We sure went from gushing over having the best young goalie in the world to thinking signing him for 7% of the cap for 4 years is a disaster awfully quick
I don't think in a vacuum it's a disaster or even outside of it, more so I think they pretty much paid him around 7M for his two UFA years and there is not really anything in the pipeline to replace him in 4 year either. (which is why some are already suspecting the Rangers will draft goalies with their earlier picks next year)
To me that seems silly as there is no really great possible outcome from it unless they win the Cup over that time period.
No Cup
He is good and they pay him what for any UFA years beyond when he is age 29. 10M?
He is average, and they gave an average goalie 5.66M cap hit?
He is bad, and they gave a bad goalie 5.66M cap hit and then what, buy him out?
With a Cup(s) all if forgiven, and I am happy.
Detroit traded a 3rd and gave Nedeljkovic 3M for 2 years
The outcomes there
He is good and he gets a raise to 7M, maybe, down side he'll be a UFA and could leave. They drafted Cossa this draft and have several other goalie prospects both signed and on their reserve list.
He is average and they are happy with 3M for a couple years and will take it from there.
He is bad, and 3M becomes ~2M if he is demoted to the AHL and it's two years.
The difference between how two different organization operate is somewhat obvious. One has a long term plan, with contingencies, the other not so much.