Report cards so far?

[Paul4587]

Relative to expectations:
Getzlaf 4/10
Rakell 2/10
Comtois 10/10
Henrique 5/10
Silfverberg 8/10
Cogliano 3/10
Kesler 6/10
Sherwood 8/10
Lundestrom 7/10
Steel 4/10
Terry 2/10
Gibbons 3/10
Rowney 4/10
Aberg 3/10

Lindholm 5/10
Montour 2/10
Fowler 2/10
Manson 2/10
Pettersson 1/10
Schenn 5/10
Sustr 3/10

Gibson 15/10
Miller 8/10

Yeah outside of goaltending it’s been bad...

 

[maxbme]

Mostly relative to expectations. The more heinen Debrusk and krejci play together the higher I see them going. They have 2/3rds of a solid 3rd line but aren't clicking.

Bergeron 10
Pastrnak 10
Marchand 9
Heinen 7
Debrusk 7.5
Krejci 8
Bjork 6
Nordstrom 7
Backes 5
Donato 4
Acciari 4
Kuraly 5
Wagner 3

Chara 8
Carlo 8
McAvoy 7
Grzelcyk 7
Miller 6
Moore 6.5
Kampfer 5
Too early to say on vaakanainen and Lauzon but I've liked them both

Rask 5
Halak 8

 

[MMC]

Skaters 0/10
Gibson 10/10
Miller 8/10

 

[CP4]

Relative to expectations. 5/10 is meeting expectations.

Horvat: 8/10 (still trapped in his own end too often but has carried the team offensively since EP went down)
Boeser: 3/10 (coming off an injury, still doesn't look 100%)
Baertschi: 6/10
Pettersson: 10/10
Goldobin: 5/10 (Looking good but struggling to produce without EP)
Eriksson: 1/10 (Decent PKing and defensive play but overall efffort level and offensive ability is lacking)
Sutter: 5/10
Virtanen: 5/10 (Decent to good defensively. Still not much of a threat offensively)
Leipsic: 2/10 (unable to get in the lineup consistently after a pretty decent half season last year)
Schaller: 3/10 (Dime a dozen fourth liner. Started awful but has been better lately)
Beagle: 5/10 (Filled his role adequately so far)
Roussel: 4/10
Motte: 8/10 (Good motor, really exceeded expectations but has low upside)

Edler: 8/10 (eating major minutes against top lines)
Tanev: 8/10 (ditto)
Hutton: 7/10 (Has stepped up and played well in big minutes. Much more assertive than last year)
Gudbranson: 2/10 (Has fallen off even more than last year. Doesn't have the smarts or puck skills to be an NHLer)
MDZ: 1/10 (Garbage, frequent healthy scratch)
Stecher: 6/10 (Decent in limited minutes)
Pouliot: 5/10 (Not an NHL player but hasn't been too bad this year)

Markstrom: 8/10
Nilsson: 8/10

Goaltending has been stealing games and keeping the Canucks in games to allow for all of the Overtime and shootout victories.

I agree with all of this except for Gudbranson, I think he's been way better this year.

 

[WesMcCauley]

Buchnevich 7/10
Chytil 6.5/10
Fast 8/10
Hayes 3/10
Howden 10/10
Kreider 6/10
Lettieri 5/10
McLeod 6/10
Namestnikov 10/10
Spooner 0/10
Vesey 9/10
Zibanejad 10/10
Zuccarello 6.5/10

DeAngelo 10/10
McQuaid 7/10
Pionk 1/10
Shattenkirk 3/10
Skjei 8/10
Smith 7/10
Staal 3/10

Lundqvist 10/10
Georgiev 3/10

Namestnikov has been very mediocre. 5/10 imo.

Zuccarello deserves at least 7/10. He has 8 points in 10 games and is 2nd in scoring.

Kreider at least 7/10 imo as well. Been fantastic around the net and has 7 points in 10 games.

DeAngelo has been solid when he has played but not close to 10/10. 7/10 imo.

Howden 10/10? He has been good but i mean he hasnt been fantastic? 8/10 imo.

Buch has struggled at times. 6/10 imo

 

[780il]

Mcdavid 10/10
RNH 10/10
Rattie: 5/10
Lucic 6.5/10
Draisaitl 8/10
Yamamoto 5.5/10
Caggiula: 5/10
Rieder 6.5/10
Strome 5/10 (he’s playing well but can’t buy a point to save his life)
Chiasson 7/10
Brodziak 4/10
Puljujarvi 5/10
Kassian 1/10
Khaira 3.5/10

Klefbom 8/10
Larsson 7/10
Nurse 6/10
Bouchard 6/10
Gravel 5/10
Russell 6.5/10
Benning 1/10
Garrison 1/10

Talbot 7/10
Koskinen 8/10 (only 1gp)

 

[authentic]

I'd give Matthews an A for offense and a C- for defense so far.

 

[StrangeVision]

Panthers:

 

[ChaoticOrange]

Oil:

McDavid 10/10
RNH 10/10
Rattie: 5/10
Lucic 6/10
Draisaitl 6/10
Yamamoto 5/10
Caggiula: 4/10
Rieder 4/10
Strome 5/10 (he’s playing well but can’t buy a point to save his life
Chiasson 7/10
Brodziak 4/10
Puljujarvi 5/10
Kassian 2/10
Khaira 4/10

Klefbom 8/10
Larsson 7/10
Nurse 6/10
Bouchard 6/10
Gravel 5/10
Russell 4/10
Benning 2/10
Garrison 2/10

Talbot 3/10
Koskinen incomplete

I’m demoting Kassian to 1/10 and promoting Klefbom to 9/10.

