Let me first start out by saying I think everyone did an amazing job and I think this is somewhat daunting, but having done soccer drafts with massive writeups I get it. I definitely read pretty much everything you all wrote as well. Also, I'm not as well versed on all things wrestling as many of you are. So that said and along with really cares what I think, don't take any of this the wrong way. Just some of my thoughts on the cards.
In general:
-Too many gimmick matches or stipulations, etc. Some worked for me, others did not. Some cards had way too many though.
-Looking at the picks, and maybe I'm thinking more Group A here, but looking at the picks during the draft I didn't see how some of these would come together. Some of you did an excellent job though and it really looks thought out. Very nicely done.
Chris Cutter's card:
-I think the pre-show is entirely unnecessary.
-"Kick the baby" contest is also unnecessary and would almost mean not getting a vote in my book.
-I think Cody Rhodes vs Dustin Rhodes/Goldust with Dusty as ref would have been more interesting. Maybe Cody going to "dashing" mode and Dustin going to Goldust afterwards and beating down on Dusty.
-Most of your matches made sense, though a bit of an underwhelming main event.
quoipourquoi's card:
-My problem, but I don't even know who is in your main event.
-I could see shuffling your opponents a bit. Rey vs Eddie in the Hell in a Cell would be interesting to me personally.
OMNISENS' card:
-Most of your matches made sense to me and I'm a bit perplexed you're not getting more credit for your card.
-Not sure HHH vs Warrior even needs to be a specialty match. 60 minutes is too long either way. I can't stand the Ultimate Warrior, but I could see this match being your main event really.
-I'd move Razor vs del Rio up the card some.
-I like your team on commentary.
GONGSHOWWILLY's card:
-Wow, a lot to like here with some excellent matches.
-I like your commentary team.
-I would take Debra out of the Main Event if you're going to have her in two matches.
-I'd split the TLC match into two matches. Jeff Hardy vs Shane in the TLC match and the other two in maybe a #1 contenders match.
-Tag Team title match is possibly the most interesting to me. Two of the very best ever (the Bulldogs are underrated on most lists I've seen).
HANDSOMEHOLLYWOOD's card:
-I get your two top matches not going for the obvious, but I'd probably go that way anyway.
Morozov's card:
-Well I have to hand it to you, a lot to like here starting with the name of the event. Haha, Chiraq is great and you've got some matches to go with that theme.
-Not sure you need MCMG in that tag match, but it doesn't kill it either.
-DDP vs Douglas should be moved up the card if you ask me.
-I get Saturn not being in the Flock, but don't get him with Pillman.
-IMO you don't use guys' best personas. Should have had Kidman and X-Pac instead of the other two if you ask me.
-I could see some mixing things up here. Orton, tagged the "legend killer" as you did, vs Savage. Punk vs... DDP and then Owen vs Douglas. Not saying it'd be better mind you.
-So many matches that make sense. Nicely done.
Natey's card:
-Pre-show is unnecessary for me. Old School vs New School match seems a bit like filler.
-Penalty Box match is a great idea.
-I'd move the women's match at least two spots down the card.
-I like that you included #1 Contender's matches, but perhaps too many?
EmperorEddy's card:
-For me personally your card is a real mixed bag.
-Main Event is probably the best in this group by a ways.
-I'd definitely move the women's match down at least two spots.
-Like the tag team match, but unsure how the titles would work here. Also, if Bullet Club has taken over they're feuding with New Day?
-Retirement match is a great idea as someone else noted. Final match for two great teams. Better yet this would have been the tag team title match. Imagine the loser losing the belts along with having to retire.
-Pre-show does little for me. I can't stand either The Natural Disasters or Demolition. IMO Demolition are the most overrated tag team of all time. However that Bullet Club vs Sanity match isn't bad and I'd have just put it on the card.
HABSRULE's card:
-Hmmm. A lot to work with here, but I'd have shuffled the deck.
-I don't understand how the Lesnar-RVD match works. Feel like something is mis-explained there.
-Jake vs Kane would have been kinda cool. Damien actually bites Kane and then Jake hits the DDT?
-Then maybe Lesnar vs Yokozuna. Could Lesnar F5 Yokozuna?
-The Rock vs Rude.
-Balor vs RVD.
-Lita and Rude are together and make a rated R scene in the middle of the ring. Rock comes out and shames her.
-Kane-Balor is probably the match I'd keep. Just don't like the finish, but very interesting otherwise and very well thought out.
nameless1's card:
-All I can say is TLDR. Seriously though...
-The weekend?
-A bit confusing. Factions should have been spelled out at the very beginning.
-Some matches are great, others a bit too much.
-Too big a roster with too many matches.
-I love that there are factions and they seem to make some sense.
-I think you should have gone after the Wyatt/IRS angle a bit more.
