Value of: Pysyk to Edmonton

[ConnorMcNugesaitl]

A upgrade to our top 4 RD
2019 2nd or 3rd round picks
A goalie capable of 50+ games

I'd do a 2019 2nd for Pysyk + 4th/ C level prospect

Or Bear + one of your 3rd round picks.

Benning + a 3rd is a possibility.

I'd do Benning and a 3rd, not interested in the others.

I think Benning can still turn it around but a fresh start might help.

 

[780il]

Oh ya....? How about now?!?

Ultimately, I'd ask for Bear + Maksimov + 2019 3rd for Pysyk + 2019 4th

Feel Bear is worth a 3rd, Maksimov is worth a 4th, combined with the 3rd, it's a late 2nd and Pysyk + 4th is equal to it. I know they may hold more sentimental value for you but feel it's a fair deal considering Pysyk has 2 years left @ $2.7 million and is good for 16-18pts a year while being a really durable low end top 4 RD.

Deal or no deal?

Thats a no from me boss


I'd do the Benning + Safin + Pick deal but leave my Ethan Bear alone

 

[TheImpatientPanther]

I'd do Benning and a 3rd, not interested in the others.

I think Benning can still turn it around but a fresh start might help.

Thats a no from me boss


I'd do the Benning + Safin + Pick deal but leave my Ethan Bear alone

Benning doesn't interest me much. Feel we have the same player in Petrovic already and most Panther fans love Weegar who plays a good physical game and has top 4 RD potential in him if he can keep progressing.

No deal to be made here. All good, no worries.

 

[Dr Quincy]

Don't think Florida can afford to trade Pysyk without getting a good dman back

I think they can. They'd rather move Petrovic but Yandle, Ekblad, Matheson, Petrovic, Kissevelich and Weegar are fine as a top 6 (well not fine, but really no worse than having Pysyk in there). The only problem is that FLA needs a starting goalie and secondary scoring, and I don't see EDM being able to fix either of those issues.

 

[TML1967]

Oh ya....? How about now?!?

Ultimately, I'd ask for Bear + Maksimov + 2019 3rd for Pysyk + 2019 4th

Feel Bear is worth a 3rd, Maksimov is worth a 4th, combined with the 3rd, it's a late 2nd and Pysyk + 4th is equal to it. I know they may hold more sentimental value for you but feel it's a fair deal considering Pysyk has 2 years left @ $2.7 million and is good for 16-18pts a year while being a really durable low end top 4 RD.

Deal or no deal?

If the cost is a 3+3+4 (value you give the prospects) I think the Leafs would outbid for Pysyk.

Justin Holl (#6/7 RHD to replace him for now) + Eemeli Rasanen (recent 2nd rounder, RHD D man) for Pysyk+4th?

 

[TheNumber4]

Pysyk isn't an offensive D man. Oilers biggest need is more offence form the back end. No way I give up on Bear for a stay at home type D man. We have those in spades already. Be patient with Bear to develop his defensive game, we already know he's got a rocket shot and smart snappy accurate passes,

 

[Drew311]

Bear isn't NHL regular yet.. Pysyk is.
Chia needs to make the playoffs this year if he wants to stay employed.
Bouchard allows EDM to trade Bear.

Ideally Oilers trade Benning+3rd instead

This is exactly the mentality that will continue to kill the franchise.

 

[belair]

This is exactly the mentality that will continue to kill the franchise.

If the past two off-seasons haven't been obvious enough--that isn't the mindset.

 

[ConnorMcNugesaitl]

This is exactly the mentality that will continue to kill the franchise.

That's been his mindset since he got here. He just sucks at his job hence the Reinhart deal and a bunch of shitty contract negotiations.

 

[IceManCat]

Psysk would get a third second round pick at most. I’ll deal him for a 2nd in a flash

 

[belair]

That's been his mindset since he got here. He just sucks at his job hence the Reinhart deal and a bunch of ****ty contract negotiations.

If making the team short-term competitive was the mindset, he would've bought at the deadline in 2017 and he would've added to the roster instead of shedding salary that off-season. The past two summers have been very passive by Peter Chiarelli. They've improved the prospect situation considerably and avoided making long-term commitments due to their current cap situation partially caused by those two guys eating up $21m of their cap.

The 'mindset' has been to let the core of that 2017 make up the ground that was lost last season.

 

[ChaoticOrange]

Psysk would get a third second round pick at most. I’ll deal him for a 2nd in a flash

I stand by my Benning+3rd+B prospect offer. I think it’s good value.

I’ll even do you a solid and give you the higher of our two thirds.

 

[tony d]

Would take a bit more than Bear to get Pysyk to Edmonton I think.