Rank your TOP 10 Goalies in NHL?

[Makar Goes Fast]

this year so far, crawford deserves the vezina. yeah its early but holy lights out.

 

[ChiHawks10]

this year so far, crawford deserves the vezina. yeah its early but holy lights out.

I think his 5v5 save percentage is around .975 or .980

It's insane.

 

[Makar Goes Fast]

I think his 5v5 save percentage is around .975 or .980

It's insane.

usually its varly that is unbeatable in the avs blackhawks game.

we got a taste of our own medicine this year.

 

[piteus]

this year so far, crawford deserves the vezina. yeah its early but holy lights out.

There's not doubt he's in the conversation, but I haven't seen the other goalies enough to make that assessment. However, these awards have a tendency to be lifetime achievement awards. Perhaps, some of the writers will feel that way if Crow is still in range for the Vezina at the end of the year.

 

[sharks9]

There's not doubt he's in the conversation, but I haven't seen the other goalies enough to make that assessment. However, these awards have a tendency to be lifetime achievement awards. Perhaps, some of the writers will feel that way if Crow is still in range for the Vezina at the end of the year.

Keep in mind that it's the GMs that vote for the Vezina, not the writers.

 

[Subbaman]

I'll play.

1- Price
2- Holtby
3- Schneider
4- Crawford
5- Lundqvist
6- Bishop
7- Quick
8- Rask
9- Luongo
10- Dubnyk
HM: Varlamov, Talbot, Rinne, Bobrovsky

 

[Prairie Habs]

this year so far, crawford deserves the vezina. yeah its early but holy lights out.

8-0-0
1.63GAA
.953%

Apparently not lights out?

 

[SladeWilson23]

please tell me how that matters, exactly?

is Justin Abdelkader a better player than Phil Kessel?

and Schneider's numbers are better across the board then Quick

Quick and Schneider are a lot closer than you would think.

 

[Stud Muffin]

1.Price
2.Holtby
3.Schneider
4.Crawford
5.Bishop
6.Lundqvist
7.Rask
8.Bobrovsky
9.Talbot
10.Quick

 

[CloutierForVezina]

1. Price


2. Schneider
3. Holtby
4. Rask
5. Crawford


6. Lundqvist
7. Dubnyk
8. Quick
9. Bishop
10. Luongo

Bob is making a real case to fight his way back onto this list. Jones and Murray are close to breaking in, Gibson might be there in a year or two, Talbot is making a strong push to establish himself here as well.

 

[sandysan]

this year so far, crawford deserves the vezina. yeah its early but holy lights out.

Yeah niemi v2.0 never gets his tires pumped the way he deserves.

It is still early.

 

[Michel Beauchamp]

Price - The best of the best right now. The clear #1.

Rask - One "bad" season his entire career and his numbers were still better than most. From the start of his career his SV%, Quality starts are better than anyone in the NHL, i believe.

Schnieder/Holtby

False.

Not that it means anything, but Rask is at .639 while Schneider is at .642.

Why not check such a simple fact before misleading the Boards ?

PS: Same thing for save %.

Rask at .92455, Schneider at .92514.

 

[Makar Goes Fast]

8-0-0
1.63GAA
.953%

Apparently not lights out?

sorry i hurt your feelings and talked about another goalie other than price being good. thanks for implying something i never said.

 

[Shmuffalo]

1. Price
2A. Holtby
2B. Schneider
2C. Lundqvist
5A. Bishop
5B. Rask
7. Crawford
8. Dubnyk
9. Quick
10. Jones

HM: Luongo, Talbot, Bobrovsky

I agree with this.

 

[Bleeker]

- Price


- Schneider

- Holtby
- Rask
- Lundqvist
- Quick
- Crawford
- Bishop
- Luongo
- Bobrovsky

HM: Talbot, Rinne, Dubnyk, Fleury

 

[KrisLetAngry]

everyone has schneider ranked higher than quick, but he never starts for team USA....

