LSCII
Cup driven
I don't think Granlund costs anywhere close to that much. I think if a 1 year $6M contract was available to either of them, they'd already have signed. Just look at Toffoli. Evolving Wild is usually spot on with their contract projections. They had him at $6M/5 years. He had to settle for almost $2M less and only 4 years. Guys like Hoffman and Granlund are sitting around hoping that a miracle happens and the market recovers, but I don't think that happens. There's just not much money available and the teams that have it are the poorer teams in the league, so they're not going to want to spend even though they have the space.
Sure, the money will probably be less, but again, his last contract was $6.3 mill with a cap hit of $5.75 mill. While it may likely drop, I don't think he's going to be signing a $3 mill per yr deal. Players don't typically like to go backwards. You give TT as an example, but his cap hit was $4.6, and it only dropped to $4.25 per with his new deal. I get you want to talk about overall deal size and term, but I'm looking at the cap impact as this team doesn't have huge dollars to spend with their own RFAs to sign. If it came to giving Granlund a deal that's on par with something that Hoffman is getting, I take Hoffman because of the consistency.