Value of: Rielly for another D 1-for-1 swap?

[schenneuf]

Leafs need a shakeup on D, will move Rielly strictly in a 1-for-1 package. D for D.

What do ya got?

Click to read more...

 

[Leafs87]

Nooooo

No was too short

 

[AvroArrow]

Dude. We are in year 2 of our rebuild. This does not need to happen. We are not contenders, we will not be trading core pieces to help this team compete immediately. Rielly isn't the problem.

 

[Hunter368]

Don't listen to Schenneuf...universally mocked on the Leafs board for a reason.

OK, let his own fellow leaf fans criticise the OP

Not even a leaf fan, trading Reilly a very bad idea. So many rookies on your team (like jets) bound to have some bad defensive nights.

 

[Prairie Habs]

Dude. We are in year 2 of our rebuild. This does not need to happen. We are not contenders, we will not be trading core pieces to help this team compete immediately. Rielly isn't the problem.

Is this like reverse dog years or something?

 

[Rufus]

Seems like an overreaction

 

[Ropesman]

wow

Its no wonder leaf fans get such a bad rep on these boards.

Don't even know where to start with this one, so you know what.... I wont even.

 

[TheBeastCoast]

"Our defense sucks so lets trade one of our good defensemen! #logic"

 

[LeafGrief]

When Mike Babcock was talking about pain, he was talking to people like OP.

Chill the **** out, dawg.

 

[Ropesman]

When Mike Babcock was talking about pain, he was talking to people like OP.

Chill the **** out, dawg.

Haven't you heard??? This roster is clearly a contender for a wild card spot!!

 

[Jyrki Lumme]

I don't think Rielly is all he's cracked up to be and I don't think he'll ever be a complete #1 d-man. But we should value him for what he is and recognize he can be a really good top pairing d-man if he's given proper defensive support beside him.

 

[Kent Nilsson]

wow

Its no wonder leaf fans get such a bad rep on these boards.

Don't even know where to start with this one, so you know what.... I wont even.

HF doesnt have a problem with the few leaf fans who acknowledge that not all their 20y/o kids are future HOFers.

 

[AvroArrow]

Is this like reverse dog years or something?

No it's common knowledge. Not so common i guess.

 

[dubey]

OP thinks we can get Drew Doughty for Rielly

 

[MakeTheGoalsLarger]

op is the first Leaf fan to leave tank mode.

 

[schenneuf]

You can see the pain in the other Leafs fans eyes. I didnt say trade Rielly for a 30 year old. I didnt say I want playoffs.

I simply think Rielly is overrated and wanted to see what other teams would offer? Looking for a similarly talented D of about the same age in return.

I am a pragmatic Leaf fan and they tend to get chastised for not being homers.

 

[dubey]

You can see the pain in the other Leafs fans eyes. I didnt say trade Rielly for a 30 year old. I didnt say I want playoffs.

I simply think Rielly is overrated and wanted to see what other teams would offer? Looking for a similarly talented D of about the same age in return.

I am a pragmatic Leaf fan and they tend to get chastised for not being homers.

Oh so a NHL 17 trade

Who else has a OVR the same as Rielly, guys? Not looking for anything in particular just the same player, same age, etc

 

[LilySmoov]

I'd probably do it for Trouba.

 

[garyturner3]

Leafs need a shakeup on D, so lets trade our best D? What's happening now is all expected and part of the rebuild; have some patience man!

 

[TheBeastCoast]

You can see the pain in the other Leafs fans eyes. I didnt say trade Rielly for a 30 year old. I didnt say I want playoffs.

I simply think Rielly is overrated and wanted to see what other teams would offer? Looking for a similarly talented D of about the same age in return.

I am a pragmatic Leaf fan and they tend to get chastised for not being homers.

Again how does trading Rielly solve the problem....when we need more good defensemen not just swap a good one for a good one lol

 

[LV*]

OP thinks we can get Drew Doughty for Rielly

this

anyone you get for Rielly won't be a superstar on the Leafs yet.............. cmon man ****

 

[schenneuf]

Oh so a NHL 17 trade

Who else has a OVR the same as Rielly, guys? Not looking for anything in particular just the same player, same age, etc

Haven't bought an NHL game since NHL 94. I did pick up Titanfall 2 on Friday though.

 

[kihei]

This reminds me of the Gump Worsley story when he played goal for the Rangers. When asked which team gave him the most trouble, Gump instantaneously responded, "The New York Rangers." Which fans make the worst Leaf trade proposals? Leaf fans.

 

[schenneuf]

I'd probably do it for Trouba.

Id do that assuming he re-signs long term.

 

[Ropesman]

Id do that assuming he re-signs long term.

I wouldn't.

Considering the one time they played on the same team Moe played first pairing mins and Trouba was a healthy scratch, I would say we have the better D man ATM.