all of them in the O right?

Terribly sorry for just coming up with a few off my head. You two must of completely missed the point of my post LOL.

 

[Scorcho]

Yak was a total bust, being the most since Yak is not a high bar

Do you not remember the hype surrounding nail tho?

don't be a revisionist.

 

[The Winter Soldier]

Not as high as Laine. Laine's stock only truly started to rise after the WJC, then after the Liiga playoffs he really took off until he reached his high point after being named best fwd at the world's.

Svechnikov never got that bump after the WJC. He's a terrific prospect and talent though. IMO he could go anywhere from #2-#5

 

[FlyTimmo]

Laine
Yakupov
Svechnikov/Drouin
Pool Party/Zadina

 

[ijuka]

He's not even close to Laine.

Really... I think he's somewhat overrated.

 

[Teemu]

Do you not remember the hype surrounding nail tho?

don't be a revisionist.

Yeah, but Nail was a bit like Nolan Patrick last year. Insane hype from the D-1, but didn't quite replicate that level of production in the draft year. Svech has had the better draft year so far, and still had an excellent D-1. There would definitely at least be a lively debate if they were the same year.

 

[93LEAFS]

Do you not remember the hype surrounding nail tho?

don't be a revisionist.

Yak wasn’t viewed as on par with Hall who was prior. What happened with him, was he had an amazing d-1 with a healthy Galchenyuk, and a very good draft year but didn’t live up to prior hype. Yak held on to his spot more due to attrition, two of his strong challengers suffered pretty much season long injuries before November (Galchenyuk and Rielly), Ryan Murray missed a good 1/4 of the year and Grigorenkos stock just imploded in the playoffs. He didn’t really rise above the competition as much as the competition never emerged. The best players who didn’t face injury problems that year were Forsberg (have no idea what happened to his stock), Dumba, Griffin Reinhart and Trouba.

 

[StatisticsAddict99]

Terribly sorry for just coming up with a few off my head. You two must of completely missed the point of my post LOL.

Me? I did exactly what the thread post says....

 

[lakai17]

Zadina could have gone #1 last year.

 

[X66]

He's not even close to Laine.

Really... I think he's somewhat overrated.

Wouldn't surprise me in the least though if he has more impact to the game than Laine because he has the elite speed and line driving ability that Laine doesn't.

Averaging almost a goal per game as a 17 year-old OHL rookie is damn impressive.

Both are high-end wingers.

 

[qwerty]

There’s a lot of conflicting reports I’ve read. I keep reading that this draft is strong, but then I’ve read that scouts have called it a really weak draft, so which is it?

 

[Frk It]

Best winger prospect since Hall, IMO.

 

[93LEAFS]

There’s a lot of conflicting reports I’ve read. I keep reading that this draft is strong, but then I’ve read that scouts have called it a really weak draft, so which is it?

Average.

 

[SPF6ty9]

I'd have him over Yakupov and not because of the benefit of hindsight. Yakupov was the probable first overall but not clear cut in a weak draft. If Svechnikov were in that draft I think he goes before Yakupov. Best since Hall.