Pick your favourite top 9

Pick your poison


  • Total voters
    29
  • Poll closed .

Sensinitis

Registered User
Aug 5, 2012
15,934
5,526
A
Perfetti-Stutzle-Batherson
Tkachuk-Norris-Duclair
Formenton-L.Brown-White

B
Tkachuk-Byfield-Batherson
Formenton-Norris-Raymond
Balcers-L.Brown-Duclair

C
Perfetti-Byfield-Duclair
Tkachuk-Norris-Batherson
Formenton-White-C.Brown

D
Formenton-Stutzle-Batherson
Tkachuk-Norris-Holtz/Quinn
Balcers-White-Duclair


Please justify your choice:thumbu:
 

KnuckChuckinTkachuk

Give'yer balls a tug
Jan 23, 2011
2,101
966
D. Stutzle and Holtz please except I'd line them up as such:

Holtz-Stutzle-Batherson
Tkachuk-Norris- NYI 1st (Jarvis)
Formenton-Brown-Duclair
 

Xspyrit

DJ Dorion
Jun 29, 2008
30,846
9,784
Montreal, Canada
E- Other

Duclair-Stutzle-Raymond
Tkachuk-Norris-Batherson
Formenton-Brown-Pinto

And dat luxury 4th line :

Paul-White-Brown

Crazy that guys like Balcers, Abramov, Chlapik (maybe more) might have to be traded to get a regular NHL job

Tierney and all other vets will be gone too IMO, it's a matter of when
 
Last edited:

Answer

Registered User
Dec 17, 2006
6,970
1,432
Edmonton
Duclair - Byfield/Stutzle - Batherson
Tkachuk - Rossi - ??? / Abramov?
Formenton - Norris - White
 

NyQuil

Big F$&*in Q
Jan 5, 2005
95,680
59,903
Ottawa, ON
I like B.

I'd think Byfield and Tkachuk would be tough to play against the playoffs, and Raymond rides shotgun on that second line.
 

NyQuil

Big F$&*in Q
Jan 5, 2005
95,680
59,903
Ottawa, ON
E- Other

Duclair-Stutzle-Raymond
Tkachuk-Norris-Batherson
Formenton-Brown-Pinto

And dat luxury 4th line :

Paul-White-Brown

Crazy that guys like Balcers, Abramov, Chlapik (maybe more) might have to be traded to get a regular NHL job

Tierney and all other vets will be gone too IMO, it's a matter of when

I might have voted for this one if it were available.

I guess it means I have Raymond in that 2nd forward position - I'm still intrigued by Rossi though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Xspyrit

NyQuil

Big F$&*in Q
Jan 5, 2005
95,680
59,903
Ottawa, ON
Does the fact that Raymond is Swedish and has options to play professionally at home lessen his value?
 

aragorn

Do The Right Thing
Aug 8, 2004
28,570
9,083
Tkachuk - L. Brown - Batherson
Formenton - Byfield (#3) - Pinto
Cuylle (#52) - Norris - Dufour (#46)
Paul - Peterson (#53) - Trineev (#74)/Coe (#95)

Chabot - JBD
Sanderson (#5) - Schneider (#21)
Kleven (#33) - Hans (#64) / Prokop (#64)

Askarov (#10)
 

NyQuil

Big F$&*in Q
Jan 5, 2005
95,680
59,903
Ottawa, ON
Tkachuk - L. Brown - Batherson
Formenton - Byfield (#3) - Pinto
Cuylle (#52) - Norris - Dufour (#46)
Paul - Peterson (#53) - Trineev (#74)/Coe (#95)

Chabot - JBD
Sanderson (#5) - Schneider (#21)
Kleven (#33) - Hans (#64) / Prokop (#64)

Askarov (#10)

Oof, I respect you as a poster but this is basically the opposite of what I want to see.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ReginKarlssonLehner

Xspyrit

DJ Dorion
Jun 29, 2008
30,846
9,784
Montreal, Canada
Tkachuk - L. Brown - Batherson
Formenton - Byfield (#3) - Pinto
Cuylle (#52) - Norris - Dufour (#46)
Paul - Peterson (#53) - Trineev (#74)/Coe (#95)

Chabot - JBD
Sanderson (#5) - Schneider (#21)
Kleven (#33) - Hans (#64) / Prokop (#64)

Askarov (#10)

I really doubt that 57% of the future Sens roster will be drafted this year. That you like it or not, guys like Brannstrom, Thomson and Wolanin will be part of it. Same for Duclair, Brown, Balcers, White, Abramov... They won't all be there down the road but a few of them will.

