Poll #1 McDavid-Eichel-Hanifin
- Thread starter Beerz
- Start date
Zman5778
Moderator
joshjull
Registered User
Husko
Registered User
I love Eichel. I'm really excited about the fact that we're likely to get him. I think he's amazing. Can't wait to have him on the team.
All that said, the answer is McDavid and it's not even close.
All that said, the answer is McDavid and it's not even close.
EichHart
Registered User
stokes84
Registered User
I want McDavid, obviously.
I'll be elated if we get eichel at #2, he'd be the #1 pick in almost any draft in the last 10 years (maybe 1 debatable).
If we end up in Hanifin/Kylington territory... I'm happy to get such high end players, but would always feel we missed out on a franchise changing opportunity.
I'll be elated if we get eichel at #2, he'd be the #1 pick in almost any draft in the last 10 years (maybe 1 debatable).
If we end up in Hanifin/Kylington territory... I'm happy to get such high end players, but would always feel we missed out on a franchise changing opportunity.
SamuraiArt
Balso Par Big John S
McDavid: Unquestionably the better player (to what extent is debatable - I've seen both arguments on HF). Also, like the Canadian angle on McDavid-Reinhart if simply because they (might) have more familiarity with each other and their playing styles.
Eichel: I'm already getting tired of seeing McDavid's mug. That's my big argument for Eichel and I can't be convinced it's not a valid one.
Eichel: I'm already getting tired of seeing McDavid's mug. That's my big argument for Eichel and I can't be convinced it's not a valid one.
Look at how bad we are.
Look at the 80% chance the #1 team has of not winning the lottery.
I agree that "can't wait to have him on the team" is a little preemptive...but saying that getting him is likely is very realistic
stokes84
Registered User
It's most definitely questionable. These two are neck and neck. WJC is going to be wonderful. Can't wait for them to go head to head. McDavid might be destined to go no. 1 because of fear of not picking the chosen one, but that doesn't neccesarily make him the better player.
I snicker with glee each and every night we lose. I feel that this team will compete every night but lose mostly. When that time comes, I think McDavid is the answer. That kid is just not gonna fail. I have faith in Murray and Co. to thoroughly scout to make sure he's the best pick...but at this point we just know it - that whoever ends up with #1 is going to take McDavid, because of the hype. If we end up with Eichel I'll be ecstatic as well though.
cramdizzl
cram it
Husko
Registered User
I'd say Eichel is in that echelon.
McDavid is above it. He's the best prospect since Crosby. That's why it's not close.
FamilyGuy716
Registered User
buffalowing88
Registered User
This is a joke. Eichel is going to be a very good player down the road but McDavid is the best prospect the league has seen in years. I just don't understand the comparison. I'll be happy with either but I will be confident that the rebuild was a success if we get McDavid.
Both are the cherry on top of the rebuild, the difference between waiting three years to being competitive or next year having a chance to make the playoffs. That said McDavid brings a crazy passing skill set that sets him a part. Still think Hanafin, if he pans out which is a little riskier at d, with our other defensemen could be something very special.
Old Navy Goat
Registered User
I actually prefer Eichel's playing style and think that his game will translate better to the NHL. McDavid's shot is mediocre so unless it improves he'll be a playmaker, which isn't a bad thing but Eichel can do both. I'd be happy with either of them and Hanifin as a consolation prize wouldn't be too bad either as he could be that elusive true #1 defenseman Buffalo hasn't ever had.
stokes84
Registered User
Eichel is on a 4 ppg pace through his first three college games. He is also the best prospect the league has seen in years. That's what people are not getting.