Not to bag on him too much, but he is a little overrated imo.

Coaches are not perfect beings

 

[Nucker101]

everyone has schneider ranked higher than quick, but he never starts for team USA....

Not to bag on him too much, but he is a little overrated imo.

lol, he's closer to being #1 than #3.

 

[CHaracter79]

As a habs fan I gotta say

Price- top

Next level

Rask
Schneider

Best of the rest

(Holtby
Bishop
Crawford )

That's the order I would choose goalies in s fantasy draft

 

[TT1]

I agree with this.

Maybe if you're evaluating them based on their first 10 games of the season. There's no chance in hell that Dubnyk is a top 10 goalie, he's not better than Varlamov either.

 

[Maximus]

What about Craig Anderson?

Anderson hasn't been mentioned even once and yet his stats are pretty much as good from an all around perspective as the top 5 goalies in the league thus far as far as wins, GAA and Save %. Combine that with the fact he is dealing with the unfortunate stuff that is going with his wife and her cancer situation, it is absolutaly astonishing the year he is having and that not even one person other than me right now has mentioned how well he is performing thus far.

I realize he's not the "sexy" type goalie compared to others and he's on the oldersid but facts are fact fellas, at this point of the season, he's easily top 5 for me overall thus far let alone top 10 and I'm shocked not even one person has mentioned him.

Am I on an island here or there something I'm not seeing here? After the first 3-4 games of the year where even tho he won the games he played in, his stats have been as good as any goalie in the league not named Cary Price. Sorry fellas but some of y'all are missing the boat here on Anderson.

Heck, he's not even been mentioned in anyone's honorable mentions yet....shocking. The guy has been phenomenal so far. Time for some of y'all to start paying attention...lol

 

[AIexisLafreniereNYR]

My Hanke poo is falling

 

[piteus]

Yeah niemi v2.0 never gets his tires pumped the way he deserves.

It is still early.

With Scott Gomez Jr., and Antti Niemi v2.0 ... have the Hawks even won a game this year?

 

[Nucker101]

1. Price
2. Schneider
3. Holtby
4. Lundqvist
5. Rask
6. Quick
7. Crawford
8. Bishop
9. Luongo
10. Talbot/Jones

 

[Bleedred]

Dubnyk being on so many of these lists just further proves my point that when people make these lists, they base some of their picks on who has been hot for this season or one particular seasons. James Reimer might have been on a couple of these lists in the first month of last season.

I can't get behind Dubnyk being on a ''Top 10 goalies in the NHL'' list, unless we're talking a top 10 goalies in the NHL this season, which Dubnyk would be in the top 3 quite easily.

But Dubnyk has been an average goaltender for most of his career, with the propensity to have some meh or bad seasons and then some really good seasons as well.

There ain't no way in hell Dubnyk is one of the 10 best goaltenders in the NHL.

 

[Bleedred]

Quick and Schneider are a lot closer than you would think.

Hey Glenn, I know the zombie apocalypse began in 2010 and Schneider had only played 10 NHL games by that point, including 8 BRUTAL one's in 08-09. But in the real world, it's 2016 and I just don't think this is the case at all.

I would absolutely put Quick in the top 10, just probably on the lower end. As far as Dubnyk and Murray and some of these other names being ranked ahead of him, hell no. Murray has only played 37 games in the NHL, that's including 21 playoff games. I think we need a larger sample for him. Dubnyk has been an average goaltender for most of his career. He's having a hot start to this season and had a hot 14-15 season. He also had a terrible season just the year before that. He's not as bad as he was that year, nor as good as he's started this year or 14-15.

And LOL @ calling Crawford Niemi 2.0

Crawford has already had 3 seasons that were as good or better than Niemi's best season in the league. He was also much stronger in both of his cup runs than Niemi was in his. Niemi has also been one of the worst playoff goaltenders of the decade, while Crawford has been one of the best.