Also, not sure how you were able to get pick #10 and #21

And IMO, it would be a huge mistake to draft Sanderson #5 OA when you could get him at #10

Finally, this roster lacks scoring potential to become a true contender, would probably a playoff team but lacks another elite forward and offense from the D.
 

jhutter

Registered User
Dec 23, 2016
1,194
830
E- Other

Duclair-Stutzle-Raymond
Tkachuk-Norris-Batherson
Formenton-Brown-Pinto

And dat luxury 4th line :

Paul-White-Brown

Crazy that guys like Balcers, Abramov, Chlapik (maybe more) might have to be traded to get a regular NHL job

Tierney and all other vets will be gone too IMO, it's a matter of when

I don't find it particularly crazy that Chlapik might need to be traded to get a regular NHL job. He's a borderline NHL player, and Balcers and Abramov might be in the same category.
 

aragorn

Do The Right Thing
Aug 8, 2004
28,570
9,083
I really doubt that 57% of the future Sens roster will be drafted this year. That you like it or not, guys like Brannstrom, Thomson and Wolanin will be part of it. Same for Duclair, Brown, Balcers, White, Abramov... They won't all be there down the road but a few of them will.

Also, not sure how you were able to get pick #10 and #21

And IMO, it would be a huge mistake to draft Sanderson #5 OA when you could get him at #10

Finally, this roster lacks scoring potential to become a true contender, would probably a playoff team but lacks another elite forward and offense from the D.
Agreed, it will take a few yrs before a number of the guys on the roster now are moved out & some won't be re-signed. I expect a few to be moved out by next season's trade deadline too & a couple more could go at this yr's draft. #10 is a pick I would like to see them create a package to get & #21 is the NYI pick which as I understand could be moved up as high as #15, I think. Where do you have the NYI pick?

Most sites I have seen have Sanderson inside the top 10. Bob McKenzie has him at 8th, but said two NHL scouts have Sanderson at #3 ahead of Drysdale, so it's not unanimous. I wouldn't be surprised to see if Drysdale is picked 4th which could leave Ott to pick Sanderson 5th. Who knows which way Ott will go with this pick, D or forward?

I also expect that Ottawa will get at least one good player in the 2021 1st rd draft, right now I like two guys in the top 10 in Owen Power LD & Dylan Guenther RW. I expect that Ott should be able to move Tierny, Anisimov & Reilly at the TDL for picks & maybe one of Duclair or C. Brown for another 1st rd pick in 2021.

I also expect that a few prospects could be moved at some point. Ryan is another guy who is almost gone & I assume they will eventually try & move Zaitsev. They will also lose at least one player in the 2021 Seattle expansion draft, I expect there could be a few deals/trades around that day.

I don't see Balcers or Abramov as NHL players, at least not on this team & I think they only keep one of Brannstrom or Thomson & IMO it might be Thomson. I like Wolanin, but he's also 25 yrs old, how much longer does he have here with so many good young players coming? Of course, it won't all happen over night but over the course of the next 3 to 5 yrs IMO where this team replaces most of the players they have now.
 

ReginKarlssonLehner

Let's Win It All
May 3, 2010
40,764
11,060
Dubai Marina
I like B.

I'd think Byfield and Tkachuk would be tough to play against the playoffs, and Raymond rides shotgun on that second line.

Yup. 5 is freaking amazing. Has everything. Size, speed, strength, pure skill, grit, 2 way play. The only thing missing missing would be a pure shooter. That's where we'd exert our assets to try and trade up to get Quinn or even Holtz if he falls.
 

