PORTLAND – The Portland Pirates are scheduled to open their regular season in less than six weeks, but whether they will ever play a game in the newly renovated Cumberland County Civic Center remains in serious doubt.
Has always been a toxic relationship, but Petrovek knows the Civic Center can't survive without his team as a regular tenant - that building has nothing else to offer.
PORTLAND – The Cumberland County Civic Center’s Board of Trustees met in executive session with its legal counsel for over three hours Wednesday to discuss its next steps regarding its main tenant, the Portland Pirates.
Certainly bad news to hear that their future in Portland may be in doubt. Hope their negotiations with the city restart with earnest and that they reach a longterm deal.
PORTLAND – The Cumberland County Civic Center’s Board of Trustees and owners of the Portland Pirates are staring down at a possible courtroom showdown over whether an agreement reached in April constitutes a binding lease agreement.
Chris Roy @Chris_MHJ 4h
@PortlandPirates have filed suit against Cumberland County. More expected from 2:15pm presser. #mesports #coyotes #ahl #nhl
Chris Roy @Chris_MHJ 57m
@PortlandPirates contend Apr. 17th lease agreement is binding agreement. Civic Center Trustees disagree. #mesports #Coyotes #ahl #nhl
Source: https://twitter.com/Chris_MHJ
Pirates, civic center may go to court over lease
To quote:
"The Cumberland County Civic Center's trustees and the owner of the Portland Pirates may be headed to court after failing to reach an agreement on a lease that would keep the American Hockey League team playing at the arena for at least five more years."
Source: http://www.pressherald.com/news/Civic-Center-board-takes-no-action-on-Pirates-lease.html?searchterm=portland+pirates+file+suit
So, this is pretty much messed up. If I've got this right, the team plans to play out of the Lewiston Colisee (4000 seater) to start the season while improvements are being made to the Civic Centre, with whom they dont even appear to have any signed agreements and in fact appear to be miles apart on reaching one? Indeed, the Trustee's of the Civic Centre stating that they'll just fill the dates over 13/14 with other events, and that even with the pre-existing agreement they lost money or just barely broke even anyway? So I guess like, why bother? My God. Poor Phoenix. Here there top farm club, well, I just dont know what to say. On the business side of the equation, if it wasnt for bad luck they wouldnt have any luck at all. I mean, theres just no way the Pirates make a cent playing out of the Androscoggin Bank Colisee, who I note on their website dont even have the Pirates schedule up.
So, this is pretty much messed up. If I've got this right, the team plans to play out of the Lewiston Colisee (4000 seater) to start the season while improvements are being made to the Civic Centre, with whom they dont even appear to have any signed agreements and in fact appear to be miles apart on reaching one? Indeed, the Trustee's of the Civic Centre stating that they'll just fill the dates over 13/14 with other events, and that even with the pre-existing agreement they lost money or just barely broke even anyway? So I guess like, why bother? My God. Poor Phoenix. Here there top farm club, well, I just dont know what to say. On the business side of the equation, if it wasnt for bad luck they wouldnt have any luck at all. I mean, theres just no way the Pirates make a cent playing out of the Androscoggin Bank Colisee, who I note on their website dont even have the Pirates schedule up.
From what I've read in earlier reports, K (and it's admittedly very little)...
The Pirates thought they had a lease agreement worked out earlier this year and the commission that controls the arena changed it at the last minute with a "take it or leave it" attitude.
The guys here who cover the Pirates probably have a better handle on this. Maybe they can fill in some details.??
PORTLAND – The Portland Pirates have filed a lawsuit against the Cumberland County Civic Center’s Board of Trustees over failed lease negotiations to play at the downtown arena.
So, this is pretty much messed up. If I've got this right, the team plans to play out of the Lewiston Colisee (4000 seater) to start the season while improvements are being made to the Civic Centre, with whom they dont even appear to have any signed agreements and in fact appear to be miles apart on reaching one? Indeed, the Trustee's of the Civic Centre stating that they'll just fill the dates over 13/14 with other events, and that even with the pre-existing agreement they lost money or just barely broke even anyway? So I guess like, why bother? My God. Poor Phoenix. Here there top farm club, well, I just dont know what to say. On the business side of the equation, if it wasnt for bad luck they wouldnt have any luck at all. I mean, theres just no way the Pirates make a cent playing out of the Androscoggin Bank Colisee, who I note on their website dont even have the Pirates schedule up.
“I think this was the only deal to be made at the end of the day and the question was, is it in the best interest of the county taxpayers to have this deal or not to have this deal. I think both parties worked extremely hard and if you look at the amount of work that went into this deal it was essentially the only deal to be made.”
A couple of FYI's.....
The Pirates website is down because they are building a brand new site.
Also, playing out of the Colisee in Lewiston wouldn't be a money loser, in fact, the Pirates are likely to make money because ownership now has a majority stake in the arena and they collect all the revenues from the building.
The Pirates contend that both sides came to an agreement back on April 17th and the trustees approved and signed the so-called lease agreement. Therefore, it’s an enforceable agreement in the state of Maine – most likely anywhere really – and the CCCC is now trying to use the liquor licensing issue as a way to getting a better deal.
I’ve read the complaint, request for injunction and affidavit from Petrovek and it’s compelling, but I’m not a lawyer and I haven’t read the briefs yet from the Civic Center so it’s difficult to weigh one over the other at the moment.
The CCCC contend that it’s nothing more than a resolution, a guide for further negotiations, and there was never a deal in place. They say it was only to allow them to further lease talks.
I’m calling bunk on that because in the time I’ve been dealing with the trustees and the Pirates they’ve never approved a set of talking points to keep taking. To further that point here is what Neal Pratt said in an April 18 article which I wrote.
http://mainehockeyjournal.com/2013/04/17/pirates-civic-center-come-to-terms-on-new-lease/
That certainly doesn’t sound like a resolution to me.
I’m not sure how the judge will rule… I suspect he might kick them both out of the courtroom for wasting his time and tell them to fight it out in the playground or he may force them to mediation of some sort, but I think both sides will get a deal done. It might not happen until Jan. and the Pirates may have to play the entire season in Lewiston, but as I said that’s not a doomsday problem because the team is likely to make more in Lewiston with fewer seats than in Portland.
The bottom line is the Civic Center needs a full-time tenant. These people who are appointed as trustees are a bunch of dinosaurs. Most of them eat dinner by 3pm and are in bed before Wheel of Fortune comes on. For the longest time they just had to deal with their little building and now because of the renovation they are forced into the real world of building management and they haven’t the first clue at what they are doing. They need the Pirates because the trustee’s just pick pocketed the county residents of $33M to renovate a building that isn’t going to attract one more event then they were already getting.
Another point…. Folks who think they’ll end up in another city. I’m not so sure on that. I won’t say it can’t happen, but you need to understand that we’re not just talking about an AHL franchise that would be for sale, but rather a lot of real estate, branding and copyrights/trademarks.
Huh? You say….
The AHL Pirates are only a piece of a much bigger conglomerate. Ownership also owns OA Sports Performance Center, which is a complex that houses MHG Ice Centre, OA Center for Orthopedics, Michael Phelps Swim Center and the offices for Octagon Olympics & Action Sports. It’s also the home of the Portland Junior Pirates and the practice facility of the AHL Pirates. They recently spent $3M to expand the rink, add office space, add locker space and make other improvements to the facility. The ownership group is also majority owner now in Firland Management which owns and operates the Colisee in Lewiston. The AHL Pirates is the engine that makes this work financially for the ownership group. Its brand power they’ve built in the marketplace. If they can’t play at the CCCC, it’s not necessarily that they moved to Adirondack or Houston or another city, but I suspect they’d play in Lewiston for the short-term while building a new 4,500 seat arena on property they own near MHG Ice Centre.
The number of seats is not important…. Petrovek has said they have a business model based on 3,250 fans attending each game. The model is based on corporate sponsors and the business community buying into what the Pirates are doing. So far, until this latest fiasco it was working.
Unfortunately MHG is still run by the same people as before
Ron Cain is essentially the one who financed the MHG work (who also owns a majority stake in the Pirates). Even if the team moved and he sold his portion, he makes out with a rink with some critically needed upgrades.