Sather had a terrible first half of his tenure. If there was a time for him to be fired, it was after not making the playoffs for 4 straight seasons out of the gate. Since then, the team has made the playoffs every single season but one. Sather's free agent faux pas are widely publicized, but we've still made the playoffs despite all that, which is more than many teams can say.
Yeah, he traded Leetch and Graves. That was 10 years ago, I think we can finally move on. Sather certainly deserves criticism for many of his decisions, but the amount of vitriol directed towards the guy is a little over the top. Any good/smart organizational decision: "Gordie/Gorton to the rescue!!" Any poor/stupid organizational decision: "OMGZ SATHER WTF!" We're smarter than that.