Bubba Pilks

Registered User
Jun 21, 2019
208
238
Mine is a little different.

Norris-Byfield-Batherson
Tkachuk-Rossi-Pinto
Formenton-Brown-Duclair

Tkatchuk-Rossi combo is something I've thought a lot about and they would be a nightmare to play against. Feel like their styles would mesh beautifully.

I also feel like Norris has top line upside.

Also hope for one of:

At 15:
Jarvis
Mercer
Gunler

At 21
Foerster
Bourque
Perrault

To fill up the RW Depth Chart
 

SensFactor

Registered User
Oct 25, 2008
11,003
6,175
Ottawa
E

Tkachuk-Byfield-Batherson(Strong AF, in your face, elite 1st line)
Duclair-Rossi-Quinn (Overload of skill) - (Trade Isles pick, and however many 2nds it takes to get Quinn at #10 if he drops there)
Formenton-Norris-C.Brown(Good luck dealing with this trio, 3rd pairing dmen)

You're welcome, Dorion.
This all day.
 
  • Like
Reactions: L'Aveuglette

Sensinitis

Registered User
Aug 5, 2012
15,934
5,526
Mine is a little different.

Norris-Byfield-Batherson
Tkachuk-Rossi-Pinto
Formenton-Brown-Duclair

Tkatchuk-Rossi combo is something I've thought a lot about and they would be a nightmare to play against. Feel like their styles would mesh beautifully.

I also feel like Norris has top line upside.

Also hope for one of:

At 15:
Jarvis
Mercer
Gunler

At 21
Foerster
Bourque
Perrault

To fill up the RW Depth Chart

Tkachuk-Rossi-Pinto is a nasty winner line nice find!
 

aragorn

Do The Right Thing
Aug 8, 2004
28,570
9,083
E- Other

Duclair-Stutzle-Raymond
Tkachuk-Norris-Batherson
Formenton-Brown-Pinto

And dat luxury 4th line :

Paul-White-Brown

Crazy that guys like Balcers, Abramov, Chlapik (maybe more) might have to be traded to get a regular NHL job

Tierney and all other vets will be gone too IMO, it's a matter of when
I see you're also getting rid of a number of guys currently on the roster & in the org. You have Duclair & C. Brown still on the roster but in your own words mentioned in another thread that Ottawa could have an entire team under 25 yrs old soon which btw was something EM said a yr or two ago.

There are a number of players in this org that IMO could be moved sooner rather than later & a few that could be moved later rather than sooner. Duclair & C. Brown are two players that could be moved later while the list of players who could be moved sooner are the UFAs & guys like Tierny, Reilly & Balcers. Anisimov & Nilsson could be moved by the TDL & given this pandemic I don't see a need for PD to re-sign Boro or Anderson.

Chlapik is another bubble guy who has been in the AHL for a few yrs & if he can't make the team this coming season could be another guy on his way out. I also think with the plethora of goalies that a goalie could be moved this yr as well, my guess Gustavsson in a package. A few more AHL guys I think don't have a future in Ottawa are Davidsson, Beaudin, Abramov, Alsing, Carcone & maybe Kelly. It might not all happen this yr but over the course of the next three yrs I expect that most of these guys should be gone. Zub is wait & see, Ryan could get moved before his contract expires or in the last yr & Zaitsev could be another guy moved later since he has a lot of term left. Ryan & Zaitsev could be bought out at some point too. Certainly interesting times.
 

Sens of Anarchy

Registered User
Jul 9, 2013
65,259
49,885
giphy.gif
 

Xspyrit

DJ Dorion
Jun 29, 2008
30,846
9,784
Montreal, Canada
Agreed, it will take a few yrs before a number of the guys on the roster now are moved out & some won't be re-signed. I expect a few to be moved out by next season's trade deadline too & a couple more could go at this yr's draft. #10 is a pick I would like to see them create a package to get & #21 is the NYI pick which as I understand could be moved up as high as #15, I think. Where do you have the NYI pick?

