Reinbacher is in the same tier of Jiricek and Nemec?

[KevSkillz4]

Do you think that Reinbacher is in the same tier of Jiricek and Nemec?

Click to read more...

 

[Sweetpotato]

Nemec yes, Jiricek no.

I don't see Reinbacher or Nemec having the offensive ceiling that Jiricek has.

 

[Wierzbowski426]

Nemec just had a phenomenal year in the ahl production wise with almost 0 power play time (where most of jiricek's points came from).

 

[OKR]

There is absolutely no way any of them have a full tier between them as of now, there is absolutely nothing to base that on.

 

[Royal Thunder]

Trying to decipher the difference between “tier above” and “tier ahead”

 

[Emerica]

Tier above, tier ahead

 

[Pavels Dog]

He's not a tier above but certainly a tier ahead.

 

[ricky0034]

Trying to decipher the difference between “tier above” and “tier ahead”

everyone in this years draft is a tier ahead of Jiricek and Nemec because it's the 2023 draft and they were in the 2022 draft

 

[Regal]

As above, so ahead

 

[JT3]

People will argue he's not based on Nemec and Jiricek's D+1's but as of their draft years he is absolutely in the same tier.

 

[BondraTime]

Nope

 

[ViD]

Jiricek

Nemec


Reinbacher

 

[Antiillafire]

Jiricek

Nemec


Reinbacher

Rainking in terms of being a powerplay merchant ?

 

[Nabrules]

people saying they’re not in the same tier is simply perplexing. He produced as good as the other 2 in their draft years in a substantially better league.

Nemec and Jircek were known commodities early in their draft years while Reinbacher came out of nowhere, so the other 2 are automatically put on a pedistal.

Very close between all 3.

 

[Garl]

Before answering make a mental experiment, imagine, Reinbacher is not from Austria but from Sweden or at least Finland or Czechia. Then, compare him to Jiricek and Nemec

 

[majormajor]

Same tier as draft prospects. Just looking at their skillsets it is all comparable. Reinbacher actually looks more NHL ready than Jiricek and Nemec did.

 

[GermanSpitfire]

Same tier. Last years draft was rather weak at the top, so I’d imagine he’d be fighting with those two.

 

[Canovin]

IMO Jiricek is the best player from that draft. Been saying this for 2 years now. Columbus got a very good one

 

[Favin]

Are Nemec and Jiricek even in the same tier? Nemec was a lot better in AHL this year.

Nemec


Jiricek
Reinbacher
ASP
Willander

 

[Kaiden Ghoul]

I had Nemec over Jiricek at the draft and still do, Reinbacher is in the same tiers as Jiricek

Jiricek better off.
Reinbacher better def.
Nemec will do it all

Nemec
Jiricek
Reinbscher

For now

Eventually i may very well put Reinbacher above Jiricek

 

[trick9]

Yes.

Reinbacher might be drafted lower than Nemec went, but this draft is also a much better around the top than last years. Where would Slafkovsky and Wright go in this draft? That's the competition for Nemec and Jiricek.

I'm not surprised about the results though. D's get criminally underrated during their draft seasons. Even though the top ones have much better hit % than top-10 forwards, for example. They take longer to develop than forwards. That's also why so many top D's take massive leaps in their D+1 and D+2 seasons compared to forwards. Jiricek and Nemec are just 2 of the most recent examples of this.

 

[BB88]

People will argue he's not based on Nemec and Jiricek's D+1's but as of their draft years he is absolutely in the same tier.

Would have he been in the talks for top3 pick last year?

 

[LemonSauceD]

Jiricek

Simashev/Nemec/Reinbacher

 

[JT3]

Would have he been in the talks for top3 pick last year?

My personal list last year was
Wright
Nemec
Cooley
Slaf
Jiricek
Gauther

He probably would have been in the mix with Cooley, Slaf, Jiricek I would say. As for NHL teams, I'm sure he would have been in the conversation, although whether or not he actually would have been drafted top 3 who knows. Maybe NJ would have liked him more than Nemec and taken him 2oa, hard to say.

 

[BB88]

My personal list last year was
Wright
Nemec
Cooley
Slaf
Jiricek
Gauther

He probably would have been in the mix with Cooley, Slaf, Jiricek I would say. As for NHL teams, I'm sure he would have been in the conversation, although whether or not he actually would have been drafted top 3 who knows. Maybe NJ would have liked him more than Nemec and taken him 2oa, hard to say.

I remember Jiricek and Nemec being neck and neck last year.

I don’t see how a Dman who could go around 10 would have been in the talk for 2nd overall last year.