 

[Bjornar Moxnes]

Gaudreau: 7/10
Monahan: 5/10
Lindholm: 9/10
Tkachuk: 9/10
Backlund: 7/10
Neal: 2/10
Bennett: 7/10
Frolik: 6/10
Czarnik: 7/10
Dube: 6/10
Ryan: 4/10
Jankowski: 4/10
Hathaway: 8/10

Giordano: 8/10
Brodie: 7/10
Hamonic: 9/10
Hanifin: 6/10
Valimaki: 8/10
Andersson: 7/10
Stone: 7/10

Smith: 1/10
Rittich: 9/10

 

[Trade]

Guentzel: 6/10
Hornqvist: 7/10 (has really found his spot on the third line.)
Cullen: 6/10 (lost a step, still great at PK and smart player)
Rust: 5/10 (played on basically every line on both wings.) once he settles in somewhere he’ll be fine
Sprong: 2/10 (usage aside, literally nothing he’s done has pointed to him being spoon fed more minutes. Earn your keep)
Kessel: 9/10
Geno: 10/10
Sid: 9/10
Letang: 10/10
Dumoulin: 8/10
Oleksiak: 6/10 scoring goals
JMFJ: 4/10
Maatta: 6/10
Simon: 6/10
Sheahan: 7/10
Brassard: 7/10

Murray: 7/10
Desmith: 8/10

 

[Al Lagoon]

Wilds - for those who have made an impression in their role
Dubnyk - A
Stalock - B+
SuTer - B+
Dumba - B+
Spurgeon - B
Brodin - B
Seeler - B
Pateryn - B-
Parise - A-
Zucker - B+
Granlund - B
Coyle - B
Foligno - B
Staal - B-
Fehr - B-
Koivu - B-
Greenway - C+
Niederreiter - C-
The rest - incomplete

 

[ujju2]

McDavid 10/10
RNH 10/10
Rattie: 5/10
Lucic 7/10
Draisaitl 7/10
Yamamoto 6/10
Caggiula: 6/10
Rieder 5/10
Strome 5/10
Chiasson 8/10
Brodziak 4/10
Puljujarvi 4/10
Kassian 2/10
Khaira 4/10

Klefbom 8/10
Larsson 8/10
Nurse 7/10
Bouchard 6/10
Gravel 5/10
Russell 6/10
Benning 1/10
Garrison 2/10

Talbot 7/10
Koskinen 8/10 (only one game played)

Coaching Staff 7/10 (actually surprised I agree with a lot of McLellan's decisions, and the team is playing well. Yawney seems to be paying dividends early, as our PK and defence look much better than last year. PP also statistically much better.)

 

[Bounces R Way]

Gaudreau - 7/10: Good, but not great. Taken some games off
Monahan - 5/10: Not good enough, plain and simple
Lindholm - 7/10: Scoring lots, very good in his own zone as well. Deserves a shot at 1C imo
Tkachuk - 5/10: Had some good games, had some not so good ones. Can be a LOT better
Backlund - 6/10: Snakebitten offensively, still doing well shutting down other team's top lines
Czarnik - 4/10: Fast, not much else so far. Been a healthy scratch a couple times
Bennett - 8/10: Really worked on being a catalyst, earning some more ice time. Still waiting on the points to come
Neal - 4/10: Has to start finishing his chances, stop taking bad penalties, and up his compete level. Lazy
Ryan - 5/10: Been OK I guess, pretty smart player. soft
Dube - 6,5/10: Also getting a lot of chances, very good on the forecheck and defensively
Jankowski - 4/10: Mostly just existing, too soft, sat a lot so far
Hathaway - 7/10: Scored two goals, hits everything, mucks it up. Doing exactly what he's supposed to
Frolik - 6/10: Been fine, has less of a role but is filling it well so far

Giordano - 7/10: Been pretty solid, just think he has another level
Brodie - 5/10: Has two good games, then two bad. Needs to step it up on the top pairing.
Hamonic - Been injured
Hanifin - 5/10: Like what I've seen for the most part with his skating and his physicality, definitely mistake prone
Andersson - 7/10: Very composed for a rookie, needs to work on his positioning and awareness but really promising player
Valimaki - 7/10: More or less exactly the same as Andersson, very happy with him so far
Prout - 4/10: Enjoying his popcorn, hope to not see much more of him

Smith - 3/10: Been bad so far, not as worried about him as most Flames fans are though. He'll bounce back
Rittich - 8/10: Has been the Flames best player every time he's started.. not really a good thing

Special teams - 4/10: Zero consistency

 

[Bank Shot]

McDavid is 11/10 you guys.

 

[DFC]

Based entirely on expectations:

Gourde: 9/10
Miller: 9/10
Johnson: 9/10
Point: 8/10
Callahan: 7/10
Joseph: 7/10
Killorn: 7/10
Cirelli: 7/10
Paquette: 7/10
Kucherov: 6/10
Stamkos: 5/10
Erne: 4/10
Palat: 3/10

McDonagh: 10/10 (I'd give him 11 if I could)
Stralman: 9/10
Hedman: 8/10
Coburn: 8/10
Girardi: 6/10
Sergachev: 5/10 (but rising)