Most sites I have seen have Sanderson inside the top 10. Bob McKenzie has him at 8th, but said two NHL scouts have Sanderson at #3 ahead of Drysdale, so it's not unanimous. I wouldn't be surprised to see if Drysdale is picked 4th which could leave Ott to pick Sanderson 5th. Who knows which way Ott will go with this pick, D or forward?

I also expect that Ottawa will get at least one good player in the 2021 1st rd draft, right now I like two guys in the top 10 in Owen Power LD & Dylan Guenther RW. I expect that Ott should be able to move Tierny, Anisimov & Reilly at the TDL for picks & maybe one of Duclair or C. Brown for another 1st rd pick in 2021.

I also expect that a few prospects could be moved at some point. Ryan is another guy who is almost gone & I assume they will eventually try & move Zaitsev. They will also lose at least one player in the 2021 Seattle expansion draft, I expect there could be a few deals/trades around that day.

I don't see Balcers or Abramov as NHL players, at least not on this team & I think they only keep one of Brannstrom or Thomson & IMO it might be Thomson. I like Wolanin, but he's also 25 yrs old, how much longer does he have here with so many good young players coming? Of course, it won't all happen over night but over the course of the next 3 to 5 yrs IMO where this team replaces most of the players they have now.

I'm not sure what you are agreeing to as we are not saying the same thing at all... First, you know that the Sens picks won't look even close to what you suggested. Maybe Byfield but you'd be lucky (and happy) if another one becomes an Ottawa Senator, not to mention it would be shocking (and counter-productive IMO) to select Sanderson at #5 and Askarov at #10 (if the Sens manage to add that pick, which woud cost a pretty penny). Yes the Isles pick could be expected to be #21 (for now). You're right, it's possible that the Sens are high on Sanderson, and it's also possible that they go with 1 fwd and 1 D-man even though IMO they should go with the 2 BFA (2 Best Forwards Available)

Byfield (#3)
Sanderson (#5)
Askarov (#10)
Schneider (#21)
Dufour (#46)
Cuylle (#52)
Peterson (#53)
Hans (#64) / Prokop (#64)
Trineev (#74)
Coe (#95)
Kleven (#33)

I don't know which season was your suggested line-up but even if it's i 3-4 years, I really doubt 57% of the line-up will be including picks from this draft...

In your suggested line-up, I see that all of Duclair, Balcers, Connor Brown, Tierney, Chlapik, White and Hawryluk are gone but some of them will probably still be there and it's far from a garantee that all your picks will be more worthy of a roster spot.

Yes, Tierny, Ryan Anisimov & Reilly should be expected to be moved out in the near future, and even Zaitsev eventually. Also possible for Duclair and Connor Brown but they could kept as part of the future core going forward. We'll have to wait and see for that

At least, you have probably the 7 of the main young forwards in your line-up (Tkachuk, Batherson, Norris, Brown, Formenton, Pinto and Paul). I understand you're not high on the others not in your line-up but guys like White, Duclair, Brown, Balcers, Abramov, Hawryluk, Chlapik, Crookshank, Gruden, etc will also push to keep their spot or claim a spot. I wouldn't expect ALL OF THEM to fail or be traded. I really doubt all of those 2nd/3rd round picks in 2020 will beat them out to take their place in the future plans.

Same on defense, you have NONE of Brannstrom, Thomson, Wolanin, Zub, Alsing, Jaros, Lajoie and Guenette. You can be sure some of them will succeed. I really doubt all of them fail or get traded to leave space for those guys selected in your draft scenario...

Finally, regarding your last quote " Of course, it won't all happen over night but over the course of the next 3 to 5 yrs IMO where this team replaces most of the players they have now"

You're basically suggesting that the Sens REBUILD THE REBUILD? Sure, the line-up is far from a finished product but I don't think your suggested scenario is more realistic than having to see some of these players being part of the future plans, actually the opposite.
 
Last edited:

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad